When Feedback Feels Manipulative: Navigating Classroom Gaslighting
We’ve all been there: staring at a graded essay covered in red ink, stomach sinking as we try to make sense of harsh comments. But what happens when a teacher’s feedback leaves you questioning not just your writing skills, but your own perception of reality? Recently, a student shared a troubling experience: “I think my English teacher tried to gaslight my class after a horrible essay.” Let’s unpack what this might mean, how to recognize problematic behavior, and what students can do to advocate for themselves.
—
Understanding Gaslighting in Academic Contexts
Gaslighting—a term borrowed from a 1938 play—refers to manipulative tactics that make someone doubt their own memories, feelings, or judgment. In classrooms, this might look like a teacher dismissing valid concerns, rewriting past events (“I never said that!”), or reframing failures in ways that shift blame entirely onto students. For example, if an entire class struggles with an essay assignment, a gaslighting response could involve the teacher insisting, “You all misinterpreted the instructions,” even if the instructions were unclear.
The key question here: Was the teacher’s feedback constructive criticism meant to help students grow, or was it a deflection of responsibility that left the class feeling disoriented and insecure?
—
“Horrible Essays” and the Blame Game
Let’s imagine the scenario. A class submits essays they worked hard on, only to receive universally low grades. The teacher returns the papers with vague comments like, “This wasn’t at all what I asked for,” or “You should’ve known better.” When students point out that the assignment guidelines seemed contradictory, the teacher doubles down: “No one else had trouble understanding. This is entirely on you.”
This reaction raises red flags. A responsible educator would likely:
1. Acknowledge confusion: “I see some of my instructions weren’t clear. Let’s review them together.”
2. Offer solutions: Schedule a revision workshop or provide examples of strong essays.
3. Take accountability: “I’ll adjust future assignments to avoid this issue.”
Gaslighting, by contrast, avoids accountability. It shuts down dialogue and leaves students feeling isolated in their frustration.
—
How to Tell the Difference Between Criticism and Manipulation
Not all harsh feedback is gaslighting. Teachers should challenge students to improve, even if it feels uncomfortable. Here’s how to distinguish tough love from toxic behavior:
– Constructive criticism: Specific, actionable, and focused on the work (“Your thesis lacks focus—try narrowing it to one main argument”).
– Gaslighting: Vague, personalizing, and dismissive (“You clearly didn’t listen during my lectures”).
Another telltale sign? Patterns. A one-time miscommunication isn’t gaslighting. But if a teacher habitually denies their role in misunderstandings, mocks students’ confusion, or claims “Everyone else gets it except you,” that’s a problem.
—
Why Might a Teacher Gaslight a Class?
Educators are human, and some handle their own stress or insecurity poorly. A teacher might gaslight students to:
– Avoid admitting mistakes (e.g., unclear lesson plans).
– Maintain authority by making students doubt their own competence.
– Cover up burnout or unpreparedness (“If the class fails, it’s their fault, not mine”).
This doesn’t excuse the behavior, but understanding possible motives can help students navigate the situation calmly.
—
What Students Can Do: A Step-by-Step Guide
If you suspect gaslighting, here’s how to protect your confidence and seek resolution:
1. Document everything: Save assignments, rubrics, and emails. Note dates/times of confusing interactions.
2. Talk to classmates: Are others feeling the same way? Group concerns carry more weight.
3. Request clarity: Ask specific questions (“Can you explain which part of the essay didn’t meet expectations?”).
4. Escalate thoughtfully: If the teacher remains defensive, bring your evidence to a counselor, department head, or trusted administrator.
5. Practice self-validation: Remind yourself that confusion or mistakes don’t define your worth or intelligence.
—
The Bigger Picture: Building Healthier Student-Teacher Relationships
Open communication is the antidote to gaslighting. Teachers should create environments where questions are welcomed, not weaponized. Students, meanwhile, can advocate for themselves without assuming malice. For example:
– Instead of: “You gave us bad instructions!”
– Try: “I want to make sure I understand—could you rephrase the requirements for the next assignment?”
Most educators want their students to succeed. But when power dynamics tilt toward manipulation rather than mentorship, it’s okay to speak up.
—
Final Thoughts
Criticism is part of learning, but gaslighting has no place in education. If feedback leaves you feeling small, confused, or like your reality is being rewritten, trust your instincts. Gather evidence, seek support, and remember: A good teacher helps you grow with clarity and respect—not by making you doubt your own mind.
Whether this particular English teacher intended to gaslight or simply handled a bad situation poorly, the lesson here is universal: You deserve to understand where you stand, both in your essays and in your classroom. Don’t let anyone convince you otherwise.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Feedback Feels Manipulative: Navigating Classroom Gaslighting