Anyone Still Play “Would You Rather” with Their Students? Let’s Talk About Why You Should
Remember the thrill of being asked a bizarre hypothetical question that made your brain twist in knots? “Would you rather eat a pizza made of bugs or drink a milkshake flavored with toothpaste?” For decades, the classic game “Would You Rather” has been a staple in classrooms, road trips, and family gatherings. But in an era dominated by digital distractions and fast-paced learning tools, a fair question arises: Do teachers still use this simple, low-tech game with their students?
The answer is a resounding yes—and for good reason. Let’s explore why this timeless activity remains a secret weapon for educators and how it can transform classroom dynamics, foster critical thinking, and even strengthen social bonds.
—
1. Breaking the Ice (and Awkward Silences)
Starting a class or welcoming new students can feel like navigating a minefield of awkwardness. “Would You Rather” acts as a social lubricant, inviting laughter and curiosity without pressure. Imagine beginning a Monday morning with: “Would you rather have the ability to talk to animals or speak every human language fluently?” Suddenly, even the shyest student might perk up. The game’s playful absurdity creates a judgment-free zone where there are no “wrong” answers—just opportunities to share perspectives.
Teachers often use these questions to highlight personality traits or hidden interests. A student who chooses “be invisible for a day” over “read minds” might reveal a love for adventure or a preference for observation. These insights help educators tailor lessons to engage individuals more effectively.
—
2. Sparking Critical Thinking (Without the Eye-Rolls)
At its core, “Would You Rather” is a stealthy exercise in decision-making. Students must weigh pros and cons, analyze trade-offs, and defend their choices—all while pretending they’re “just playing a game.” Take this example: “Would you rather live in a world without technology or a world without art?” Suddenly, learners are debating the value of innovation versus creativity, connecting abstract concepts to real-life implications.
This kind of low-stakes critical thinking prepares students for higher-level problem-solving. A math teacher might ask, “Would you rather solve 10 easy equations or one super-hard riddle?” to spark a conversation about perseverance and strategy. Even silly questions (“Would you rather have spaghetti for hair or meatball elbows?”) encourage kids to visualize outcomes and articulate reasoning—a foundation for logical arguments.
—
3. Building Empathy and Perspective-Taking
One of the game’s underrated superpowers is its ability to cultivate empathy. When a student chooses “live in a treehouse” over “live in a submarine,” peers get a glimpse into their priorities—adventure, nature, solitude, or community. Discussions often reveal cultural or personal values, fostering respect for diverse viewpoints.
Teachers can also use the game to address social-emotional learning (SEL). For example: “Would you rather everyone always tell the truth, even if it’s hurtful, or let people tell harmless lies to protect feelings?” This question opens doors to conversations about honesty, kindness, and ethical dilemmas. By practicing perspective-taking in a playful setting, students develop emotional intelligence they’ll use far beyond the classroom.
—
4. Reviving Creativity in Standardized-Test Culture
In an education system increasingly focused on metrics and benchmarks, “Would You Rather” offers a breath of fresh air. Its open-ended nature rewards imagination over memorization. A science teacher might ask, “Would you rather explore the depths of the ocean or the surface of Mars?” triggering debates about biology, physics, and human curiosity.
Creative writing prompts naturally emerge from these scenarios. After pondering “Would you rather have a pet dragon or a robot best friend?” students could craft stories explaining their choices. The game becomes a springboard for narratives, persuasive essays, or even art projects—proving that learning can be both structured and whimsical.
—
5. Adaptability: From Kindergarten to College (and Beyond)
The beauty of “Would You Rather” lies in its flexibility. For younger kids, questions like “Would you rather be a dinosaur or a superhero?” boost vocabulary and imaginative play. For teens, dilemmas like “Would you rather be famous for 15 minutes or respected in your field for life?” spark career-related reflections. Even college seminars use nuanced versions (“Would you rather cure one disease or prevent all future wars?”) to explore ethics and philosophy.
In virtual classrooms, the game remains just as effective. Polls or chat-based questions keep remote learners engaged, while breakout rooms allow smaller groups to debate choices. It’s a reminder that connection and creativity don’t require fancy tools—just a little ingenuity.
—
How to Use “Would You Rather” in Your Classroom Today
Ready to revive this classic? Here are practical tips:
– Morning Warm-Ups: Kick off the day with a lighthearted question to energize the room.
– Writing Prompts: Turn choices into short essays or journal entries.
– Curriculum Tie-Ins: Align questions with lesson topics (e.g., “Would you rather have lived in ancient Rome or medieval Japan?” during history units).
– Conflict Resolution: Use hypotheticals to discuss fairness, teamwork, or compromise.
– Quick Brain Breaks: Reset focus during long sessions with a 2-minute debate.
—
The Verdict: Keep Asking Those Crazy Questions
“Would You Rather” isn’t just a relic of the pre-digital age—it’s a timeless tool that adapts to modern educational needs. By blending fun with critical thinking, empathy, and creativity, it proves that learning doesn’t have to be serious to be meaningful. So go ahead: Ask your students whether they’d rather breathe underwater or fly. Their answers might just teach you something new.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Anyone Still Play “Would You Rather” with Their Students