The Tutor’s Secret Weapon: Why Knowing What Actually Explains Well Changes Everything
Imagine standing before a student, a tricky concept in hand. You craft an explanation, drawing on your knowledge and experience. You deliver it clearly, using analogies, diagrams, maybe even a quick demonstration. The student nods. “Got it,” they say. Relief washes over you. But a week later, during review… blank stares. That “got it” was fleeting. The concept remains elusive. Sound familiar? This is the universal tutor’s dilemma: How do you know if your explanation truly landed? More crucially, would tutors find it incredibly useful to know which explanations actually worked?
The answer, unequivocally, is a resounding YES. Feedback on explanation effectiveness isn’t just helpful; it’s transformative for tutors and students alike. It shifts tutoring from an educated guessing game into a precise science of understanding.
Why Explanations Are the Core of Tutoring (And Why They Often Miss the Mark)
At its heart, tutoring is about bridging gaps in understanding. Explanations are the primary tools we use to build those bridges. But here’s the catch:
1. The Illusion of Transparency: Tutors, steeped in their subject, often overestimate how clear their explanations are. What seems obvious to us might be a tangled mess for the learner.
2. The Silent Nod: Students, wanting to please or avoid looking “dumb,” often nod along even when utterly lost. This provides false positive feedback.
3. One Size Doesn’t Fit All: An analogy that clicks perfectly for Student A might completely baffle Student B. Without knowing which approach resonates with whom, we waste time reinventing the wheel.
4. The Memory Mirage: Tutors often rely on recalling what worked generally in the past, but individual student needs vary wildly. Specific feedback cuts through the fog.
Knowing “What Worked” Isn’t Just Nice – It’s Game-Changing
Understanding the specific explanations that unlock understanding for individual students provides tutors with powerful advantages:
1. Hyper-Personalization: Imagine having a personalized toolkit for each student. Feedback tells you: “For this student struggling with fractions, the ‘pizza slice’ analogy was magic, but the ‘number line’ visualization fell flat.” Next session? You go straight to pizza slices and build from there, saving precious time and boosting efficiency.
2. Building a Repertoire of Proven Tactics: Over time, gathering this feedback creates a tutor’s personal “goldmine” of effective explanations. You start to see patterns: visual learners respond best to X, auditory learners grasp Y analogy quickly, kinaesthetic learners need Z type of demonstration for concept ABC. This curated repertoire makes you faster and more adaptable.
3. Boosting Tutor Confidence & Reducing Burnout: Constantly questioning if you’re getting through is exhausting. Concrete feedback like, “That specific breakdown of the photosynthesis equation finally made it click for Sarah,” is incredibly validating. It confirms your impact and replaces doubt with confidence. Knowing you have reliable tools reduces the stress of the unknown.
4. Pinpointing Knowledge Gaps (Yours & Theirs): Sometimes, an explanation fails because the student lacks a foundational piece you assumed they knew. Feedback highlighting where the explanation broke down (“They understood step 1 and 2, but step 3 lost them completely”) helps you diagnose the real starting point. It might also reveal a gap in your ability to explain that specific step – prompting valuable professional reflection.
5. Enabling Truly Responsive Teaching: Tutoring should be a dynamic conversation, not a monologue. Knowing what explanation worked allows you to pivot during a session. If Plan A fails, you can confidently pull out Plan B or C from your proven arsenal, rather than fumbling for alternatives.
6. Improving Communication Beyond Explanations: The process of seeking and receiving feedback fosters better overall communication between tutor and student. It signals to the student that you genuinely care about their understanding, not just delivering content. It builds trust and a collaborative learning environment.
“Feedback Needed”: How Do We Actually Get This Gold?
This is the million-dollar question. Knowing it’s useful is one thing; obtaining specific, actionable feedback on explanation effectiveness is another. It requires intentional effort:
1. Ask Specific Questions (Not “Do you understand?”):
Instead of: “Got that?”
Try: “Okay, can you explain that concept back to me in your own words?” (Forces synthesis).
Try: “Which part of what I just said made the most sense to you?” or “Was there any part that still feels a bit fuzzy?” (Targets specific parts).
Try: “I explained that a couple of ways – the analogy about [X] or the step-by-step breakdown. Which one helped you more?” (Directly compares methods).
2. Use “Show Me” Techniques:
“Can you solve this similar problem using the method we just talked about?” (Demonstrates application).
“Draw a quick sketch of how you visualize this process now.” (Reveals mental models).
3. Leverage Quick Checks (Formative Assessment):
Use mini-whiteboards for students to write answers or key points.
Use simple online polls or quizzes at the end of a topic to gauge understanding of specific explanations covered.
Ask for a 1-minute written summary.
4. Create a Safe Space for “I Don’t Get It”: Explicitly tell students it’s expected and valuable to say when something isn’t clear. Normalize the struggle. “Great, pointing out that it’s confusing helps me explain it better. Let’s tackle that part again differently.”
5. Observe & Listen Intently: Pay attention to body language (furrowed brows, nodding, eyes lighting up), the quality of follow-up questions, and the ease with which they tackle related problems after your explanation.
6. Reflective Practice (For the Tutor): After a session, briefly note: “Tried explanation A for concept X with Student Y. Seemed to work well based on their problem-solving.” or “Explanation B for Z fell flat – need alternative approach next time.”
Challenges? Sure. Worth It? Absolutely.
Getting truly granular feedback takes time and practice. Students might struggle to articulate why something worked. Younger students might find it particularly hard. It requires tutors to be vulnerable, open to critique, and adaptable.
But the payoff dwarfs the effort. Moving beyond the vague feeling of “I think that went okay” to the concrete knowledge that “That specific explanation unlocked understanding for this specific student” is revolutionary. It transforms tutoring from an art form guided by intuition into a more refined practice guided by evidence.
The Bottom Line for Tutors
Knowing which explanations actually work isn’t just a “nice-to-have”; it’s a fundamental lever for improving your effectiveness, efficiency, and impact. It empowers you to tailor your approach with laser focus, build confidence in your methods, reduce frustration (for both you and your student), and ultimately, become a significantly better tutor. It turns the often-invisible process of understanding into something tangible you can observe, refine, and replicate. Seeking and acting on this specific type of feedback is the mark of a truly reflective and dedicated professional. Embrace the quest for “what worked” – it’s the secret weapon hiding in plain sight, waiting to unlock your students’ potential and elevate your tutoring practice to the next level. Don’t just explain; know what explains best.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Tutor’s Secret Weapon: Why Knowing What Actually Explains Well Changes Everything