Understanding Your 23-Month-Old’s Contradictory Behavior: “No” Followed by “Yes”
Parenting a toddler is full of delightful surprises and puzzling moments. One common scenario many caregivers face is when their 23-month-old firmly declares “No!” to a request—only to immediately reverse course and ask for the exact same thing. Picture this: You offer your child a banana. They cross their arms, scrunch their face, and shout, “No banana!” Two seconds later, they’re tugging your sleeve, pleading, “Banana? Pease?” If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Let’s unpack why this happens and how to navigate it with empathy.
The Developmental Roots of “No-Yes” Whiplash
At 23 months, toddlers are in a fascinating phase of self-discovery. Their brains are rapidly developing, and with newfound language skills, they’re testing boundaries to assert independence. Saying “no” isn’t just defiance—it’s a milestone. Psychologist Erik Erikson identified this stage (ages 1–3) as a critical period for autonomy vs. shame/doubt. When your child says “no,” they’re declaring, “I’m my own person!”
But why the sudden flip to “yes”? Two factors collide here:
1. Impulse Control vs. Desire: Toddlers lack fully developed prefrontal cortexes—the brain region governing decision-making. Their “no” is an automatic reaction, but their genuine desire (e.g., hunger for that banana) quickly overrides it.
2. Communication Growing Pains: Language skills are still emerging. A toddler might reject something verbally while their body language (reaching for the item) tells a different story. They’re learning to align words with intentions—a work in progress.
Decoding the Mixed Signals
Imagine your child refusing to put on shoes, then bursting into tears when you take the shoes away. Frustrating? Absolutely. But this behavior isn’t random—it’s a window into their cognitive development:
– Testing Cause and Effect: Toddlers are tiny scientists. They’re experimenting: “If I say ‘no,’ what happens? Will Mom get upset? Will the banana disappear?” Their reversal is often a surprised response to unintended consequences.
– Emotional Whiplash: Big emotions flood little bodies. A toddler might refuse a snack due to momentary anger, then panic when they realize their favorite yogurt is being put away.
– Seeking Control in an Overwhelming World: Saying “no” provides a sense of power. But when that power leads to missing out, they backtrack—a sign they’re learning to balance independence with reliance on caregivers.
5 Strategies to Reduce Power Struggles
1. Pause Before Reacting
When met with a knee-jerk “no,” take a breath. Responding with frustration (“You just said no!”) escalates tension. Instead, stay neutral: “Okay, no banana right now.” Often, the mere act of not arguing gives your child space to reconsider.
2. Offer Limited Choices
Reduce opportunities for blanket refusal by providing options:
– “Would you like the banana sliced or whole?”
– “Should we put your shoes on before or after brushing teeth?”
This preserves their autonomy while guiding decisions.
3. Use “When…Then” Statements
Frame transitions collaboratively:
– “When you finish your milk, then we can read a book.”
– “When your shoes are on, then we’ll go to the park.”
This teaches cause-and-effect without ultimatums.
4. Validate Feelings, Then Redirect
Acknowledge their emotions without giving in to unreasonable demands:
– “You really wanted to keep playing. It’s hard to stop. Should we save this toy for after lunch?”
– “You don’t want the banana right now? That’s okay. Let’s set it here in case you change your mind.”
5. Laugh It Off (When Appropriate)
Sometimes, humor disarms tension. If your child demands the rejected item, playfully echo their contradiction:
– “Hmm…First ‘no banana,’ now ‘yes banana’? You’re keeping me on my toes!”
This models lightheartedness while highlighting the inconsistency—without shaming.
When to Worry (Spoiler: Rarely)
Most “no-yes” flip-flops are normal. However, consult a pediatrician if:
– Your child never changes their mind after refusing essentials (food, sleep).
– The behavior is accompanied by extreme aggression or withdrawal.
– Language development seems significantly delayed.
The Bigger Picture: Building Lifelong Skills
These seemingly exasperating moments are foundational. By handling contradictions calmly, you’re helping your child:
– Develop Emotional Intelligence: They learn it’s safe to express conflicting feelings.
– Practice Problem-Solving: “Hmm, I said ‘no’ but actually want this. How do I fix it?”
– Trust Caregivers: Consistency teaches them the world is predictable, even when their emotions aren’t.
So the next time your toddler does a 180 on snack choices or playtime requests, remember: This phase won’t last forever. Each “no…yes” is a stepping stone toward clearer communication—and a reminder that even tiny humans have complex inner lives worth understanding.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Understanding Your 23-Month-Old’s Contradictory Behavior: “No” Followed by “Yes”