Considering “Pumped Up Kicks” for a School Concert: A Thoughtful Discussion
When planning a school concert, song selection often sparks lively debates among educators, students, and parents. Few tracks ignite as much discussion as Foster the People’s 2010 hit Pumped Up Kicks. Its infectious melody and danceable rhythm contrast sharply with its dark lyrical content, creating a dilemma for schools aiming to balance artistic expression with sensitivity. Let’s explore the considerations surrounding this controversial choice.
—
Understanding the Song’s Context
Pumped Up Kicks tells a story from the perspective of a troubled teenager contemplating violence. While the upbeat tempo made it a summer anthem, the lyrics reference themes of isolation, mental health struggles, and school shootings—a stark juxtaposition that has divided audiences since its release.
For educators, the challenge lies in separating the song’s artistic merit from its subject matter. Foster the People’s Mark Foster has stated that the track aimed to spark conversations about youth mental health and gun violence. However, in a school setting, where safety and emotional well-being are priorities, even well-intentioned art can feel unsettling.
—
Why Schools Hesitate
1. Sensitivity to Current Events
School shootings remain a painful reality in many communities. Performing a song that metaphorically addresses this issue could unintentionally trigger anxiety or distress among students, parents, or staff who’ve experienced trauma.
2. Age Appropriateness
Younger audiences may not grasp the song’s nuanced critique. Without context, the catchy chorus (“All the other kids with the pumped-up kicks…”) might overshadow its darker message, potentially normalizing harmful themes.
3. Parental Concerns
Parents unfamiliar with the song’s intent might perceive it as glamorizing violence. Schools often prioritize transparency with families, and unexpected controversy could overshadow the concert’s purpose: celebrating student talent.
—
The Case for Artistic Freedom
On the flip side, censoring Pumped Up Kicks raises questions about how schools navigate complex topics. Here’s why some argue for its inclusion:
1. Teaching Critical Thinking
Music offers a gateway to discuss real-world issues. Performing the song could be paired with classroom discussions about lyric analysis, media literacy, or mental health awareness. This transforms the performance into an educational moment.
2. Acknowledging Student Voice
High schoolers are often drawn to music that reflects their generational experiences. Allowing students to reinterpret the song—say, through an instrumental arrangement or revised lyrics—could empower them to engage with its themes constructively.
3. Historical & Cultural Relevance
As a defining track of the 2010s, Pumped Up Kicks holds a place in modern music history. Omitting it entirely might sidestep an opportunity to explore how art mirrors societal anxieties.
—
Alternative Approaches
If a school decides to proceed, thoughtful planning can mitigate risks:
– Contextualize the Performance
Introduce the song with a brief explanation of its intent. For example, a student or teacher could share how the track critiques societal neglect of troubled youth rather than glorifying violence.
– Modify the Arrangement
An instrumental version preserves the melody while distancing the performance from the lyrics. Alternatively, a choir could adapt the words to focus on unity or resilience.
– Pair with a Call to Action
Use the concert as a platform to raise awareness about mental health resources or anti-violence initiatives. Partner with student clubs to share information during intermission.
—
What Other Schools Have Done
Some institutions have navigated this dilemma creatively:
– A California high school band performed the song alongside an original spoken-word piece about school safety, turning the performance into a tribute to resilience.
– A middle school in Texas hosted a post-concert panel where students discussed how music can address tough topics responsibly.
– Others have opted for parody lyrics (e.g., changing “pumped-up kicks” to “pumped-up books”) to maintain the rhythm while shifting the narrative.
—
The Bigger Picture: Music’s Role in Education
This debate reflects a broader question: Should schools avoid controversial art, or embrace it as a catalyst for growth? Music has always been a medium for rebellion, protest, and social commentary—from Billie Holiday’s Strange Fruit to Childish Gambino’s This Is America. Avoiding uncomfortable topics might shelter students from the very conversations that prepare them for the real world.
That said, context is key. Randomly including Pumped Up Kicks without purpose risks trivializing its message. But as part of a structured program that encourages reflection, it could foster empathy and critical dialogue.
—
Final Thoughts
Choosing Pumped Up Kicks for a school concert isn’t a simple yes/no decision. It requires weighing artistic value against community needs, student maturity, and educational goals. Engage stakeholders early—poll students, consult counselors, and communicate openly with parents.
If the choice is “yes,” lean into the teachable moments. If “no,” use the discussion to explore why certain themes demand sensitivity. Either way, the process itself can empower students to think deeply about music’s power—and responsibility—in shaping culture.
After all, school concerts aren’t just about entertainment; they’re a stage for learning, connection, and growth. Whatever the setlist, that’s a rhythm worth keeping.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Considering “Pumped Up Kicks” for a School Concert: A Thoughtful Discussion