Beyond “Agree” or “Disagree”: The Magic When Your Child Hands You Their Words
It arrives with a mixture of pride and shyness – a crumpled piece of notebook paper, a document hastily pulled up on a tablet, maybe a carefully illustrated storybook crafted from stapled-together pages. “My son wrote this,” you announce, holding it out, perhaps to a partner, a grandparent, a friend. Then comes the inevitable question, often tinged with a parent’s protective hope and genuine curiosity: “Do you agree with him?”
It’s a simple question, loaded with layers we often don’t pause to unpack. That little query, “Do you agree?” reveals so much more than just a desire for validation of a child’s grammatical structure or factual accuracy. It opens a window into the beautiful, complex world of childhood expression, parental hopes, and how we navigate the journey of nurturing a young voice.
The Unspoken Questions Beneath “Do You Agree?”
When we ask “Do you agree?”, we’re rarely just asking about the literal content. We’re often asking:
1. “Is this ‘good’?” (The Quality Quandary): Did he spell things mostly right? Does the story make sense? Is the argument logical? We instinctively seek external benchmarks to gauge if our child is “on track” academically or creatively.
2. “Is this… normal?” (The Validation Vault): Seeing your child express thoughts wildly different from your own can be surprising. Sometimes “Do you agree?” is a quiet plea for reassurance: “Is this quirky perspective okay? Is he seeing the world in a way that makes sense?”
3. “Am I Doing This Right?” (The Parenting Pulse Check): Our children’s output often feels like a reflection of our input. When we share their writing, part of us is subtly asking, “Is my approach working? Have I guided him well?” Agreement can feel like parental approval.
4. “Can You See What I See?” (The Pride Projection): We see the effort, the tiny spark of creativity, the courage it took to put thoughts on paper. “Do you agree?” can sometimes translate to “Do you see the brilliance I see in this?”
The Child’s World: Where Agreement Isn’t the Point
While parents are navigating these complex layers, the child often exists in a simpler, purer space of creation. For a young writer, especially in the early stages:
Expression is Exploration: Writing isn’t primarily about persuasion or winning an argument (though it might be framed that way!). It’s about testing ideas, processing feelings, experimenting with language, and making sense of their experiences. That story about a dragon who hates treasure? It’s not necessarily a manifesto against materialism; it might just be a fun “what if?” scenario.
Perspective is Unique (and Tiny): Children see the world from ground level, both literally and figuratively. Their scale is different. A battle between ants might be epic. A broken toy can be a tragedy. Their “truth” is filtered through limited experience and boundless imagination. Asking if we “agree” with their perspective can be like asking if we agree that gravity pulls us down – it’s their current understanding of their world.
The Act is the Achievement: The sheer act of wrestling thoughts onto paper, choosing words, forming sentences – that is the victory. Focusing solely on whether we endorse the conclusion misses the monumental effort of the process.
Moving Beyond “Agree” or “Disagree”: A Better Response Framework
So, if “Do you agree?” isn’t always the most productive question, what can we do instead when that precious piece of writing is shared? Try shifting the focus:
1. Lead with Curiosity: “Wow, you wrote this! Tell me more about [specific part].” “What inspired you to write about this?” “How did you decide to end it that way?” This shows genuine interest in their process and thinking.
2. Focus on Effort and Specifics: “I can see you worked really hard on this description!” “I love how you used the word ‘gigantic’ here – it paints such a clear picture!” “The way you built the suspense kept me reading!” This validates the craft and effort without necessarily endorsing the viewpoint.
3. Acknowledge the Perspective: “That’s a really interesting way to look at it!” “I hadn’t thought about it like that before.” This respects their unique viewpoint without demanding alignment.
4. Ask Clarifying Questions (Gently): If something seems confusing or contradictory, ask them to explain: “Help me understand this part…” “What did you mean when the character…?” This encourages critical thinking about their own work.
5. Share Your Reaction (Thoughtfully): Instead of “I agree/disagree,” try: “I felt surprised when…” “This part made me laugh because…” “I wonder what would happen if…” This models thoughtful response without judgment.
6. Celebrate the Courage: “I’m so impressed you shared this with me!” “It takes bravery to put your ideas out there. Well done!”
The Magic Unlocked
When we move beyond the binary of agreement or disagreement, something magical happens:
We Validate the Writer, Not Just the Writing: The child feels heard and valued for their effort and unique voice, building confidence that isn’t tied to external approval of their opinions.
We Foster Intrinsic Motivation: The joy shifts from seeking “right” answers to enjoying the process of creation and discovery itself.
We Encourage Critical Thinking: By asking open-ended questions and discussing their ideas, we help them refine their thoughts, consider alternatives, and strengthen their reasoning skills – far more valuable than simply parroting a viewpoint we endorse.
We Deepen Connection: Engaging authentically with their creative output builds trust and opens communication channels. They learn their thoughts are worthy of discussion, even if they aren’t universally agreed upon.
So, the next time your son (or daughter!) hands you something they wrote, resist the automatic “Do you agree?” Instead, take a deep breath. Look at that piece of paper – a tangible piece of their mind and heart. See the courage in the scribbles, the imagination in the plot twists, the unique worldview in every chosen word.
Ask “What inspired this?” Ask “Can you tell me more about this character?” Ask “What was the hardest part to write?” Celebrate the effort. Marvel at the perspective. Engage with the ideas. You might be surprised by the depth of thought you discover when you stop asking for agreement and start asking for understanding. That’s where the real magic of their words truly begins.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Beyond “Agree” or “Disagree”: The Magic When Your Child Hands You Their Words