The “Why Can You, But I Can’t?” Question: Unpacking Parental Rules That Feel Like Hypocrisy
Kids have a built-in radar for fairness. They notice everything. So when a rule applies to them but seemingly doesn’t to Mom or Dad, the question pops up, often with an edge of accusation: “Why is it okay for you to do that, but not for me? Isn’t that… hypocritical?”
That moment, that very specific question born from a child’s sharp sense of justice, can leave parents scrambling. We’ve all been there – caught eating the forbidden candy after dinner, scrolling on our phones past “no screens” time, staying up late when we just enforced bedtime, or maybe even raising our voices after demanding calm. The child’s eyes narrow, the head tilts, and the question hangs in the air: “Why is that rule different for you?”
Is it Hypocrisy? Decoding the Accusation
From the child’s perspective, it absolutely feels like hypocrisy. They see a clear action: Parent does X. Parent tells child not to do X. Conclusion? Parent isn’t following their own rules. Simple, logical, and deeply unfair.
They haven’t yet developed the complex understanding of context, responsibility, and developmental differences that adults (ideally) possess. Their world is often black and white, right and wrong. When the rule-maker appears to break the rule, it shakes their trust and sense of fairness. It can feel like a betrayal, a sign that the rules exist purely for control, not for any real reason tied to their well-being.
The Parental Perspective: Justification or Excuse?
When confronted, parents often feel defensive. We might blurt out “Because I’m the parent!” (which rarely satisfies the keen young mind) or offer flimsy explanations that don’t hold water. But beneath the surface, the reasons why rules differ can sometimes be justified, even if poorly communicated:
1. The Responsibility Factor: “I stayed up late because I was paying the bills/planning your birthday/sorting laundry.” An adult staying up late often involves handling responsibilities that a child simply doesn’t have. The purpose of the action differs. A child staying up late usually leads to exhaustion and grumpiness the next day, hindering their primary “job” – learning and growing. The rule isn’t just about the action (staying up), but the consequence and purpose.
2. Safety and Development: “You can’t drink coffee because it can stunt your growth/affect your sleep terribly.” “You can’t drive the car because you haven’t learned how and aren’t physically ready.” These are clear-cut differences based on age, physical development, and safety. The rule exists solely because the child is not developmentally ready or it poses a genuine risk. Parents drinking coffee or driving isn’t hypocritical; it’s a function of adulthood and capability.
3. Modeling Imperfectly: “I know I yelled, and I shouldn’t have. I’m working on staying calm too.” This is where it gets trickier. Parents are human. We get frustrated, tired, and overwhelmed. Sometimes we break the very standards we set. The key difference here is acknowledgement and effort. Saying “Do as I say, not as I do” without explanation is hypocritical. Admitting a mistake, apologizing (“You’re right, I shouldn’t have yelled. I lost my cool, and I’m sorry”), and demonstrating a commitment to doing better? That’s modeling accountability – a crucial life skill. It transforms a moment of perceived hypocrisy into a lesson in handling imperfection.
4. Different Stages, Different Needs: “You need more sleep than I do for your growing brain.” “Too much sugar affects your energy and focus differently than mine.” Rules about diet, sleep, and even screen time are often based on the specific developmental needs of a child’s body and brain, which differ significantly from an adult’s. The rule isn’t arbitrary; it’s tailored.
5. Information Asymmetry: “I said ‘no’ to that sleepover because I know things about that family/situation that you don’t.” Parents sometimes make decisions based on knowledge or intuition they can’t (or shouldn’t) fully share with a young child. This can look like arbitrary rule-breaking (“You let me go to Jamie’s!”) but stems from a protective instinct and access to more complete information.
When “Justification” Crosses into Hypocrisy
Not all parental double standards are defensible. Sometimes, the child’s instinct is spot on:
“Do as I Say, Not as I Do” Without Explanation: Demanding politeness while constantly interrupting, insisting on healthy eating while living on takeout, preaching honesty while telling white lies freely – without any attempt to explain the complexity or acknowledge the discrepancy, this erodes trust.
Rules Purely for Convenience: Enforcing strict tidiness on a child while leaving your own things strewn about simply because “I’m too busy” or “It’s my space” sends a message that rules only apply to the less powerful. This breeds resentment.
Inconsistent Enforcement Based on Mood: Allowing screen time one day and banning it the next for the same behavior, simply because the parent is stressed, feels deeply unfair and hypocritical to a child. Rules need consistency to feel legitimate.
Unacknowledged Privileges: Enjoying clear privileges of adulthood (staying up, driving, making big decisions) without ever acknowledging that these are privileges earned through age and responsibility, and that the child will gain them too in time, can make rules feel like oppression rather than guidance.
Navigating the Minefield: How Parents Can Respond (Better)
So, when the inevitable “That’s hypocritical!” accusation flies, how should a parent respond?
1. DON’T Dismiss: Avoid “Because I said so!” or “I’m the parent!” This shuts down communication and validates the child’s feeling of unfairness.
2. Listen and Validate: Start with, “I hear you. It looks like I’m doing something I told you not to do. That must feel confusing/frustrating/unfair.” Acknowledging their perception is crucial.
3. Explain the Why (if there is one): “You’re right, I am eating candy after dinner. The difference is, my body is fully grown, and I understand how to balance treats so they don’t replace healthy food. Your growing body needs different nutrition right now. Plus, I’m responsible for making sure you eat well. When you’re older, you’ll make those choices too.” Or, “I stayed up late because I had to finish something important for work. You need more sleep than I do for school tomorrow. My staying up is an exception, not the rule.”
4. Acknowledge Your Imperfection (if applicable): “You’re right, I yelled. I told you not to yell, and then I did it. That wasn’t okay. I got really frustrated, but yelling isn’t the right way to handle it. I’m sorry. I’m working on staying calm.” This is powerful modeling.
5. Discuss Context (Appropriately): For older children, discussing nuance can be helpful: “Sometimes rules change based on the situation, your age, or information I have. It’s not always simple. I’ll always try to explain my reasons when I can.”
6. Revisit Rules: If a child consistently questions a rule, it might be time to revisit it. Is it still age-appropriate? Can you explain it better? Is there some hypocrisy at play you need to address in your own behavior?
The Takeaway for Kids (and Parents)
A child asking “Is that hypocritical?” isn’t just being cheeky. It’s a sign they’re thinking critically about fairness, rules, and authority. It’s an opportunity, however uncomfortable, for genuine connection and teaching.
For parents, the goal isn’t perfection. It’s awareness and integrity. Sometimes, the difference in rules is justified by age, responsibility, safety, or development. Sometimes, we mess up. Owning that, explaining the complexities of adulthood when appropriate, and striving to align our actions with our values as much as possible is what builds real trust and respect. It shows our kids that rules aren’t about power for power’s sake, but about guidance, safety, and growth – messy, imperfect, human growth for everyone involved. The next time that question comes, take a breath – it might just be the start of a really important conversation.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The “Why Can You, But I Can’t