The Tutor’s Secret Weapon: Knowing Which Explanations Actually Click
Imagine this: Sarah, a dedicated math tutor, spends ten minutes walking her student, Alex, through a tricky algebra concept using her favorite analogy – comparing equations to balancing scales. Alex nods politely. Sarah moves on, assuming understanding. The next week, Alex struggles with related problems, clearly lost. What went wrong? Did the scale analogy actually work? Or was Alex just nodding to be polite? This scenario highlights a fundamental challenge in tutoring: how do tutors really know which explanations hit the mark?
The answer seems obvious: Of course tutors would find it incredibly useful to know which explanations actually worked. But the reality is, getting clear, actionable feedback on the specific effectiveness of different teaching approaches is often elusive and underutilized. Let’s dive into why this knowledge is a game-changer and how tutors can actively seek it out.
Why Knowing “What Worked” is Transformative for Tutors
1. Personalization Powerhouse: Every student is unique. What illuminates a concept for one might confuse another. Knowing which explanation resonated with which student allows tutors to build a personalized toolbox. Instead of guessing, Sarah could recall, “Ah, for visual learners like Jamie, the graph method clicked instantly, but for logical thinkers like Ben, the step-by-step breakdown was key.” This precision dramatically boosts efficiency and effectiveness.
2. Time Optimization: Tutoring time is precious. Wasting minutes on an explanation that falls flat is frustrating for everyone. Identifying explanations that consistently yield understanding lets tutors deploy them confidently, maximizing productive learning time. They can ditch approaches that rarely work and refine those that show promise.
3. Confidence and Clarity: There’s immense professional satisfaction in knowing you helped a student grasp a concept. Specific feedback on successful explanations validates the tutor’s skills and provides concrete evidence of their impact. It combats the nagging doubt of “Did they really get it?”
4. Closing the Feedback Loop: Teaching is inherently a feedback-driven process. Without knowing what worked, the loop is broken. Effective feedback allows tutors to adapt in real-time and long-term. If Sarah knew the scale analogy failed Alex, she could immediately pivot to a number line example during that same session.
5. Refining the Craft: Tutors are constantly evolving. Knowing what works provides invaluable data for professional growth. It helps them identify their own strengths (“I’m really good at explaining quadratic equations using real-world projectile examples”) and areas needing development (“I need more strategies for teaching abstract grammar rules”).
6. Building Student Self-Awareness: The process of gathering feedback makes students more aware of their own learning. Asking “Which part of that explanation made it click for you?” encourages metacognition – thinking about their thinking. This is a crucial skill for independent learning.
The Feedback Gap: Why It’s Hard to Get This Information
Despite its clear value, tutors often operate without this specific feedback:
The “Nod of Agreement”: Students, especially younger ones or those who are shy, often nod or say “yes” to indicate they’re following along, even when they’re not fully grasping the concept. They might fear appearing slow or disappointing the tutor.
Lack of Specific Questions: Tutors often ask broad questions like “Do you understand?” or “Any questions?” which rarely elicit specific feedback on which part of the explanation was effective. Students might just say “yes” or ask about a different point entirely.
Focus on Answers, Not Process: Feedback often centers on whether the student got the answer right on a problem, not which explanation led to that understanding. A correct answer doesn’t always reveal if the student truly internalized the concept or just memorized a step.
Assumption is Easier: It’s simpler to assume an explanation worked if the student doesn’t immediately object or if they solve one subsequent problem correctly. Deep understanding isn’t always immediately apparent.
How Tutors Can Actively Gather “What Worked” Feedback (Actionable Strategies!)
Knowing the why is important, but the how is crucial. Here’s how tutors can proactively seek this golden feedback:
1. Ask Specific, Reflective Questions (Post-Explanation):
“Okay, we just covered [Concept]. What one part of what I just said made the most sense to you?”
“Was there a particular example or analogy I used that helped you picture this?”
“Think back to when it started to make sense. What did I say or do right before that ‘aha’ moment?”
“If you had to explain this back to me in your own words right now, what would be the main idea?” (This reveals their understanding derived from your explanation).
2. Offer Choice & Observe: Present two different ways to approach the same problem or concept. “We could look at this using [Method A] or [Method B]. Which one seems like it might make more sense to try first?” Observe their reaction during and after each method. Which one did they engage with more? Which one led to more independent application?
3. The “Teach-Back” Method: After explaining a concept, ask the student to teach it back to you, as if you were a complete beginner. Listen carefully to the language they use, the examples they choose, and the points they emphasize. This reveals which parts of your explanation they internalized most effectively.
4. Utilize Mini-Assessments (Formative Checks): Don’t just wait for the end-of-session quiz. After explaining a key point, give one very specific practice problem that directly tests that specific aspect of your explanation. Did they apply the concept correctly immediately after hearing it? This provides instant feedback on the effectiveness of that particular explanation.
5. Leverage Concept Mapping or Diagrams: Ask students to create a quick mind map or diagram summarizing what they just learned based on your explanation. What connections did they make? What stands out as the central idea? This visual output reflects what resonated most clearly.
6. Regular “Feedback Pulse” Checks: Briefly at the end of a session, or during a mid-point check-in, ask: “Today we covered [Topic A] and [Topic B]. Which one feels clearer to you right now? What about the way we approached it helped?” Focus the reflection.
7. Create a Safe Environment: Crucially, students need to feel safe admitting confusion without judgment. Explicitly state, “It’s totally okay if something didn’t land perfectly. In fact, telling me exactly what was fuzzy helps me help you better next time. That’s how I learn to be a better tutor for you.”
Beyond the Session: Building a Feedback Library
The most effective tutors don’t just gather feedback; they use it systematically:
Brief Session Notes: Jot down quick notes after each session: “Explained [Concept] using [Method X] – seemed effective for [Student Y] based on [Observation/Student comment].” “Tried [Analogy Z] for [Concept] – [Student A] looked confused; pivoted to [Method B] which worked better.”
Pattern Recognition: Review notes periodically. Do you see patterns? Does a certain approach consistently work well for a specific type of learner or concept? Does another approach often lead to confusion?
Refine Your Toolkit: Actively add your proven explanations to your mental (or physical) toolkit. Phase out methods that consistently yield poor results or confusion.
Conclusion: Feedback is the Compass
For tutors, knowing which explanations truly “land” isn’t just useful – it’s fundamental to their effectiveness. It transforms tutoring from a guessing game into a targeted, evidence-based practice. It builds tutor confidence, saves valuable time, deepens student understanding, and fosters a more collaborative learning partnership. By moving beyond the “Do you understand?” question and embracing specific, reflective, and safe feedback practices, tutors unlock a powerful secret weapon: the clear knowledge of what actually helps their students learn. Asking “Would tutors find it useful?” is almost rhetorical. The real question is: how can any dedicated tutor afford not to seek this vital information? Make gathering this specific feedback a core part of your tutoring routine – it’s the compass that guides you towards truly impactful teaching. Start asking the specific questions in your next session; the insights you gain will be your most valuable teaching resource.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Tutor’s Secret Weapon: Knowing Which Explanations Actually Click