Anyone Here Familiar with the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) Field?
Ever found yourself puzzling over a teaching challenge, tweaking an assignment, or wondering if that new activity really helped students learn? If you have, you might have been dipping your toes into the world of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, often called SoTL (pronounced “sottle”).
It sounds academic, maybe a bit intimidating. But at its heart, SoTL is something profoundly practical and increasingly vital in education at all levels. It’s essentially research about teaching. Think of it as educators stepping back from the daily grind of lesson planning and grading, putting on a researcher’s hat, and asking: “How does learning actually happen in my classroom? What works best? Why? And how can I share what I discover?”
SoTL Isn’t Just “Teaching Tips”
It’s easy to confuse SoTL with simply sharing good teaching practices. While sharing is a crucial outcome, SoTL is fundamentally about the process. It’s systematic inquiry. Imagine a biology professor designing a new lab activity. Instead of just hoping it works, they might:
1. Frame a Question: Does this structured group discussion protocol improve students’ ability to analyze complex primary sources compared to individual analysis?
2. Gather Evidence: They collect student work samples, survey students about their experience, perhaps even analyze video snippets of group interactions.
3. Analyze & Reflect: They look for patterns in the data. Did understanding improve? Did certain students benefit more? What challenges emerged?
4. Share Findings: They write up their process, evidence, and conclusions, perhaps presenting at a teaching conference or publishing in a SoTL-focused journal.
This moves teaching beyond a private act. It transforms classroom experiences into shared knowledge, subject to peer review and critique, just like research in any other discipline. The goal isn’t just to improve their own teaching, but to contribute to a collective understanding of effective learning.
Why Does SoTL Matter? (More Than You Might Think)
You might wonder, “Isn’t this just extra work for already busy teachers?” While it is work, the benefits ripple outwards:
Evidence-Based Improvement: SoTL moves teaching beyond anecdote, tradition, or fads. Decisions about pedagogy are grounded in actual data gathered from your students in your context.
Professionalizing Teaching: It elevates teaching from a craft to a scholarly activity. Engaging in SoTL demonstrates a deep commitment to understanding and enhancing the learning process, deserving of recognition alongside traditional research.
Bridging the Gap: It directly connects what happens in the classroom with broader educational theories. SoTL practitioners test theories in the messy, wonderful reality of actual classrooms.
Sharing & Scaling Impact: When findings are shared, one instructor’s experiment can benefit countless others. What works in an engineering lab might inspire innovations in a history seminar.
Student-Centered Focus: SoTL relentlessly asks: “What does this mean for student learning?” It keeps the spotlight firmly on the learners’ experiences and outcomes.
What Does SoTL Look Like in Practice? It’s Diverse!
SoTL isn’t one rigid method. It’s incredibly adaptable. You might find:
Disciplinary SoTL: A physics professor studying the impact of specific problem-solving tutorials on conceptual understanding of electromagnetism.
Cross-Disciplinary SoTL: An art historian and a biologist collaborating to explore how visual analysis skills developed in art courses transfer to interpreting scientific diagrams.
Institutional SoTL: Investigating the effectiveness of a new university-wide writing center initiative on student writing proficiency across different majors.
Focus on Specific Challenges: Researching interventions to reduce student assessment anxiety in online courses or exploring the impact of specific feedback strategies on student revision.
Methods can range from analyzing student work and exam scores, to conducting surveys and focus groups, to classroom observations and even educational data mining. The key is the systematic, intentional inquiry into teaching and learning phenomena.
How Does SoTL Change the Classroom?
The ultimate test is impact. Engaging in SoTL often leads to concrete shifts:
Revised Assignments: Discovering that traditional essays weren’t revealing deep understanding might lead to designing authentic projects or portfolios.
Different Activities: Evidence showing passive lectures led to poor retention could spur the adoption of active learning techniques like think-pair-share or case studies.
Assessment Overhaul: Realizing exams only measured recall might inspire more formative assessments and competency-based evaluations.
Improved Feedback: Research into how students use feedback might lead to more targeted, dialogic feedback practices.
Technology Integration: Investigating the learning impact of a specific simulation or online discussion tool informs smarter tech choices.
For instance, a professor might use SoTL to explore a flipped classroom model. They’d collect data on student preparation, engagement in class activities, and learning outcomes compared to previous semesters. The findings wouldn’t just tell them if the flip “worked” for them; they could reveal why and for whom, informing others considering similar changes.
Getting Started: You Don’t Need a PhD in Education
Feeling intrigued? The beauty of SoTL is its accessibility. You don’t need to be a full-time education researcher. Start small:
1. Identify a Puzzle: What’s one thing about your students’ learning that genuinely puzzles or intrigues you? (e.g., “Why do they consistently struggle with concept X?”, “Does this new tech tool actually save time or improve outcomes?”, “How can I get more meaningful participation in discussions?”).
2. Explore Existing Knowledge: See what others have found on similar topics. Check out journals like Teaching & Learning Inquiry, The International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, or discipline-specific pedagogical journals. Your campus teaching center is also a goldmine.
3. Design a Tiny Inquiry: How could you gather some evidence? Compare two sections? Analyze responses to a specific question? Do a quick mid-semester feedback survey focused on one aspect?
4. Reflect & Share: Talk about your process and preliminary findings with colleagues over coffee. Write a short blog post for a campus teaching site. Present a poster at a local teaching conference.
The SoTL community is generally welcoming and supportive, understanding that everyone starts somewhere. It’s about a mindset of curiosity and continuous improvement, not perfection.
So… Anyone Familiar with SoTL?
If you weren’t sure before, hopefully now you’ve got a clearer picture. The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning is about educators taking their craft seriously enough to study it. It’s about moving from “I think this works” to “Here’s what the evidence suggests about what works, for whom, and why, in my context.”
It transforms teaching from a solitary endeavor into a collaborative, evidence-informed profession. It honors the complexity of learning and empowers educators to be not just practitioners, but scholarly architects of meaningful educational experiences. Whether you’re a seasoned professor or just beginning your teaching journey, SoTL offers pathways to deepen your impact and contribute to a richer understanding of how we all learn best. So next time you tweak a lesson or wonder about a student’s progress, you might just be stepping onto the path of SoTL yourself. Why not explore it a little further? The conversation is happening, and your perspective is valuable. Let’s keep learning about learning, together.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Anyone Here Familiar with the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) Field