Rethinking That First Piece of Advice: Why “Get an Evaluation” Isn’t Always the Best Starting Point
You notice your child struggling. Maybe reading feels like climbing a mountain, homework time dissolves into tears, or the classroom environment seems overwhelming for them. Concerned, you reach out – perhaps to a teacher, a pediatrician, or even a well-meaning friend. And often, the first piece of advice lands with a thud: “You should just get a full evaluation.”
It sounds so straightforward, so logical. Identify the problem, right? But for many parents navigating the early stages of concern about their child’s learning, development, or behavior, this directive can feel overwhelming, intimidating, and sometimes, counterproductive. Here’s why pushing the “get an evaluation” button as the very first step often misses the mark.
1. It Overlooks the Parent’s Emotional Journey: Hearing “get an evaluation” can instantly catapult a parent into a place of heightened anxiety. It subtly implies a significant problem requiring formal diagnosis. The parent might be in a phase of initial observation or gentle concern. Immediately suggesting a full evaluation can bypass the crucial step of validating their worries and allowing them space to process their observations. They need support and understanding first, not a directive that feels like jumping into the deep end of a complex medical or educational system.
2. It Can Feel Like Dismissing Simpler Solutions: Often, parents aren’t yet convinced a major underlying condition exists. They might be observing a symptom – frustration with homework, reluctance to read aloud, social awkwardness – and seeking practical strategies. Jumping straight to “evaluation” can feel like their immediate request for help is being bypassed. They might wonder, “Couldn’t we try simpler things first? Are there adjustments the teacher could make? Is this just a temporary phase?” Dismissing these possibilities by immediately escalating to formal testing can erode trust and make parents feel unheard.
3. It Presumes Easy Access and Understanding: “Just get an evaluation” assumes a level of access and knowledge that many families simply don’t have.
The Labyrinth: Navigating the world of evaluations – understanding the differences between school-based evaluations (often free) versus private neuropsychological or psycho-educational evaluations (often expensive and with long waitlists), knowing who to contact, understanding insurance coverage – is incredibly complex. Telling someone to “just” do it underestimates this daunting administrative and financial hurdle.
The Fear Factor: For parents unfamiliar with the process, the prospect of evaluations can be frightening. What if they find something “wrong”? What labels might be applied? Will this change how others see their child? The emotional weight of this step is significant and deserves acknowledgment, not dismissal.
4. It Can Create Premature Barriers: Sometimes, immediately suggesting an evaluation can inadvertently create an “us vs. them” dynamic between parents and educators or other professionals. The parent might feel pressured into a formal process before a collaborative relationship is established. Teachers might feel their own observations and potential classroom interventions are being sidelined before they’ve even had a chance to try them. Jumping to evaluation can short-circuit the crucial, collaborative problem-solving that should come first.
5. It Puts the Cart Before the Horse: A high-quality evaluation is most effective when there’s already a foundation of information and observation. Rushing into it without gathering preliminary data can sometimes lead to less accurate results or a need for re-testing. What’s more helpful before that major step?
So, What Should Be the First Step?
The best first step is almost always building understanding, collaboration, and gathering targeted information. Here’s what that looks like:
1. Deep Listening & Validation: “It sounds like you’re noticing [specific behavior/struggle]. That must be really tough to see. Tell me more about what you’re observing, and when it happens.” This validates the parent’s concern and invites them to share their perspective without judgment.
2. Focused Observation: Encourage the parent (and teacher, if applicable) to observe specifically: When exactly does the struggle occur? (During math homework? During transitions? In noisy environments?) What does it look like? (Avoidance? Tears? Shutting down? Acting out?) How long has it been happening? What seems to help, even a little? Concrete examples are gold.
3. Collaborative Problem-Solving (Before Testing): “Based on what you’re seeing, are there some small adjustments we could try first?” This could involve:
At Home: Trying a different homework routine, breaking tasks into smaller chunks, using visual timers, reducing distractions.
At School: The teacher implementing simple accommodations like preferential seating, extra time on specific tasks, access to fidget tools, or checking for understanding more frequently.
Communication Bridge: Setting up a consistent way for parents and teachers to share observations about what’s working or not working (e.g., a simple daily log, brief weekly email check-in).
4. Information Gathering: Suggest resources that help parents understand common learning differences or developmental stages without immediately pathologizing. Reputable websites, books, or parent support groups can be empowering. “Have you looked into resources about [e.g., dyslexia traits, executive function challenges in kids, anxiety signs]? Sometimes reading about others’ experiences can be clarifying.”
5. Explaining the “Why” Behind Evaluation (When It’s Time): When the conversation naturally progresses towards evaluation, frame it constructively: “If we try these strategies for a few weeks and don’t see progress, or if the challenges seem significant across different settings, then an evaluation becomes a really useful tool. Its purpose isn’t just to find a ‘label,’ but to get a detailed map of your child’s unique strengths and learning style. That map helps everyone – you, their teachers, any therapists – provide the right kind of support much more effectively. It’s about understanding how they learn best.” Explain the process simply and offer to help navigate the next steps.
The Power of a Better First Step
Consider Priya. She mentions to her son Aiden’s teacher that reading homework is a nightly battle. An immediate “You need to get him evaluated for dyslexia” might send Priya spiraling. Instead, the teacher listens, validates her frustration, and asks for specifics. Priya notes Aiden guesses words based on the first letter, avoids reading aloud, and gets headaches. The teacher agrees to observe in class and try some simple strategies: using a ruler under the line of text, offering audiobook versions alongside physical books, and focusing on comprehension through discussion rather than just oral reading fluency for a while. They agree to check in weekly.
After a month, some things help slightly, but Aiden still struggles intensely with decoding new words. Now, the conversation about a potential evaluation feels different. It’s not a sudden, scary leap, but the logical next step based on documented concerns and attempted interventions. Priya feels like a partner in the process, armed with observations and data. She understands the evaluation isn’t about a label for its own sake, but about unlocking the specific strategies that will help Aiden succeed.
Telling a concerned parent to “just get a full evaluation” often skips the crucial groundwork. It risks overwhelming them, dismissing simpler solutions, and creating unnecessary fear. By starting with empathy, focused observation, collaborative problem-solving, and clear communication, we empower parents to be informed advocates. We build trust. And then, when an evaluation is truly indicated, it becomes a powerful tool embraced as part of a supportive journey, not a daunting command issued at the very first sign of trouble. The best support begins with understanding, not a diagnosis form.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Rethinking That First Piece of Advice: Why “Get an Evaluation” Isn’t Always the Best Starting Point