When Protection Becomes a Business: A Deep Dive into the Documentary ‘Thoughts and Prayers’
In an era where school shootings have become a grim reality, the documentary Thoughts and Prayers offers a provocative exploration of the rapidly growing industry built around campus safety. Directed by filmmaker Clara Bennett, the film doesn’t just examine the tools and tactics marketed to protect students—it asks uncomfortable questions about profit, ethics, and the commodification of fear.
The Rise of the School Security Industry
The film opens with a jarring statistic: Since 2018, the U.S. school security market has grown by over 300%, now valued at $3.1 billion. Companies selling everything from bulletproof backpacks to AI-powered surveillance systems have emerged, capitalizing on a pervasive sense of vulnerability among parents and educators. Thoughts and Prayers introduces viewers to industry insiders, including a former tech executive who pivoted to developing panic buttons for classrooms and a startup founder selling facial recognition software to schools.
But the documentary doesn’t stop at cataloging products. It digs into the psychology behind the demand. Interviews with school administrators reveal a desperate scramble to “do something”—anything—to reassure communities. One principal admits, “Parents want visible solutions. If we don’t invest in [security upgrades], they’ll assume we’re not taking safety seriously.”
The Moral Dilemma: Profiting from Fear?
A recurring theme in Thoughts and Prayers is the ethical tension between genuine protection and exploitation. The film features emotional debates between entrepreneurs who believe their products save lives and critics who argue the industry preys on collective trauma.
One particularly striking scene shows a trade fair for school security products. Vendors demonstrate bulletproof whiteboards, door barricades disguised as artwork, and even an app that simulates gunfire during lockdown drills to “prepare students for real scenarios.” A parent attending the event tearfully asks, “How did we get here? Our kids are practicing hiding from shooters before they learn multiplication tables.”
The documentary also highlights disparities in access. Wealthy districts can afford $500,000 surveillance systems and armed guards, while underfunded schools rely on outdated locks and volunteer patrols. “This isn’t just about safety—it’s about equity,” argues a teacher from a rural district.
The Human Cost of “Solutions”
Thoughts and Prayers doesn’t shy away from showing how security measures impact students’ mental health. Child psychologists discuss the long-term effects of active shooter drills, with studies suggesting increased anxiety and hypervigilance among children. Footage of a kindergarten class practicing “quiet games” during a lockdown drill is juxtaposed with interviews of students describing nightmares of being trapped in classrooms.
Perhaps the film’s most chilling revelation comes from a whistleblower at a major security firm. They reveal how companies use fear-based marketing tactics, such as sharing unverified crime statistics or worst-case scenarios, to drive sales. “We’re not just selling products,” the whistleblower says. “We’re selling the idea that danger is everywhere.”
Beyond Gadgets: Alternative Approaches
While critiquing the industry, Thoughts and Prayers also spotlights communities exploring non-commercial solutions. A Colorado school district partners with mental health organizations to identify at-risk students early. A Michigan town replaces metal detectors with mentorship programs, resulting in a 40% drop in disciplinary incidents.
The film argues that effective safety requires addressing root causes: gun access, social isolation, and systemic underfunding of education. “Arming teachers or turning schools into fortresses doesn’t solve why someone wants to harm kids in the first place,” notes a policy expert.
A Call for Accountability
In its final act, the documentary turns to legislation—or the lack thereof. Only 14 states require school security plans to be reviewed by independent experts, and there’s no federal oversight for products marketed to schools. Scenes of lawmakers debating funding for security grants contrast sharply with lobbyists pushing bills favorable to tech companies.
The title Thoughts and Prayers becomes a biting refrain. As one survivor of a school shooting remarks, “After every tragedy, politicians say ‘thoughts and prayers,’ then companies swoop in to sell us stuff. But real change? That’s nowhere in the brochure.”
Conclusion: A Conversation Starter, Not a Manual
Clara Bennett’s film doesn’t claim to have answers. Instead, it urges viewers to question who benefits from the current approach to school safety—and who gets left behind. By blending personal stories, investigative journalism, and stark visuals, Thoughts and Prayers challenges audiences to reimagine what protection means in an age where childhood itself feels under siege.
Whether you’re a parent, educator, or concerned citizen, this documentary will leave you grappling with a complex truth: In the quest to keep kids safe, good intentions aren’t enough. We need to ask harder questions about the systems we’re building—and who they truly serve.
Thoughts and Prayers is now streaming on major platforms.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Protection Becomes a Business: A Deep Dive into the Documentary ‘Thoughts and Prayers’