Little Eyes, Big Questions: When Kids Spot the Gap Between What We Say and What We Do
Kids are incredible observers. They notice the tiny ladybug on the leaf, the slight change in your tone of voice, and yes, they absolutely notice when your actions don’t quite line up with your words. “But Mommy, you said no phones at dinner… why is yours right there?” “Daddy, you told me not to yell, but you yelled at the car.” “Why can I only have one cookie when you eat three?”
That moment. The child’s head tilts, their eyes wide with genuine, innocent confusion. They’ve spotted a discrepancy. They’re holding up a mirror to our behavior, reflecting back a difference between the rule they’ve been taught and the reality they see. And their question hangs in the air, unspoken or blurted out: “Is this thing you’re doing… hypocritical? Or is there a reason that makes it okay for you but not for me?”
It’s a powerful moment, often catching parents off guard. How we handle it matters immensely. Is the child simply being difficult, or are they onto something profound about fairness and consistency? Let’s dive into why this happens and how understanding both sides can bridge the gap.
Why Little Eyes Notice Everything (Especially the “Gaps”)
1. Developing Fairness Radars: Children are hardwired to seek fairness. Rules provide structure and security. When a parent enforces a rule but then seemingly breaks it themselves, it feels fundamentally unfair to the child. Their developing sense of justice is poked.
2. Learning Through Modeling: Kids don’t just learn from what we tell them; they learn exponentially more from what we show them. You can lecture for hours about patience, but if you constantly sigh and tap your foot in a slow line, that’s the lesson they absorb. When words and actions conflict, the actions always win in the child’s learning process.
3. Testing Boundaries (and Logic): Questioning is a natural part of cognitive development. They’re figuring out the world, understanding cause and effect, and testing the logic behind the rules that govern their lives. A perceived inconsistency is a logical puzzle they need to solve.
4. Seeking Understanding: Often, the question isn’t meant as an accusation. It’s a genuine quest for understanding. “Why is this different for you?” is a request for context that helps them make sense of complex adult behaviors.
The Parental Perspective: Hypocrisy or Hidden Context?
When faced with that pointed little question, a parent’s internal response might be defensive (“How dare they question me!”) or flustered (“Oh no, they caught me!”). But beneath the surface, there are often layers of context a child simply cannot grasp:
1. Different Roles, Different Rules: This is the big one. Parents are caregivers, providers, and managers of a household. The “cookie rule” might be about nutrition and establishing healthy habits for a growing child, not about the parent’s own occasional treat. The “no yelling” rule teaches emotional regulation skills kids are still learning, while an adult might yell once out of sheer frustration after hours of trying to stay calm – not ideal, but a different context.
2. Responsibilities and Consequences: “Why do you get to stay up late?” The answer involves adult responsibilities (paying bills, managing a household, needing quiet time) and different biological needs. A child staying up late faces consequences like exhaustion and grumpiness that an adult might manage differently (though poorly!).
3. “Do as I Say, Not as I Do” (The Flawed Shortcut): Sometimes, parents know their own behavior isn’t ideal. They might say, “Don’t eat junk food,” while grabbing chips, knowing it’s a bad habit they struggle with. They genuinely want better for their child. It’s not pure hypocrisy, but a mix of good intention and personal struggle. It’s messy, but human.
4. Protection vs. Experience: Rules often exist to protect children from risks they don’t fully understand. An adult might handle a sharp knife safely; a child cannot. An adult can assess the risk of crossing a quiet street; a young child cannot. The rule isn’t hypocritical; it’s based on differing levels of competence and judgment.
Navigating the “Why Can You?” Minefield: Turning Conflict into Connection
So, your child points out the gap. What now? How do you respond without dismissing their valid observation or crumbling under perceived hypocrisy?
1. Pause and Acknowledge: Resist the urge to snap or get defensive. Take a breath. Acknowledge their observation: “You’re right, I did just raise my voice after telling you not to yell. You noticed that.”
2. Validate the Feeling: Show you understand their perspective: “It probably seems confusing/frustrating/unfair to see me do that.”
3. Explain the Context (Age-Appropriately): Offer the “why” behind the difference, honestly and simply:
For Role/Responsibility: “Grown-up bodies handle sugar differently than kids’ bodies, and I need to help you grow strong. Sometimes I don’t make the best choice for myself either, but I’m working on it.”
For Protection: “Sharp knives are very dangerous. My hands are bigger and I’ve had a lot more practice using them safely. When you’re older and have practiced a lot too, you’ll learn how.”
For Imperfection: “You know what? You’re absolutely right. I shouldn’t have yelled. I got really frustrated and lost my temper, just like you sometimes do. That wasn’t a good way to handle it. I’m sorry. We both need to work on using calm voices, huh?”
4. Avoid “Because I Said So” as the Default: While sometimes necessary in the moment, overusing this shuts down understanding and reinforces the feeling of arbitrary unfairness. Save it for true emergencies.
5. Reframe It as Shared Growth: Sometimes, the best response is admitting the inconsistency and committing to do better together: “You know, you made me realize I look at my phone too much sometimes. How about we make a new family rule? During dinner, everyone’s phone goes in the basket – including mine. Deal?”
6. Thank Them (Seriously!): “Thank you for pointing that out to me. It helps me remember to try harder to do what I ask you to do.” This shows you value their perspective and teaches them that respectful questioning is okay.
The Takeaway: Honesty Over Perfection
Children don’t need perfect parents. They need authentic ones. They need to see us striving, sometimes stumbling, and getting back up. They need to understand that rules have reasons, that roles carry different responsibilities, and that adults are flawed humans too.
When your child asks, “Why can you do that, but I can’t?” or silently wonders if your action is hypocritical, see it as an opportunity. It’s a moment to connect, to explain the complexities of the adult world in a way they can grasp, to model humility by admitting mistakes, and to reaffirm that fairness and honesty are core family values – even when navigating the messy reality of daily life.
Those little eyes are watching, learning, and building their own moral compass. How we handle their questions about our inconsistencies shapes not only their view of us but their understanding of integrity itself. By embracing the questions with honesty and empathy, we turn perceived hypocrisy into powerful lessons about context, responsibility, and the shared journey of growing up – even when we’re the grown-ups.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Little Eyes, Big Questions: When Kids Spot the Gap Between What We Say and What We Do