Why Some Online Communities Ask for Patience and Positive Contributions Before You Post
So you’ve found an awesome online forum or community, maybe a specific subreddit buzzing with discussions you’re passionate about. You’re excited to jump in, share your thoughts, ask a burning question, or maybe even post some cool content. But when you hit that “submit” button… nothing happens. Instead, you see a message: “In order to post, your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma.” Frustrating? Maybe at first. But there’s actually a very good reason behind this common gatekeeper.
Think of these requirements – the 10-day age minimum and the 100 positive karma threshold – not as arbitrary hurdles, but as the community’s immune system. They exist to protect the vibrant, healthy discussion everyone wants to participate in. Here’s why they matter:
1. Fighting Spam Onslaught: The internet is constantly under siege from automated spam bots. These programs create accounts by the thousands to flood communities with irrelevant links, scams, advertisements, and malicious content. Requiring an account to be older than 10 days instantly cripples most bot operations. Bots are designed for instant, mass posting. Forcing them to wait over a week before even starting their spam campaign makes it economically unfeasible. They move on to easier targets. Genuine humans don’t mind waiting a bit to join the conversation properly.
2. Discouraging Trolls and Bad Actors: Not all unwanted content comes from bots. Some comes from real people with disruptive intentions – trolls seeking to provoke arguments, spread misinformation, harass others, or just cause chaos. Creating a new account (a “sock puppet”) is easy and anonymous. However, demanding 100 positive karma significantly raises the bar. Earning that karma requires consistent positive contributions over time – commenting thoughtfully, sharing useful information, engaging constructively. Trolls generally lack the patience or inclination to build up good standing before launching attacks. The effort required deters casual troublemakers.
3. Promoting Quality Engagement: These rules subtly encourage newcomers to learn the community’s culture before diving into posting. That 10-day waiting period is a perfect time to:
Lurk: Read existing posts, understand the topics discussed, and grasp the unwritten rules of engagement.
Observe: See what kind of content gets upvoted (positive karma) and what gets downvoted or removed.
Learn the Guidelines: Find the community’s specific rules (often found in the sidebar or wiki) to avoid accidental missteps.
4. Establishing Trust and Good Faith: Earning 100 positive karma isn’t just about numbers; it’s a signal. It shows you’re willing to contribute value before asking something of the community (like posting a new thread or responding directly). It demonstrates you’re not just there to take or disrupt, but to participate as a constructive member. It builds a small track record of trust.
So, You’re Facing the Gate: How Do You Build That 100 Karma?
Encountering the barrier is common. The key is to see it not as a “no,” but as a “not yet.” Here’s how to navigate it effectively:
1. Start Small: Focus on Comments: Your primary path to initial karma is through commenting. Find discussions where you genuinely have something useful to add:
Answer Questions: Can you provide a helpful answer to someone’s query? Even a concise, accurate one can earn upvotes.
Share Relevant Experiences: “This worked for me when I faced a similar situation…” can be very valuable.
Add Insightful Thoughts: Build on existing points with a unique perspective or additional information.
Be Positive and Constructive: Agree thoughtfully (“Great point about X, I also found Y useful…”) rather than just saying “This.” Avoid unnecessary negativity.
Ask Clarifying Questions: Shows engagement and can spark deeper discussion.
2. Understand What Not to Do:
Beg for Karma: Posts or comments saying “Please upvote so I can post” are usually downvoted or removed. It violates the spirit of the rule.
Spam Low-Effort Comments: “Cool!”, “LOL”, “Same here.” These add no value and are often ignored or downvoted.
Post Controversial Hot Takes: Until you understand the community norms, inflammatory comments are risky and can sink your karma.
Post in Karma Farms: Some subreddits exist purely for trading upvotes. These are often against platform rules and can get you banned. The karma gained is hollow and doesn’t represent genuine community trust.
Be Rude or Aggressive: This guarantees downvotes.
3. Explore Related Communities: Your target community might have a high karma threshold. Look for related, smaller, or more general subreddits where the karma requirement might be lower or non-existent. Engage genuinely there on topics you know. Positive contributions in these spaces still build your overall karma, which counts towards the 100 needed elsewhere.
4. Be Patient and Genuine: Building 100 positive karma takes time and authentic interaction. There are no reliable shortcuts that won’t potentially harm your account or reputation. Focus on contributing value consistently during your 10 days (and beyond). Think of it as an apprenticeship period where you learn the ropes and prove your good intentions. Genuine, helpful comments will naturally attract upvotes over time.
The Bigger Picture: Community Health
Moderators are volunteers tasked with an often thankless job: keeping their communities clean, welcoming, and on-topic. The 10-day/100 karma rule is one of their most powerful tools. It significantly reduces the flood of spam, scams, and low-quality posts they have to manually remove. This allows them to focus on fostering better discussions and handling more nuanced issues, rather than just playing whack-a-mole with bots and trolls.
For the regular members, these rules mean:
Less Noise: Their feeds aren’t cluttered with junk.
Higher Quality Discussions: Posts and comments are more likely to be relevant and valuable.
A Safer Environment: Reduced exposure to scams, harassment, and malicious content.
A Sense of Shared Investment: Knowing others have also contributed positively fosters a more committed community.
In Conclusion: It’s Not Personal, It’s Protection
That message asking for 10 days and 100 positive karma might feel like a roadblock when you’re eager to jump in. But understanding its purpose transforms it from an annoyance into an appreciation. These simple requirements are fundamental shields that protect the communities we enjoy from the chaos that constantly threatens online spaces. They ensure that when you do finally get to post, you’re contributing to a healthier, more vibrant, and more valuable conversation alongside others who have also demonstrated their commitment to making it a good place. So take that waiting period, explore the community, share thoughtful comments, build your karma organically, and know that the gate exists to make your eventual participation more rewarding. The best communities are worth a little patience.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Some Online Communities Ask for Patience and Positive Contributions Before You Post