The Writer’s Constant Question: “Would You Consider This Long Enough?” (And Why It’s the Wrong One)
That blinking cursor. The word counter steadily climbing. The nagging doubt creeping in as you near what you think might be the finish line: “Would you consider this long enough?” It’s a question that haunts writers, bloggers, students, and professionals alike. We pour effort into crafting content, only to get stuck wondering if the sheer amount of words we’ve produced passes some invisible threshold. But here’s the uncomfortable truth: obsessing over word count alone is often missing the point entirely. The real question isn’t about length; it’s about value.
Why We Get Hooked on the Number
Let’s be honest, the fixation on length isn’t baseless. Some roots run deep:
1. The Ghost of School Papers: Remember those assignments demanding “at least 500 words” or “no more than 3 pages”? Early experiences ingrained the idea that length equals effort or completeness. Hitting the target felt like success, regardless of substance.
2. SEO Noise (Shhh!): While we won’t dive deep into the technical weeds, whispers circulate online about ideal word counts for search visibility. This can make writers anxious about falling short of an arbitrary benchmark, fearing their work won’t be seen.
3. Perceived Authority: There’s an underlying assumption, sometimes true but often not, that longer pieces inherently carry more weight, expertise, or thoroughness. We worry a short piece might seem flimsy or unsubstantial.
4. The “Am I Done?” Dilemma: Word count offers a seemingly concrete metric. When you’re deep in the writing trenches, unsure if you’ve covered everything, checking the number feels like a tangible progress report. “2,000 words? That must be enough, right?”
Shifting the Focus: From Quantity to Quality
Forget the ruler; grab a compass. The direction your content takes is infinitely more important than the distance it travels. Here’s what truly matters:
Purpose: Why are you writing this? Is it to solve a specific problem? Explain a complex concept? Persuade someone? Entertain? Tell a story? The goal dictates the necessary scope. A quick troubleshooting guide doesn’t need the depth of an academic thesis. A heartfelt personal essay might be powerful precisely because it’s concise.
Audience Needs: Who are you talking to? Busy professionals skimming on a coffee break crave brevity and clear takeaways. Academics researching a niche topic expect thorough exploration and extensive referencing. Hobbyists diving deep into a passion might relish the details. Are you giving your specific reader what they need?
Topic Complexity: Some subjects are simple. Explaining how to boil an egg doesn’t require 1,000 words (unless you’re diving into the fascinating science of protein denaturation!). Others, like quantum mechanics or nuanced social issues, inherently demand more space to unpack meaningfully without oversimplifying. Does the length match the inherent depth required?
Clarity and Completeness: This is paramount. Have you explained the core idea(s) clearly? Have you addressed the key questions a reasonable reader would have? Have you provided sufficient context, evidence, or examples to support your points without becoming redundant? Does the piece feel logically complete, or does it end abruptly, leaving gaps?
Engagement: Are you holding the reader’s attention? Length becomes irrelevant if the writing is dense, meandering, or dull. Conversely, a riveting short story can feel incredibly “full” despite its brevity. Does every paragraph earn its place? Is the pace appropriate?
What “Long Enough” Actually Looks Like (In Practice)
Let’s ditch theory for examples:
The Blog Post (Problem-Solving): Topic: “How to Fix a Leaky Faucet.” “Long Enough”: Covers the common causes, lists needed tools clearly, provides step-by-step instructions with safety tips, includes a brief troubleshooting section for common mistakes, and ends with when to call a plumber. (~800-1000 words might suffice). Not Long Enough: Just lists the steps without explaining why they matter or what tools to use. Too Long: Dedicates 500 words to the history of plumbing.
The University Essay: Topic: “Analyze the Causes of the French Revolution.” “Long Enough”: Clearly defines the scope, presents a clear thesis, explores multiple key factors (social, economic, political, intellectual) with supporting evidence from credible sources, analyzes their interconnections, addresses potential counterarguments, and provides a strong conclusion. (~1500-2500+ words expected). Not Long Enough: Only mentions one cause superficially. Too Long: Repeats points endlessly or includes vast amounts of irrelevant historical detail.
The Marketing Email: Goal: Announce a new product feature. “Long Enough”: Captivating subject line, clear announcement of the feature, concise explanation of the key benefit to the customer, a strong visual or GIF, a clear call to action (e.g., “Try it Now” link). (~150-300 words). Not Long Enough: Subject line: “New Feature!” Body: “Check out our new thing!” (No link, no explanation). Too Long: Life story of the developer, excessive technical jargon, multiple paragraphs before the CTA.
The Children’s Story: “Long Enough”: Introduces relatable characters, establishes a simple conflict or goal, follows a clear sequence of events leading to a resolution, uses age-appropriate language and engaging descriptions, has a satisfying ending. (Word count varies drastically by age group – a picture book might be 500 words, a chapter book for older kids 5000+). Not Long Enough: Story feels rushed, characters undeveloped, conflict unresolved. Too Long: Overly complex plot, verbose descriptions that lose a child’s attention.
Strategies to Move Beyond the Word Count Worry
So, how do you silence that nagging “Is it long enough?” voice and focus on what counts?
1. Define Success First: Before writing a word, clarify: What is the ONE main thing I want the reader to know/feel/do? Who is my reader? What specific problem am I solving for them?
2. Outline with Purpose: Structure your outline around your core message and the necessary supporting points. Ask for each section: “Is this essential for achieving my purpose for this audience?”
3. Write Freely (First): Get your ideas down without constantly checking the counter. Focus on covering the necessary ground defined by your purpose and outline.
4. Edit Ruthlessly for Value: This is where the magic happens. Read critically:
Cut Fluff: Remove redundant sentences, unnecessary adverbs, vague phrases, tangents.
Strengthen Weak Points: Where is an idea underdeveloped? Where does the reader need more explanation or a concrete example? Add substance where value is lacking, not just words for the sake of words.
Check Flow: Does the argument or narrative progress logically? Are transitions smooth?
Assess Completeness: Does it fulfill the promise made at the beginning? Are key questions answered?
5. Read Aloud: This exposes awkward phrasing, run-on sentences, and sections where attention might wane.
6. Seek Feedback (Wisely): Instead of asking “Is this long enough?”, ask specific questions: “Does this explanation make sense?” “Did I cover the most important points?” “Was there any part that felt confusing or unnecessary?” “Did you feel the piece achieved its goal?”
The Ultimate Measure: Reader Impact
Forget the arbitrary benchmarks. The true answer to “Would you consider this long enough?” lies solely with your reader.
Did they find it clear?
Did they learn something valuable?
Did it solve their problem or answer their question?
Did it engage them and hold their attention?
Did it feel complete and satisfying?
If you can confidently answer “yes” to the questions that matter for your specific purpose and audience, then yes – it is absolutely long enough. It might be 500 powerful words or 5000 meticulously researched ones. The number on the page is just a side effect. The real measure is the resonance your words create in the mind of the person who reads them. Focus on delivering genuine value, and the question of length will fade into the background where it belongs. Write with purpose, edit with intention, and trust that when the content fulfills its mission, it has achieved the perfect length.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Writer’s Constant Question: “Would You Consider This Long Enough