The A+ Question That Keeps Students Up at Night (And What Really Matters Instead)
That crisp report card lands in your hands, or maybe the notification pops up online. Your eyes scan downward… B+, A-, A… and then there it is. The A+. Relief? Absolutely. Pride? Definitely. But then, maybe a whisper in the back of your mind: “Do I really deserve this?”
It’s a question more common than you might think. That shiny, perfect grade isn’t just a mark; it often feels like a verdict on your intelligence, your effort, your very worth as a student. But the path to understanding whether you “deserved” that A+ is way more nuanced than just checking boxes on a rubric. Let’s unpack it.
Beyond Checking Boxes: What Does an A+ Actually Represent?
On the surface, an A+ usually signifies “excellence” or “superior mastery” of the material. It means you:
1. Hit Every Target: You demonstrably understood and applied all the core concepts, skills, and knowledge the course covered. You didn’t just grasp the basics; you likely explored complexities.
2. Excelled in Execution: Your work wasn’t just correct; it was insightful, polished, and often went beyond the basic requirements. Think essays with unique arguments, science projects with meticulous methodology, math solutions demonstrating elegant reasoning.
3. Consistently Delivered: This wasn’t a one-off brilliant performance. Your assignments, participation, tests – across the board – reflected a high standard maintained throughout the course.
4. Mastered the Rubric: You understood exactly what the teacher was looking for and delivered work that perfectly aligned with (or exceeded) those specific assessment criteria.
So, Why the Nagging Doubt? The Complexities Beneath the Surface
Even if you ticked all those boxes, the doubt can creep in. Here’s why:
The Effort vs. Outcome Trap: “But it felt easy for me!” This is a big one. We often equate “deserving” with grueling struggle. If a subject comes naturally, or you found the workload manageable, you might feel like you didn’t suffer enough for that top grade. Remember: Mastery isn’t defined by struggle, but by demonstrated understanding and skill. Efficiency and natural aptitude are assets, not disqualifiers!
Subjectivity in the Spotlight: Especially in subjects like English, history, or art, evaluation isn’t purely mathematical. Interpretation, style, and argument strength play a huge role. You might wonder, “Did the teacher just like my perspective?” While subjectivity exists, a genuine A+ usually involves work that’s undeniably strong on multiple objective levels as well as being subjectively compelling.
The “Could I Have Done More?” Conundrum: Perfectionists live here. There’s always another article you could have read, another draft you could have written, another problem set you could have attempted. An A+ doesn’t demand the impossible – it demands excellence within the defined scope and timeframe of the course. Holding yourself to an unrealistic standard of infinite effort is a recipe for constant dissatisfaction.
Comparison is the Thief of Joy: Seeing a classmate pour blood, sweat, and tears into a B+ while you got an A+ with (seemingly) less visible effort can trigger guilt. Remember: Everyone’s learning journey, background knowledge, and processing speeds are different. Their struggle doesn’t invalidate your mastery. Focus on your own path.
Grading Isn’t Always Perfect: Yes, sometimes grades might be slightly inflated, or a grading oversight might occur. While rare for a single A+ to be a complete error, systemic issues can exist. If you have concrete evidence something was graded unfairly in your favor, it’s worth a quiet conversation with the teacher. But constant suspicion without basis undermines your own achievement.
Shifting the Focus: What “Deserving” Should Really Mean
Instead of getting stuck on the existential “Do I deserve this?”, try reframing the question towards more productive and healthier measures of success:
1. Did I Learn Deeply? This is the core purpose. Does that A+ represent genuine intellectual growth, new skills acquired, and a deeper understanding of the world? If yes, that’s the ultimate win. The grade is a symbol; the knowledge and ability are the real treasures.
2. Did I Engage Authentically? Were you curious? Did you ask questions, participate thoughtfully, and wrestle with challenging ideas? Active engagement is a huge part of deserving success, regardless of whether every answer was perfect.
3. Did I Give My Appropriate Best? Not “theoretical maximum possible effort,” but the best effort you could reasonably sustain within the context of your entire life (other courses, health, responsibilities). Did you manage your time, seek help when needed, and apply yourself diligently? That’s deserving.
4. Have I Developed Valuable Skills? Beyond the subject matter, did you improve your critical thinking, research abilities, communication, or problem-solving? These transferable skills are often the most valuable outcome of any course.
5. Can I Build On This? Does this success give you confidence, a stronger foundation, and momentum for future learning? That’s a sign the grade reflects real progress.
What If You Feel You Didn’t Deserve It?
Honest self-reflection is crucial. If you look back and think:
“I crammed the night before every test and forgot it all immediately,” or
“I didn’t actually understand the core concepts, I just memorized patterns,” or
“My participation was minimal, and I did the bare minimum on assignments,” or
“I know there was a grading error that wasn’t caught,”…
…then the A+ might feel hollow. This isn’t about beating yourself up; it’s about integrity and understanding the difference between a mark and genuine mastery. Use that feeling as motivation for a different approach next time, focusing on deep learning over chasing the symbol. Talk to the teacher if there’s a genuine concern about an error.
The Final Bell: Beyond the A+
That A+ is a significant accomplishment – acknowledge it! Celebrate the hard work, intelligence, or effective strategies that got you there. But anchor your sense of deserving in the deeper measures: the knowledge gained, the skills honed, the curiosity nurtured, and the honest effort you invested.
The most successful learners aren’t always the ones with straight A+ transcripts; they’re the ones who consistently ask questions, embrace challenges, learn from mistakes (and grades!), and understand that true “deserving” comes from a commitment to continuous growth. The A+ is a fantastic mile marker on that journey, but it’s not the final destination. Focus on becoming the kind of thinker and doer who deserves their own respect, and the grades will often follow as a natural consequence. Now that’s an achievement worth striving for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The A+ Question That Keeps Students Up at Night (And What Really Matters Instead)