The Unexpected Weight of Six Words: When a Parent’s Words Changed Everything
It happened during one of those ordinary after-school conversations, the kind that usually blur into the background noise of parent-teacher meetings. We were discussing Liam, a bright but often quiet student in my fifth-grade class. His mom, Sarah, leaned forward slightly, her expression a mix of warmth and something else – a quiet intensity. “You know,” she said, her voice softening, “Liam mentioned something last week that really stayed with him.”
I nodded, ready for the usual feedback about homework or a classroom activity. But what came next hit me harder than I ever expected.
“He said you asked him how he felt, not just what he did.”
Six simple words. Yet, they landed like a pebble dropped into still water, sending ripples through everything I thought I knew about connecting with kids.
Beyond the Transaction: The Shift That Resonated
For years, my interactions with students often followed a familiar script:
“Did you finish the assignment?”
“What did you learn today?”
“Tell me about your project.”
These weren’t bad questions. They focused on actions, outcomes, and observable progress – the tangible stuff of education. But Sarah’s quiet observation exposed a gap I hadn’t fully acknowledged: I was prioritizing the what over the who. Liam wasn’t just a vessel for absorbing math facts or writing paragraphs; he was a whole person, navigating a complex inner world of feelings, anxieties, and quiet triumphs.
My question – “How did you feel about presenting your project today, Liam?” – had been almost incidental. For me, it was a minor detour from the main road of academic progress. For him, it was a signal. It told him I saw more than just his performance; I was curious about his experience of it. That tiny shift from the external action to his internal landscape made him feel genuinely seen and valued. Sarah’s words were a powerful mirror held up to my practice.
Why “How Do You Feel?” Holds Such Power
That conversation with Liam’s mom became a turning point, forcing me to re-examine the core of meaningful communication, especially with children:
1. It Validates the Inner World: Children constantly process emotions they may not fully understand or have the vocabulary to express. Asking “how do you feel?” acknowledges that their inner experience is real, important, and worthy of attention. It says, “Your feelings about this matter as much as the thing itself.”
2. It Builds Trust and Safety: When we ask about feelings – and truly listen to the answer without judgment – we create a safe space. Kids learn they can bring their authentic selves, fears included, into the relationship. Liam felt safe enough to share that moment with his mom precisely because he felt safe with me.
3. It Moves Beyond Performance: Constant focus on doing and achieving can create immense pressure. Asking “how do you feel?” shifts the focus, even momentarily, from outcome to process, from product to person. It helps kids understand their worth isn’t solely tied to success or failure.
4. It Provides Crucial Insight: Understanding a child’s emotional state is often the key to unlocking their potential. Knowing Liam felt proud but nervous about his presentation explained his quiet demeanor afterward far better than just knowing his grade. This insight is invaluable for teachers and parents alike.
Transforming Conversations: Putting Insight into Action
Sarah’s simple statement fundamentally altered my approach. It wasn’t about abandoning academic goals; it was about enriching the human context around them. Here’s how that insight reshaped my conversations, both in the classroom and when talking with parents:
Listen Beyond the Words: Instead of just waiting for the report (“I played soccer”), I consciously listen for the emotional undercurrent (“I played soccer… but I was nervous about taking a penalty kick”). A gentle “How did that nervousness feel?” opens a deeper door than “Did you score?”
Embrace the Silence After the Question: Asking “How did that make you feel?” often requires patience. Kids need time to locate their feelings and find the words. Sitting comfortably in that silence is crucial; rushing to fill it shuts down the process.
Reflect and Normalize: When a child shares a feeling, especially a difficult one like frustration or sadness, I acknowledge it directly: “It sounds like that was really frustrating for you,” or “Feeling sad when that happened makes total sense.” This validation is powerful.
Ask Openly, Without Leading: Instead of “You must have been happy about that A!” try “How did you feel when you saw your grade?” Let them define their own emotional experience. They might be relieved, surprised, or even worried about expectations – not necessarily just “happy.”
Apply it to Challenges: This approach is perhaps most vital when things go wrong. Instead of launching straight into “Why didn’t you finish?” try “How are you feeling about this assignment? Is something making it tough?” This often reveals root causes (confusion, overwhelm, anxiety) that a simple “why” question misses.
The Ripple Effect: Stronger Connections, Deeper Learning
The impact of focusing on the “how do you feel?” dimension has been profound. Students like Liam seem more willing to take risks, ask for help, and engage authentically. They sense they are more than just a name on a roster or a set of grades. Conversations with parents have also shifted. Rather than just reporting on behavior or achievement, we often find ourselves discussing the child’s emotional landscape and resilience – a far more meaningful collaboration.
Sarah’s words were a gift, though she likely never realized their weight. They reminded me that education, at its heart, is deeply human. It’s not just about filling minds with information; it’s about nurturing whole people. The “what” – the facts, the skills, the completed tasks – is undeniably important. But the “how” – how a child feels seen, how they experience challenge, how they navigate their own growth – is the soil in which true learning and confidence take root.
It’s amazing how six simple words, spoken by a perceptive parent, can recalibrate your entire perspective. The next time you talk with a child – your own, a student, a niece, or nephew – pause. Move beyond the easy “What did you do today?” Lean in, and gently ask, “How did you feel about that?” You might just be surprised by the depth you find, and the connection you build. That small question carries an unexpected weight, one that can shape a child’s world far more than we might ever guess.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Unexpected Weight of Six Words: When a Parent’s Words Changed Everything