I Thought I’d Cry When I First Met My Daughter. I Didn’t.
It was 36 hours of unplanned labor that ended in a last-minute c-section, and I’d eaten a greasy chorizo burrito from the gas station down the street at 2 a.m. when my wife’s contractions picked up. By the time the doctor said it was go time, my stomach was gurgling so loud I was convinced everyone in the room could hear it. The linoleum by the operating table was slippery from spilled antiseptic, and my cheap hospital socks kept sliding every time I leaned over to squeeze my wife’s hand. I’d rehearsed this moment a hundred times over nine months: I’d be steady, I’d cry the right amount, I’d say something soft and profound when they laid the baby on my chest. I even practiced blinking back fake tears in the car on the way to the hospital, just to make sure I didn’t look like a robot when the time came.
When they pulled her out, she was purple. Not the soft pink you see in movie delivery scenes, deep splotchy purple, covered in that waxy white stuff I can never remember the name of. The doctor was talking fast about suctioning her lungs, the nurse wiped her down in 10 quick motions, and all I could think was that her head was shaped like a lumpy little potato. I didn’t think that in a bad way, just that it was nothing like the round soft baby heads I’d seen in all the Instagram reels I’d binged while nesting. When they let me lean in again, all I could focus on was her left ear, folded over on itself like a crumpled origami napkin. I immediately started spiraling a little—was that broken? Would it be like that forever? Would she hate me one day for giving her a weird ear?
They asked me if I wanted to cut the cord, and I jumped so bad my elbow knocked over a half-full cup of water on the side table. I fumbled the scissors they handed me, my hands shaking so bad I couldn’t get the blade to close around the cord, and I nicked the blue sterile drape next to it. The nurse took the scissors back with a good-natured laugh and said “no worries, first timer right?” and I just nodded, my face hot enough to fry an egg.
When they wrapped her up and laid her on my chest a minute later, I waited for that rush everyone talks about. That instant “my heart is so full it’s gonna burst” feeling. I waited for the tears I’d practiced. I kept blinking, trying to squeeze something out, because I knew my wife was tired and looking at me, and I wanted her to see I felt the thing I was supposed to feel. Nothing. Just… relief. Relief that she had ten fingers, ten toes, that my wife was okay, that the 36 hours of walking the hospital hallway back and forth was over. That was it. No big explosion of love, no life-changing epiphany. Just relief, and a quiet, weird awkwardness, like I was holding a stranger’s baby at a grocery store and didn’t know when I could hand her back.
A couple hours later, they took her to the nursery to check her blood sugar—it was a little low, nothing to worry about, just standard. My wife fell asleep immediately, all doped up on pain meds, her hair stuck to her sweaty forehead, and I was left sitting in that terrible plastic chair by the bed that leans back too far but not far enough to nap. The TV was on some infomercial for a stand mixer that could knead bread in 90 seconds, and the hospital gave me a tiny paper cup of apple juice that had been sitting out so long it was warm, and it tasted exactly like the paper cup it came in. I texted my parents a blurry photo, replied to a handful of “congrats!!” texts from friends, and then I just sat there. I felt guilty. Guilty that I wasn’t over the moon. Guilty that I was more bored than anything, just sitting there waiting for something to happen. This was supposed to be the best day of my life, right? Why did it feel like I was just killing time at the DMV?
I’d heard other dads joke about feeling disconnected, but I always thought that was just people talking about post-baby blues, not the first five minutes of meeting your kid. I thought love was supposed to be instant.
It wasn’t that day. It wasn’t the next day, when we brought her home to our wobbly crib that we’d put together wrong. It was three nights later, I was up at 2 a.m. changing her diaper on that same wobbly changing table, and she peed straight up, all over my favorite old college hoodie. I jumped back, swore a little, and when I looked down at her, she grinned. Not the gas grin everyone tells you about, a real little open-mouthed grin right at me, and she wrapped her whole tiny hand around my thumb. That’s when it hit me. That stupid, overwhelming, can’t-breathe love that everyone talks about. It just didn’t show up in the delivery room, like it was supposed to.
She’s seven now. She just lost her two front teeth last week, she draws me terrible pictures of dinosaurs that have six legs, she steals my fries every time we get fast food. I still think about that first meeting sometimes, when I see all these new dads posting perfect hospital photos, captioned “my whole world started today” and all that. I used to lie a little when people asked me how it felt, say it was the most amazing moment of my life. Now I just tell the truth. It was messy. It was awkward. I was hungry, I was gassy, I was panicking about a folded ear that fixed itself in three days anyway, and I didn’t feel that big love everybody talks about for almost a week.
No one talks about that, I think. Everyone wants the movie moment. But most real moments aren’t like that. Love doesn’t have a timetable. It doesn’t show up exactly when the baby books say it will. Sometimes it hangs out in the hallway for a bit, waiting for all the noise and the pressure and the bad burritos to settle down. I still don’t have that perfect, heartwarming first meeting story to tell. I just have this one. And that’s enough, I guess.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Thought I’d Cry When I First Met My Daughter