Is a GED Really That Bad? Breaking Down the Myths and Realities
When it comes to education, few topics spark as much debate as the General Educational Development (GED) credential. For decades, the GED has been labeled a “second-chance” diploma—a backup plan for those who couldn’t finish high school. But how bad is a GED, really? Is it a legitimate pathway to opportunities, or does it carry a stigma that holds people back? Let’s dive into the facts, myths, and practical realities of earning a GED.
What Even Is a GED?
The GED was created in 1943 to help veterans returning from World War II complete their education and reintegrate into civilian life. Today, it’s a high school equivalency exam covering four subjects: math, science, social studies, and language arts. Passing the test grants a credential accepted by most employers and colleges as equal to a traditional diploma.
But here’s where the confusion starts. While the GED is legally recognized, public perception often doesn’t match reality. Many assume it’s easier than graduating high school or that it reflects poorly on a person’s work ethic. To understand whether these assumptions hold up, let’s compare the GED to a traditional diploma.
The High School Diploma: Gold Standard or Overhyped?
There’s no denying the value of a high school diploma. Finishing four years of structured learning demonstrates persistence, time management, and exposure to a broad curriculum. Students also gain social skills, extracurricular experiences, and access to guidance counselors—resources that aren’t part of the GED process.
However, traditional schooling doesn’t work for everyone. Life circumstances like financial struggles, health issues, or family responsibilities force many students to drop out. For them, the GED isn’t about taking a shortcut—it’s about reclaiming control of their future.
The GED’s Limitations: What the Data Says
Critics of the GED often cite statistics to argue its shortcomings. For example:
– Earning potential: On average, GED holders earn less than high school graduates, though more than those without any credential.
– College completion: While 60% of GED holders enroll in college, only about 5% earn a bachelor’s degree, compared to 33% of traditional diploma holders.
– Employer bias: Some hiring managers view GED candidates as less committed, especially in competitive fields.
These numbers sound discouraging, but they don’t tell the whole story. A closer look reveals that GED holders often face systemic barriers unrelated to the credential itself. For instance, many test-takers come from low-income backgrounds or have gaps in formal education, which can affect long-term outcomes. The GED isn’t necessarily the cause of these challenges—it’s often a response to them.
When the GED Is a Smart Choice
For certain individuals, the GED isn’t just a fallback option—it’s the best possible decision. Consider these scenarios:
1. Adult learners: Returning to high school as an adult isn’t practical. The GED offers a flexible, self-paced alternative.
2. Career advancement: Many jobs require a high school credential for promotions. Earning a GED quickly unlocks these opportunities.
3. Military enlistment: The U.S. Armed Forces accept the GED, though recruits may need additional college credits.
4. College aspirations: Community colleges and many universities welcome GED holders, provided they meet other admissions criteria.
In these cases, the GED serves as a stepping stone rather than a limitation. The key is to pair it with additional skills, certifications, or experience to stand out.
Overcoming the Stigma: How to Make a GED Work for You
If you’ve earned a GED, how do you address potential biases? Here’s the good news: the credential’s reputation is improving. Employers and colleges increasingly recognize that life circumstances don’t define a person’s potential. To maximize your opportunities:
– Highlight your story: Frame your GED as evidence of resilience. For example: “I left school to support my family but prioritized finishing my education later.”
– Build complementary skills: Take online courses, earn certifications (e.g., IT, healthcare), or gain hands-on experience through internships.
– Network strategically: Connect with mentors or organizations that support non-traditional students and workers.
The Bigger Picture: Education Doesn’t End With a Diploma
A high school diploma or GED is just the beginning. In today’s economy, lifelong learning matters more than ever. Many high-paying jobs in tech, trades, and healthcare don’t require a four-year degree but do value specialized training. Platforms like Coursera, LinkedIn Learning, and vocational schools make it easier than ever to gain marketable skills—regardless of how you finished high school.
Final Thoughts: It’s About Context, Not Just Credentials
So, is a GED “bad”? Not inherently. Its value depends on how you use it. For someone who left school due to homelessness or illness, the GED is a lifeline. For a teenager who drops out simply to avoid effort, it might reflect poor judgment—but even then, it’s better than no credential at all.
The bottom line: Education is deeply personal. What works for one person might not work for another. The GED isn’t a perfect solution, but it’s a critical tool for millions to rebuild their lives. Rather than judging the credential, we should focus on supporting individuals in their unique journeys—whether that includes a GED, a diploma, or something else entirely.
If you’re considering a GED, weigh your options carefully. Talk to academic advisors, employers, or community organizations to understand how it fits into your goals. With the right mindset and effort, a GED can open doors you never thought possible.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is a GED Really That Bad