When Your Teacher Says Your Notes Aren’t Working: Finding Your Groove
It stings, doesn’t it? You’ve been diligently scribbling away in class, trying to capture everything your teacher says, maybe even adding your own doodles or color-coding like a pro. Then, the words hit: “I’m not sure your way of making notes is very useful.” Ouch. Defensiveness, confusion, maybe even a bit of resentment bubble up. Before you crumple those pages (or slam your laptop shut), take a breath. This isn’t necessarily a failing grade on your effort; it might be the start of discovering a better way to learn.
Why Might Your Teacher Say That? (It’s Not Always Personal)
Teachers see hundreds of students and note-taking styles over the years. Their comment likely comes from observation, not a desire to criticize you. Consider these possibilities:
1. The “Capture Everything” Trap: Maybe you are writing down nearly every word verbatim. While it feels thorough, this often means you’re so focused on transcribing that you’re not processing the information in real-time. You end up with pages of text but little understanding. Your teacher might see you struggling to keep up or notice you aren’t engaging in discussions.
2. The “Too Sparse” Enigma: On the flip side, maybe your notes are incredibly minimal – a few keywords, arrows everywhere, maybe just headings. While this works for some brilliant minds, it can often lack the context needed later. When you review, do those cryptic symbols actually make sense? If your teacher sees gaps or confusion during revision time, they might flag it.
3. The “Beautiful but Burdensome” Effect: Do your notes look like a work of art? Detailed color schemes, perfect handwriting, intricate diagrams? That’s fantastic creativity! But if spending 10 minutes color-coding one heading means you miss the next three key points, the method might be hindering the capture. Efficiency matters.
4. Missing the Core Concepts: Sometimes notes focus heavily on examples or minor details while glossing over the fundamental principles or the “why” behind the information. Your teacher knows what’s truly essential for understanding and exams; they might feel your notes aren’t highlighting these critical elements.
5. Not Aligned with the Learning Goal: Different subjects and tasks need different approaches. Detailed, sequential notes might be crucial for learning historical timelines, but brainstorming bubbles might be better for generating essay ideas. Your method might not fit the specific purpose.
Beyond Feeling Hurt: Turning Feedback into Action
Okay, the initial sting is subsiding. Now what? Instead of dismissing the comment or stubbornly sticking to your ways, see it as valuable data. Here’s how to respond constructively:
1. Ask for Clarity (Politely!): Approach your teacher outside of class. “Hi, I was thinking about your comment on my notes. Could you help me understand specifically what seems less useful? Are there certain parts missing, or is it the overall structure?” Getting concrete examples (“You didn’t note the cause of the event, just the effect” or “Your headings weren’t clear”) is gold.
2. Honestly Evaluate Your Own Experience:
Review Time: When you sit down later to study from your notes, do they make sense? Can you easily find key points? Do they trigger your memory of the lecture/discussion? Or do you find yourself constantly confused, flipping back through the textbook, or needing to ask classmates for clarification?
Active vs. Passive: Were you actively thinking about connections, summarizing in your head, and questioning as you wrote? Or was your hand just moving automatically?
Test Performance: Is there a link between how you take notes on a topic and how well you understand it later on a quiz or assignment? Be honest.
3. Observe & Learn (Without Copying): Pay attention to how peers who seem to grasp concepts well take notes. What do their pages look like? Don’t copy blindly, but look for ideas: Do they use more diagrams? Summarize points in the margin? Leave space for questions? Ask a classmate whose notes seem effective how they decide what to write down.
Exploring the Note-Taking Toolbox: Popular Systems to Try
Think of note-taking methods like different screwdrivers – each has its best use. Experiment! Don’t feel locked into one. Here are a few proven techniques:
The Cornell Method:
How it Works: Divide your page into three sections: a narrow left-hand column (Cues), a wider right-hand column (Notes), and a section at the bottom (Summary).
In Class: Write main notes in the right column.
After Class: Jot keywords, questions, or prompts in the left “Cues” column based on your notes. Write a brief summary at the bottom.
Why it Might Help: Forces review and summarization. The cues act like flashcards for later studying. Great for lectures with clear structure.
Mind Mapping (or Concept Mapping):
How it Works: Start with the central topic in the middle of the page. Branch out with main ideas connected directly to the center. Sub-branches hold details, examples, and connections. Use keywords, images, colors.
Why it Might Help: Excellent for visual learners, showing relationships between ideas, brainstorming, and subjects where connections are key (like biology processes or character relationships in literature). Less linear than traditional notes.
The Outline Method:
How it Works: Use headings, subheadings, and bullet points organized hierarchically (I., A., 1., a., etc.). Follows the structure of the lecture/material.
Why it Might Help: Clear, organized, easy to follow. Highlights main topics and subtopics clearly. Good for very structured lectures or textbook reading.
The Boxing Method:
How it Works: Group related information together by drawing boxes around each distinct topic or concept covered during the lecture/reading. Add titles to each box.
Why it Might Help: Visually separates different ideas, making review easier. Encourages grouping related facts. Good for subjects with distinct modules or topics within a single lesson.
Charting Method:
How it Works: Create a table with columns and rows. Headings could be categories like “Concept,” “Definition,” “Example,” “Significance,” or “Date,” “Event,” “Cause,” “Effect.”
Why it Might Help: Ideal for comparing and contrasting information, categorizing facts (e.g., historical periods, scientific classifications), or learning detailed terminology. Forces concise information.
Digital vs. Analog: Finding Your Medium
Handwritten Notes: Often lead to better processing and memory retention. Easier to draw diagrams quickly. Less distracting (no notifications!). Can feel more personal.
Digital Notes: Faster for typing, easily searchable, great for organization with folders/tags. Easy to embed links, images, recordings. Syncing across devices is handy. Tools like Notion, Evernote, OneNote offer powerful features.
Hybrid?: Some swear by typing notes in class for speed, then handwriting summaries later for deeper processing.
The Ultimate Test: Does it Work For You?
Here’s the crucial part: There is no single “best” way. The method your teacher prefers might genuinely be great, but it might not be your ideal path. The goal isn’t just neatness or conforming; it’s effective learning and recall.
When to Adapt: If experimenting shows another method genuinely helps you understand concepts faster, remember information longer, and perform better, embrace it! Your teacher’s feedback was a catalyst for improvement.
When to Advocate (Respectfully): If, after honest trial and self-reflection, your unique method does work brilliantly for you (and your results prove it), be prepared to explain it. Show your teacher how you use your notes effectively to study and succeed. “I understand the concern about my visual maps, but I find that creating them forces me to see connections, and when I review, the spatial layout helps me recall everything. My grades on these topics have been strong.”
The Takeaway: Notes Are Your Personal Learning Engine
That initial comment, “your way of making notes is not useful,” is really a challenge: “Is your current method maximizing your learning?” It’s an invitation to explore, experiment, and become a more strategic learner. Don’t just take notes passively – actively craft them as powerful tools tailored to your brain. Talk to your teacher, try new techniques, pay attention to what boosts your understanding, and don’t be afraid to own what works. The most useful notes aren’t the prettiest or the most conventional; they’re the ones that empower you to grasp, retain, and apply knowledge effectively. That’s the goal worth scribbling, typing, or mapping your way towards.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Teacher Says Your Notes Aren’t Working: Finding Your Groove