The Bedsharing Question: When Does “Never” Become “Maybe Later”?
For many new parents, the decision against bedsharing – sharing a sleep surface with their infant – is firm and often driven by strong safety recommendations. Groups like the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) consistently advise against bedsharing with infants under 1 year old, citing clear risks like suffocation, entrapment, and Sudden Unexpected Infant Death (SUID). This guidance leads many to adopt a strict “anti-bedsharing” stance initially, choosing room-sharing with a separate crib or bassinet instead. But as that tiny newborn grows into a wriggly, communicative toddler, parents who were once staunchly against bedsharing often wonder: “When, if ever, does this become safe? Is there a point where the benefits might outweigh the risks for our family?”
It’s a natural question. The intense vulnerability of infancy fades, replaced by a more robust child. The initial reasons for the hardline stance might feel less absolute. So, let’s navigate this complex transition thoughtfully, focusing on evidence and developmental readiness.
Understanding the Shift in Risk
The core reason for the “anti-bedsharing” recommendation for infants revolves around developmental vulnerability:
Lack of Mobility: Young infants cannot easily reposition themselves if their breathing is obstructed by bedding, a parent’s body, or the gap against a wall.
Immature Arousal: Their ability to wake in response to breathing difficulties (like rebreathing carbon dioxide) is underdeveloped.
Small Size & Weakness: They lack the strength to push away suffocation hazards.
As children grow, these risks significantly decrease:
Age 1+: By the first birthday, motor skills, head control, and the ability to roll over purposefully are typically well-established. The risk of SUID also drops dramatically after 12 months.
Age 2+: Toddlers are incredibly mobile. They can sit up, crawl, walk, and forcefully push objects (or people!) away. Their arousal mechanisms are much more mature. They can often vocalize needs clearly.
Age 3-4+: Preschoolers are generally very robust physically. They understand simple instructions (“stay on your side,” “no kicking”) and have excellent motor control. The primary safety concerns shift towards falls from a height (if no rail) or entanglement in adult bedding.
So, Is There a “Safe” Age?
There isn’t a single, universally agreed-upon magic number where bedsharing suddenly becomes 100% risk-free. Safety depends heavily on the specific child, the sleep environment, and parental habits. However, we can look at developmental milestones:
Around 12-18 Months: Many experts agree that the most critical period of high risk has passed. While the AAP still recommends room-sharing (separate surface) ideally for the first 6 months, and preferably up to 1 year, their strong bedsharing prohibition primarily targets infancy. For a healthy, typically developing toddler over 1 year old in a safe sleep environment, the risk profile changes significantly. This is often when parents who were previously “anti” start to seriously reconsider.
Toddlerhood (18 Months – 3 Years): This is a common window where families who choose to introduce bedsharing often do so. The child is physically capable, and benefits like easier nighttime comforting, potential for more family sleep (if everyone settles), and emotional closeness become more prominent factors for some.
Preschool (3-4+): From a purely physical safety perspective (regarding suffocation/SIDS risks), bedsharing with a healthy preschooler is generally considered to have very minimal inherent risk comparable to an older child or adult sleeping alone. Concerns here are more about sleep habits, parental sleep quality, and family dynamics.
Crucial Considerations Before Transitioning (Even After Age 1)
If you were firmly anti-bedsharing initially but are now contemplating it with your older baby or toddler, safety remains paramount. Transitioning requires careful preparation:
1. The Sleep Environment MUST Be Safe:
Firm Mattress: No soft memory foam toppers that create indentations.
Minimal Bedding: Avoid heavy comforters, quilts, or excessive pillows near the child. Consider separate, lighter blankets for the child. No stuffed animals or loose items near their sleep space initially.
No Gaps: Ensure the mattress fits tightly against the headboard and footboard (or remove them). Fill any gaps between mattress and wall or furniture with pool noodles securely fastened under the sheet or use specific bed gap guards.
Guardrails: Essential if the bed is high, especially for younger toddlers transitioning out of a crib. Ensure they are securely installed with no gaps a child could slip through.
No Other Children/Pets: Initially, only one caregiver (if any) and the child should share the bed. Avoid siblings or pets in the sleep space.
Safe Bed Frame: Platform beds are generally safer than those with high frames and potential under-bed entrapment zones. Avoid waterbeds.
2. Parental Factors:
Sobriety: Absolutely no alcohol, drugs, or medications causing excessive drowsiness for the adult sharing the bed.
No Smoking: Smoking (even outside) increases risks.
Extreme Obesity: Can still pose an unintentional overlay risk even with older toddlers; extra caution is needed.
Exhaustion: Severe sleep deprivation can impair awareness. Be mindful.
3. Child Factors:
Health & Development: Is your child healthy, meeting physical milestones, and able to move freely?
Temperament: Is your child a very restless sleeper who thrashes or rolls excessively? This might increase fall risks or disrupt everyone’s sleep.
Readiness: Does your child want to sleep in the big bed, or are you imposing it? A smoother transition often happens when the child shows interest.
The “Why Now?” Question: Weighing Pros and Cons
Beyond safety, consider why you are reconsidering bedsharing now:
Night Wakings: Is your toddler waking frequently and needing comfort? Could other gentle sleep coaching methods be effective without bedsharing?
Child’s Request: Is your child asking to join you, expressing fear of their own room?
Family Harmony: Is one parent strongly for it while the other remains hesitant? Open communication is vital.
Parental Sleep: Will bringing the child in actually improve your sleep, or lead to more kicking and less rest? Be realistic.
Long-Term Habits: Are you comfortable potentially establishing a habit that might last for years? How will you eventually transition them back to their own bed if desired?
It’s a Spectrum, Not a Binary
For parents who started out “anti-bedsharing,” the journey isn’t about flipping a switch from “never” to “always.” It’s about recognizing that risk evolves with development.
Age 0-12 Months: Strict avoidance of bedsharing is the safest course, aligning with major health organization guidelines.
Age 1-2 Years: The inherent risks decrease substantially for healthy toddlers. Safety depends critically on the environment and parental factors. This is a common “reconsideration zone” for previously anti-bedsharing parents. Many experts feel risks are low if all safe sleep practices are meticulously followed.
Age 2-3+ Years: Physical safety risks related to suffocation/SIDS become minimal for typically developing children in a safe environment. Decisions become more about family preference, sleep dynamics, and emotional needs.
Making Your Informed Choice
If you were once firmly against bedsharing but find yourself wondering “when is it safe enough?”, know that your caution in infancy was well-founded. As your child grows, the safety landscape changes. There’s no single right answer that fits every family.
The key is:
1. Acknowledge the reduced risk profile after infancy (especially post-18-24 months).
2. Rigorously implement safe sleep practices (environment, sobriety) if you choose to try bedsharing.
3. Honestly assess your family’s needs and dynamics. Does it solve a problem or create new ones?
4. Be flexible and communicate. What works one month might not work the next. Talk with your partner.
For parents who remain uncomfortable with bedsharing at any age, that is a perfectly valid choice. Continued room-sharing (child in their own bed in your room) or encouraging independent sleep in their own room are excellent alternatives that still provide security. The transition from “anti-bedsharing” isn’t an obligation; it’s simply opening the door to re-evaluate what “safe” and “right” means as your unique child grows. Trust your knowledge, prioritize safety, and choose the path that brings your family the most peace and rest.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Bedsharing Question: When Does “Never” Become “Maybe Later”