The Gift Card Dilemma: Should You Ever Reclaim a Present Meant for Your Grown Child?
It’s a scenario many parents of adult children might recognize: Months ago, perhaps for a birthday or holiday, you carefully chose a gift card for your son or daughter. It felt like the perfect present – flexible, practical, letting them pick exactly what they wanted. But now, weeks or even months have passed. You notice the card tucked forgotten in a drawer during a visit, or you casually ask if they enjoyed using it only to be met with a vague, “Oh, I haven’t gotten around to it yet.” That pristine plastic rectangle starts to feel less like a thoughtful gift and more like… wasted potential. A nagging thought emerges: “Maybe I should just use it myself?”
The temptation is surprisingly common. The justification often sounds reasonable in your head: “It’s just sitting there!” “They clearly don’t want it.” “I could really use it for groceries/gas.” “It’s better than letting it expire unused.” But is it really that simple? And crucially, what happens if you don’t tell them you reclaimed it?
Let’s unpack why the idea surfaces and what’s really at stake:
The Seed of the Temptation:
1. The Practicality Argument: Money is tangible. Seeing value unused feels inefficient. Using it yourself seems like eliminating waste – a practical solution to a practical problem. The abstract concept of “gift” can fade against the concrete need for groceries or gas.
2. The Disappointment Factor: Giving a gift that isn’t appreciated stings. Reclaiming the unused card can feel like reclaiming a bit of that lost effort or thwarted hope. It neutralizes the slight feeling of rejection.
3. The “They Won’t Mind” Assumption: Parents often project. “I wouldn’t care if someone did that with a gift I ignored,” you might think. Therefore, you assume your child shares that perspective. This is risky.
4. The Convenience of Silence: Telling them feels awkward. It risks sounding accusatory (“Why haven’t you used this?”) or petty (“Well, if you don’t want it…”). Redeeming it silently avoids that uncomfortable conversation.
Why Redeeming Without Telling Them is Problematic:
While the impulse is understandable, acting on it silently crosses several important lines:
1. Breach of Trust: At its core, a gift, once given, belongs to the recipient. Taking it back without permission, even if unused, is effectively taking something that is not yours. It violates a fundamental trust, especially with an adult child where mutual respect is paramount.
2. Disrespecting Autonomy: Your adult child has the absolute right to decide if and when they use your gift. Maybe they’re saving it for a specific purpose. Maybe they genuinely forgot. Maybe they just haven’t felt inspired yet. Their timeline is theirs, not yours. Reclaiming it dismisses their right to manage their own possessions.
3. The Potential for Discovery: Imagine the fallout. They eventually remember the card, go to use it, and find it empty or invalid. The shock, confusion, and then realization can be deeply hurtful. The message received won’t be about practicality; it will be, “My parent took back my gift without asking or telling me.” The damage to the relationship can be significant and far outweighs the card’s value.
4. Undermining the Gift’s Meaning: The act of reclaiming, especially secretly, retroactively changes the nature of the original gift. It shifts from being an expression of love or generosity to something conditional or even transactional. It sends a message that your generosity had an unspoken expiry date or contingency.
5. Modeling Questionable Behavior: As parents, we remain role models. Taking something back that doesn’t belong to you, even with seemingly good intentions, sets a poor example about respecting others’ property and boundaries.
Navigating the Situation Respectfully:
So, what should you do instead if that unused gift card is gnawing at you?
1. Give It (More) Time: Seriously. Months might feel like forever to you, but life gets busy. Unless the card is nearing expiration, patience is often the best policy.
2. Have a Gentle Conversation: If it’s been a very long time (think approaching expiry), approach it gently. “Hey, I happened to see that gift card from [occasion] tucked away the other day. Just wanted to remind you it exists before it gets lost forever! Any fun plans for it?” This prompts them without accusation.
3. The Direct Ask (If You Must): If practicality is overwhelming and the card is truly at risk of expiring unused, ask for permission. This is crucial. “I noticed that gift card I gave you for [store] hasn’t been used, and I saw it’s expiring soon. I was wondering if you’d mind if I used it for [specific small thing] to avoid it going to waste? Completely understand if you’d rather hold onto it!” This respects their ownership.
Respect Their Answer: If they say no, or hesitate, drop it immediately. It’s still theirs. If they readily agree, express thanks.
4. Suggest Regifting (To Them): Another gentle nudge: “If [store] isn’t really your thing anymore, maybe you could regift that card to a friend who’d love it? Hate to see it go unused!” This puts the power back in their hands.
5. Reframe Your Thinking: Sometimes, the healthiest approach is internal. Recognize that the gift fulfilled its purpose the moment you gave it – expressing your love and intention. What happens next is truly up to them. Letting go of the outcome is part of respecting their adulthood.
The Bottom Line:
Redeeming a gift card you gave your adult child without their knowledge or permission is, ultimately, a violation of trust and respect. It prioritizes temporary convenience or your own feelings of disappointment over the integrity of your relationship and their autonomy as an adult.
The monetary value of a gift card is almost always insignificant compared to the potential cost to trust and goodwill. The awkwardness of a brief, respectful conversation is infinitely preferable to the potential hurt and breach of trust caused by a secret reclamation. True generosity allows the recipient the freedom to receive – and use, or not use – a gift on their own terms. Choosing respect over convenience is a powerful affirmation of your relationship with your grown child. It communicates that you see them, value them, and respect their space and possessions as adults. That message is worth infinitely more than any amount loaded onto a plastic card.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Gift Card Dilemma: Should You Ever Reclaim a Present Meant for Your Grown Child