Why “Just Get an Evaluation” Might Be the Worst Thing to Say to Worried Parents
It happens countless times a day. A parent tentatively shares a concern about their child’s development, learning, or behavior. Maybe it’s to a teacher after a conference, a pediatrician during a well-check, or a friend over coffee. And the well-meaning response often comes swiftly: “You should just get a full evaluation.”
On the surface, it sounds logical, even helpful. Get the answers, right? Identify the need, access support. But more often than we realize, that phrase – “just get a full evaluation” – lands like a lead balloon. It can shut down conversation, overwhelm the parent, and sometimes even be the worst possible first step. Here’s why:
1. It Dismisses the Emotional Weight: That initial sharing is rarely casual. It’s often laced with anxiety, confusion, guilt, or fear. Parents might have wrestled with their worries for months, terrified of “overreacting” or being labeled. Throwing out “just get an evaluation” skips right over validating those feelings. It implies the solution is simple, mechanical, and immediate, minimizing the complex emotional journey they’re navigating. It can make them feel unheard and more isolated.
2. It Overwhelms Before They’re Ready: “Full evaluation.” What does that even mean? To a parent new to the world of developmental assessments, psychoeducational testing, or neurological consults, it sounds like a massive, expensive, bureaucratic labyrinth. Who do they call? Where do they start? What tests are involved? How much will it cost? Will insurance cover it? The sheer scope of “get a full evaluation” can be paralyzing, adding logistical panic to existing emotional strain. It’s like telling someone lost in a forest to “just find the main road” without a map or compass.
3. It Skips Crucial Exploration: Jumping straight to a formal evaluation often bypasses essential groundwork. It assumes the parent has already gathered enough observation or that the concern is severe enough to warrant immediate, comprehensive testing. But many concerns benefit enormously from a period of observation, documentation, and low-stakes intervention first. A teacher might implement minor classroom strategies; a pediatrician might suggest monitoring sleep patterns or minor dietary tweaks; parents could track specific behaviors at home. This initial phase provides vital context for if and what kind of evaluation is truly needed later.
4. It Can Prematurely Frame the Narrative: Suggesting an evaluation immediately positions the child within a potential “problem” or “deficit” framework. While evaluations aim for understanding, the suggestion alone can solidify a parent’s worst fears prematurely. It can shift their focus entirely onto finding a diagnosis, potentially overlooking simpler explanations or environmental factors contributing to the concern. Sometimes, the initial issue resolves with minor adjustments, making a formal evaluation unnecessary and potentially stressful for the child.
5. It Neglects Building Trust and Partnership: Effective support for a child hinges on strong collaboration between parents and professionals. Telling parents to “just get an evaluation” feels like passing the buck. It doesn’t foster a sense of partnership. Contrast this with: “That sounds really tough. Tell me more about what you’re seeing. Let’s track this together for a few weeks and see what patterns emerge. I can share some strategies we can try right now, and we can figure out the next steps together.” This approach builds trust and empowers parents as active participants, rather than passive recipients of a directive.
So, What’s a Better First Step?
Instead of reaching for the “evaluation” card immediately, try these more supportive entry points:
Listen Deeply and Validate: “I hear how worried you are about this. It makes sense that you’re concerned.” Acknowledge their feelings before diving into solutions.
Ask Open-Ended Questions: “Can you tell me more about what you’re noticing? When does it happen most? What have you tried so far?” Gather detailed information.
Collaborate on Observation: “Would you be willing to jot down some notes over the next week or two about when X happens? I’ll do the same here [in class/at daycare]. Let’s compare notes.” Concrete data is invaluable.
Suggest Simple, Actionable Strategies: “Based on what you’re describing, here are a couple of things we could try at home/in the classroom right now to see if it helps. It might give us more clues.” Focus on small, immediate steps.
Provide Reassurance and Frame Positively: “Children develop at different paces. Let’s gather more information together. This is about understanding how best to support [Child’s Name].” Emphasize understanding and support over “fixing.”
Outline Potential Pathways Gently: “If we try these things and the concerns persist, then exploring a more formal evaluation could be a helpful next step to get deeper insights. We can talk about what that involves when and if we get there.” Position evaluation as one possible future step, not the only first step.
Offer Resources (Carefully): Instead of “Get an evaluation,” try: “There’s a great local parent support group,” or “This website has reliable information on developmental milestones,” or “I can connect you with someone who can help navigate options if we decide we need more information later.”
When Is an Evaluation the Right First Step?
Absolutely, there are times when suggesting an evaluation promptly is crucial:
Significant Safety Concerns: If a child’s behavior poses an immediate danger to themselves or others.
Severe Regression: Marked loss of previously acquired skills (language, social, motor).
Clear, Persistent Red Flags: Concerns aligning strongly with known indicators of specific conditions needing early intervention (e.g., certain autism spectrum signs, profound dyslexia symptoms).
Parent Request After Exploration: When parents, after initial observation and strategies, feel strongly that a formal assessment is necessary for clarity and access to services.
The Bottom Line
Telling worried parents to “just get a full evaluation” often comes from a place of wanting to help. But its impact is frequently the opposite. It can feel dismissive, overwhelming, and premature. By shifting our first response to deep listening, collaborative exploration, and simple actionable steps, we build trust, reduce anxiety, gather better information, and empower parents. We create a foundation where if an evaluation becomes necessary later, it happens from a place of shared understanding and readiness, not panic or isolation. The goal isn’t to avoid evaluations, but to ensure they are pursued thoughtfully, collaboratively, and at the right time, as part of a supportive journey to understand and nurture a child. So next time a parent shares a concern, pause before offering that “simple” solution. Start with connection, not the clipboard.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why “Just Get an Evaluation” Might Be the Worst Thing to Say to Worried Parents