When Grown-Up Rules Seem Wobbly: Why Parents Do What They Do
That furrowed brow, the puzzled stare, the hesitant question: “But you did it…” Sound familiar? If you’re a parent, you’ve likely been on the receiving end of this childhood interrogation. Kids possess an incredibly sharp sense of fairness and an almost laser-like ability to spot inconsistency, especially when it comes to the rules you seem to bend. That thing they can’t quite name, that feeling bubbling up when your actions don’t perfectly match your words? To them, it feels like hypocrisy. But what’s really happening beneath the surface?
The Literal Lens of Childhood
Children, especially younger ones, experience the world in wonderfully concrete terms. Rules are often seen as absolute, universal laws: “No eating ice cream before dinner.” “Phones aren’t for the dinner table.” “Bedtime is 8:00 sharp.” Their developing brains grasp black and white much easier than shades of gray. So, when they witness a parent – the ultimate rule-maker and enforcer – seemingly breaking one of these sacred decrees? It’s a seismic event! That unnameable “thing” they feel is often confusion mixed with a deep sense of unfairness.
Scenario 1: You tell your child sugary treats are unhealthy and limit their cookies. Later, they see you stress-eating chocolate after a tough work call. Their question: “But you said sweets are bad? Why are you eating them?” The thing they sense: inconsistency.
Scenario 2: You constantly remind them not to spend too much time on screens. Yet, your own phone seems glued to your hand as you scroll through emails or news. Their question: “How come I can only have 30 minutes, but you’re on it all day?” The thing they sense: a double standard.
Scenario 3: You emphasize kindness and “using your words,” but they overhear you snapping impatiently at customer service on the phone. Their question (maybe unspoken, but felt): “Why is it okay for you to yell?” The thing they sense: a broken promise about behavior.
From “Hypocrite!” to “Here’s Why…” (The Justification Side)
Seeing it purely through the child’s lens makes the parent’s actions seem undeniably hypocritical. But stepping into the adult world reveals layers of context that a child simply doesn’t have the experience or brain development to fully grasp yet. This is where the “justification” often lies:
1. Different Needs, Different Rules: Adults and children have fundamentally different biological, emotional, and social needs. An adult needing coffee to function isn’t the same as a child needing caffeine. An adult staying up late to finish essential work or recharge mentally isn’t identical to a child staying up playing video games. That “one more episode” rule exists because their developing brain needs consistent sleep far more critically than an adult’s does. The rule isn’t arbitrary; it’s biologically grounded.
2. Responsibility Comes With Complexity: Parenting involves juggling countless responsibilities – work, bills, household management, relationships, and nurturing a tiny human. Sometimes, that chocolate bar is a necessary coping mechanism in the moment. The quick phone scroll might be checking an urgent message about their school event. While the action might mirror what the child is forbidden from doing, the context and intent are worlds apart. It’s not that the rule against constant snacking or screen time is invalid; it’s that an adult’s moment of coping or multitasking serves a different purpose.
3. The Nuance of “Do As I Say, Not As I Do (Yet)”: This is perhaps the trickiest justification, but often the most honest one. Parents are human. They have flaws, bad days, and ingrained habits. You truly believe in the rule “don’t yell” or “limit screen time,” but you haven’t perfectly mastered it yourself. You enforce it for your child because you know it’s better for them, even as you struggle with it. You’re not saying you’re perfect; you’re saying you’re trying to guide them towards a better standard than you might consistently achieve. It’s a work-in-progress for everyone, parent included.
4. Teaching Context: Life isn’t black and white. Sometimes, a parent’s “rule-breaking” moment is a teachable moment about context, even if not explicitly explained at the time. “Yes, I had ice cream today, but I also ate a healthy lunch and dinner first. We had it as a special treat after a long week.” It subtly introduces the idea that rules can have flexibility based on circumstances – a crucial life lesson that goes beyond simple obedience.
Why the Questions Are Actually Golden (Even When They Sting)
That child pointing out the “wobbly rule” moment? Don’t dread it! It’s actually a sign of healthy development:
Critical Thinking in Action: They are observing, comparing, analyzing, and questioning. These are essential cognitive skills!
Developing a Moral Compass: They are wrestling with concepts of fairness, consistency, and integrity. Their sense of justice is forming.
Seeking Understanding: Often, the question “Why can you do it?” is less an accusation and more a genuine plea for clarity about the confusing adult world.
Testing Boundaries (Healthily): They are learning how rules apply and where the edges are, which is a natural part of growing autonomy.
How to Respond When the “Thing” Feels Hypocritical
So, what do you do when faced with that question?
1. Pause & Acknowledge: Don’t get defensive. Take a breath. Validate their observation: “You’re right, you did see me eating ice cream after I said we shouldn’t have too many sweets.”
2. Explain the Context (Simply): Offer the “why” in age-appropriate terms: “Grown-ups sometimes make choices that aren’t the absolute best either. I was feeling really tired and made a quick choice. But that doesn’t mean the rule about sweets being a sometimes-food is wrong.”
3. Differentiate Needs: If applicable, gently explain the difference: “My body is done growing, so a little extra caffeine sometimes is okay for me, but it can make it really hard for your growing body to rest.”
4. Be Honest About Imperfection: “You know what? You caught me. I tell you not to yell, and then I raised my voice on the phone. That wasn’t my best moment. I’m still working on handling my frustration better. Thank you for reminding me about our rule.” This models accountability.
5. Reaffirm the Rule’s Purpose: Remind them why the rule exists for them: “We have the screen time rule because your brain needs time to play, imagine, and rest without so much flashing light.”
6. Invite Conversation: Sometimes, ask them: “What do you think about that?” or “Does that explanation make sense?” It turns a potential confrontation into a dialogue.
The next time your child points out that confusing inconsistency – that “thing” they can’t quite name but feels fundamentally unfair – remember it’s not just a challenge to your authority. It’s an opportunity. It’s their developing mind grappling with the complex, often messy reality of being human. By acknowledging their perception, offering honest (even if imperfect) explanations, and affirming the underlying values, you do more than justify a moment of seeming hypocrisy. You build trust, foster critical thinking, and show them that navigating life’s gray areas with integrity is a journey you’re on together. Their questions aren’t attacks; they’re the sparks of a growing understanding.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Grown-Up Rules Seem Wobbly: Why Parents Do What They Do