When Little Kids Get Sent Home: Understanding Preschool Expulsion
Imagine a 4-year-old named Jake, who loves dinosaurs and building towers with blocks. One day, he throws a toy during circle time, accidentally hitting another child. His teacher, overwhelmed by a classroom of energetic preschoolers, labels the behavior “dangerous” and recommends Jake be removed from the program. Stories like Jake’s are more common than most people realize—and they’re part of a troubling trend called preschool expulsion.
Recent studies reveal that young children, especially those from marginalized communities, are being expelled from early education programs at alarming rates. Unlike older students, preschoolers aren’t suspended for academic reasons; their removals often stem from behaviors adults find challenging, like tantrums, aggression, or difficulty following instructions. Let’s unpack why this happens, its long-term consequences, and what caregivers and educators can do to create more supportive environments.
—
The Hidden Crisis in Early Childhood Education
Preschool expulsion isn’t a rare occurrence. A landmark Yale University study found that preschoolers are expelled at three times the rate of K–12 students. Boys, Black children, and kids with disabilities are disproportionately affected. For example, Black boys make up just 18% of preschool enrollment but account for 48% of suspensions. These disparities reflect systemic biases—implicit assumptions about “problem” behavior—and a lack of resources to address underlying causes.
Why are young children being expelled? Teachers often cite safety concerns, but experts argue that many behaviors labeled as “unmanageable” are developmentally normal. A 3-year-old who bites when frustrated isn’t being malicious; they’re communicating in the only way they know. The real issue, researchers say, is that many educators lack training in trauma-informed care, social-emotional development, and culturally responsive practices. Overworked staff in underfunded programs may resort to expulsion as a quick fix, unaware of the harm it causes.
—
The Ripple Effects of Removing a Child
Expelling a preschooler isn’t just about losing a spot in a classroom. It sets off a chain reaction with lifelong implications. Studies link early expulsion to:
– Academic struggles: Kids who miss out on structured early learning often fall behind in kindergarten.
– Social isolation: Being labeled “difficult” can follow a child, affecting peer relationships.
– Mental health risks: Repeated rejection fuels anxiety, low self-esteem, and higher rates of disciplinary action later in school.
For families, expulsion creates logistical and emotional chaos. Parents may scramble to find new childcare, lose income from taking time off work, or internalize guilt about their child’s behavior. Marginalized families, already facing barriers to quality education, bear the heaviest burden.
—
Turning the Tide: Solutions That Work
The good news? Preschool expulsion is preventable. Schools that adopt proactive strategies see dramatic reductions in removals. Here’s what works:
1. Teacher Training and Support
Educators need tools to manage behavior without exclusion. Programs like Pyramid Model train teachers to understand triggers, teach emotional regulation, and build positive relationships. Coaching and mental health consultations for staff also reduce burnout and turnover.
2. Trauma-Informed Classrooms
Many kids act out due to stress at home—like poverty, violence, or family separation. Trauma-sensitive approaches focus on safety, consistency, and empathy. Simple changes, like quiet corners for self-regulation or visual schedules, help children feel secure.
3. Family Partnerships
Collaboration between teachers and parents is key. Home visits, regular check-ins, and shared goal-setting (e.g., “We’ll work on sharing toys”) build trust. Culturally competent communication ensures families aren’t blamed for their child’s challenges.
4. Policy Changes
Some states, like Colorado and Oregon, now ban preschool expulsion except in extreme cases. Others fund mental health services in early childhood programs. Advocacy for smaller class sizes and fair funding is critical to sustain these reforms.
—
Stories of Success: Schools Getting It Right
In Tulsa, Oklahoma, a preschool serving low-income families cut expulsion rates to zero by hiring behavioral specialists and training teachers in conflict resolution. When a child acts out, staff ask, “What does this behavior tell us?” instead of “How do we stop it?” Solutions might include sensory breaks, social stories, or one-on-one playtime with a teacher.
Another example comes from a Head Start program in Chicago, where a “no expulsion” policy led to creative problem-solving. A boy who kicked and yelled during transitions was given a “job” (line leader) to channel his energy. His outbursts decreased within weeks.
—
What Parents Can Do
If your child is at risk of expulsion, know your rights. Under federal law, children with disabilities are entitled to behavioral support through Individualized Education Programs (IEPs). Even without a diagnosis, parents can:
– Request a classroom observation or evaluation.
– Suggest a Functional Behavior Assessment (FBA) to identify triggers.
– Partner with teachers on a behavior plan (e.g., “When Mia feels angry, she’ll squeeze a stress ball”).
—
The Bigger Picture: Rethinking Early Education
Preschool should be a place where every child feels valued. Expulsion undermines this ideal, punishing kids for needing help. As awareness grows, more schools are shifting from “What’s wrong with this child?” to “What does this child need?”
Investing in early childhood isn’t just about academics—it’s about nurturing resilience, curiosity, and belonging. By addressing preschool expulsion, we take a vital step toward equity, ensuring all children get the strong start they deserve.
—
From policymakers to parents, everyone has a role in ending this practice. Let’s replace exclusion with understanding, so kids like Jake can thrive—blocks, dinosaurs, and all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Little Kids Get Sent Home: Understanding Preschool Expulsion