When Preschoolers Get Sent Home: Understanding the Complex Issue of Early Childhood Expulsion
Imagine a four-year-old being asked to leave preschool because they hit a classmate during playtime or threw a tantrum during circle time. It sounds extreme, but preschool expulsion—yes, even for children barely out of diapers—is a reality in many communities. Recent studies reveal startling trends about how and why young children are removed from early education settings, raising urgent questions about equity, support systems, and the long-term impact on kids.
The Hidden Crisis in Early Education
Preschool is often seen as a safe space for children to learn social skills, build friendships, and prepare for kindergarten. However, research led by experts like Walter Gilliam at Yale University shows that expulsion rates in early childhood programs are shockingly high. In the U.S., preschoolers are expelled at three times the rate of K–12 students. Even more concerning? Racial disparities persist, with Black boys facing the highest risk of expulsion despite representing a small percentage of enrolled children.
Why does this happen? Teachers and caregivers often point to “challenging behaviors”—aggression, defiance, or emotional outbursts. But dig deeper, and the issue isn’t just about the child. Overwhelmed staff, inadequate training, and systemic inequities play significant roles. A classroom with too many students, too few resources, and educators unprepared to address trauma or developmental differences creates a perfect storm.
The Ripple Effects of Removing a Child
Expelling a preschooler isn’t just a logistical decision; it’s a life-altering one. Studies link early expulsion to negative outcomes: children who are removed from preschool are more likely to struggle academically, face repeated discipline in later grades, and even encounter legal system involvement as teens. For families, the fallout is equally harsh. Parents may feel judged or blamed, scrambling to find alternative care while balancing work obligations.
Dr. Shantel Meek, a childhood development expert, emphasizes that expulsion often reflects a broken system, not a “bad kid.” “Young children test boundaries—it’s how they learn,” she explains. “When adults respond by removing them, we miss opportunities to teach self-regulation and problem-solving.”
Why Can’t Teachers “Handle” the Behavior?
Critics might ask: Why can’t preschool staff manage these situations? The answer lies in systemic underinvestment. Many early childhood educators work in underfunded programs with low pay, high turnover, and minimal access to behavioral specialists. A teacher juggling 20 preschoolers alone can’t realistically address each child’s needs, especially if those needs stem from trauma, disabilities, or language barriers.
Training gaps also matter. Few states require preschool teachers to learn about trauma-informed care or culturally responsive practices. Without these tools, even well-meaning educators may misinterpret behaviors. For example, a child who avoids eye contact might be labeled “disrespectful” rather than recognized as shy or neurodivergent.
Solutions That Start with Support, Not Punishment
Change is possible—and already happening in some regions. States like Illinois and Colorado have banned expulsion in state-funded preschools, redirecting resources toward mentorship programs and teacher coaching. These initiatives focus on prevention: training staff to de-escalate conflicts, partnering with families, and creating individualized behavior plans.
One successful model is the Pyramid Model, a framework used in thousands of classrooms nationwide. Instead of punishing kids for outbursts, teachers proactively build social-emotional skills through play, storytelling, and clear routines. When challenges arise, they collaborate with parents and specialists to address root causes. In Chicago, preschools using this approach saw expulsion rates drop by over 50%.
Families also play a critical role. Programs that engage parents as partners—through workshops, home visits, or shared goal-setting—report fewer behavioral issues. For example, a California preschool introduced “calm-down corners” at home and school, teaching kids to identify emotions and choose calming strategies like deep breathing.
A Call for Equity and Empathy
At its core, the preschool expulsion crisis is about equity. Children from marginalized communities—those living in poverty, kids of color, and those with disabilities—are disproportionately affected. Fixing this requires addressing biases. Research shows educators are more likely to perceive Black children as “older” or “more aggressive” than their white peers, leading to harsher discipline. Anti-bias training and diverse hiring practices can help shift these perceptions.
Investing in early childhood mental health is another priority. Some states now embed therapists in preschools to coach teachers and work directly with kids. In Los Angeles, a pilot program pairing behavioral therapists with high-needs classrooms reduced suspensions by 90% in one year.
Rethinking What’s Possible
Preschool expulsion isn’t inevitable. Countries like Finland and Sweden rarely remove young children from classrooms, focusing instead on small teacher-to-student ratios and robust social services. While the U.S. has a long way to go, grassroots efforts prove that change is achievable.
Every child deserves a fair start. By shifting from punishment to prevention—and addressing the systemic flaws that push adults to give up on kids—we can create classrooms where all preschoolers thrive. After all, if a four-year-old’s behavior is too big for us to handle, maybe our systems are too small.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Preschoolers Get Sent Home: Understanding the Complex Issue of Early Childhood Expulsion