I Read That New PE Parent Study And It Made Me Think Of My Kid’s Last Field Day
I was sitting in the car outside my 8-year-old’s piano lesson yesterday, killing time scrolling Facebook, when the study popped up. It wasn’t from some fancy education journal clickbait, just a local parent group sharing a new research paper from Michigan State that surveyed 1,200 U.S. elementary parents about what they actually think of PE. I’ve got 15 minutes before lesson ends, I thought, why not. I didn’t expect it to rattle around in my head this much, honestly.
The big takeaway that stuck out isn’t the “everyone thinks PE is important” part, which we all already know. No, the weird thing that stuck with me is the gap. 78% of parents surveyed said PE is just as important as math and reading for their kids’ long-term success. Almost 60% said it’s critical for managing kids’ stress and energy, way more than I expected. But only 32% said they’d ever even consider speaking up at a school board meeting if their district cut PE time. Less than a quarter had ever asked the school how much PE their kid actually gets each week. That hit me, because I’m one of the 75% who never asked. I just assumed my kid had PE four days a week. Turns out, it’s three. I found that out when I double checked the school website after reading the study, and I’ve had a kid there for three years. How did I not know that? I once got into a 20 minute text chain with another mom about how the school’s new cookie policy for class parties was too restrictive, but I’ve never once texted anyone about PE. That says everything, doesn’t it?
It made me remember last spring’s field day. I volunteered to man the obstacle course station, and I watched this whole thing go down. My son’s PE teacher pulled me aside halfway through, quiet, and said the district was talking about cutting one more PE period next year to make more time for state reading test prep. I nodded, said that sucks, and then a kid fell off the rope wall and scraped his knee and I had to go help, and I never thought about it again until that study popped up. That’s the gap, right? I know it sucks. I think it’s bad. But I didn’t do anything.
I’ve heard the same thing at pickup, over and over. Last month the PTA was talking about the possible cut, and I stood there holding my lukewarm coffee listening. One mom, her kid is in second grade and struggles with dyslexia, said “Look, I get it, but mine can barely read a paragraph out loud. Extra reading time is way more important than running around, honestly.” I get that. I really do. If my kid was that far behind, I’d probably be thinking the same thing. Another dad, his kid has ADHD, said that PE is the only reason his son can sit through homework at night without bouncing off the walls, but he just said that quiet to me, didn’t say it out loud to the whole group. He didn’t want to argue with the mom whose kid is struggling. I didn’t say anything either. I just stood there and agreed that it’s a hard situation, and that no one wants to pick between one kid’s needs and another’s.
I also get the parents who don’t love PE, honestly. I was that kid who was always last picked for kickball. I faked a stomach ache at least once a month to get out of PE in fifth grade. I hated every second of it, all the picking sides, all the people snickering when I tripped over my own feet. The study actually mentioned that, too – around 14% of parents said their kid has had a really negative PE experience, mostly bullying or feeling left out because they’re not good at sports, and that makes them way less likely to prioritize keeping PE time. My neighbor’s daughter has severe social anxiety, and she says PE is the worst part of her whole week, because they do all these team games and she has to stand around waiting to be picked. I can’t blame her for not being super fired up about protecting PE time. It’s not all fun and four square for everyone.
But my kid? He lives for PE. He comes home every day and tells me the entire drama of the four square games they play at the start of class – who called a do-over, who cheated, how he beat a sixth grader last week. Last month, they canceled PE because the gym was being used for state testing, and he came home, threw his backpack on the floor, ate his entire granola bar in two bites, and just moped on the couch for 45 minutes. He didn’t even want to play Minecraft. That’s how bummed he was. I remember thinking, when’s the last time he got that upset about missing a math period? Never.
The study also said that almost 40% of parents overestimate how much PE their kid gets. Most elementary schools in the U.S. only get 1 to 3 hours a week, which is way less than the CDC recommends, but most parents think it’s more like 4 or 5. I was exactly that. I had no clue. I think we just assume that PE is still a thing, that it’s on the schedule, so we don’t check. We’re too busy checking homework, signing permission slips, remembering to bring snacks for the class party. PE just fades into the background.
I’m supposed to go to the school board meeting next week, where they’re voting on that PE cut. I wrote it on my calendar. But I already know my older kid has a soccer game that starts right when the meeting does, so I’ll probably drop in for five minutes, say I don’t support the cut, and leave early before the vote. I don’t know if that matters. I don’t have a big, inspiring wrap-up here. The study didn’t give one, anyway. It just pointed out that we all say we care about kids moving, about their mental health, about them having a break from all the testing and homework, but when push comes to shove, most of us don’t do much. And I’m right there with the rest of them. I’m just sitting here thinking about my kid moping on the couch after missing PE, and wondering when I got so good at letting the important stuff slide, just because it’s easier. (Word count: 1182)
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Read That New PE Parent Study And It Made Me Think Of My Kid’s Last Field Day