Why Authentic Lesson Plans Matter in Student Teaching (and How to Create Them)
Imagine spending weeks preparing lesson plans, only to have your supervisor flag them as “inauthentic.” For student teachers, this scenario can feel discouraging—even confusing. After all, you’ve followed the curriculum guidelines, aligned your activities with learning objectives, and even added creative elements to engage students. So why would a supervisor emphasize an “authenticity check” for lesson plans?
The truth is, authenticity in teaching isn’t just about originality. It’s about creating materials that reflect your understanding, values, and adaptability as an educator. Supervisors aren’t looking for perfection; they’re assessing whether your plans demonstrate genuine effort, critical thinking, and a connection to the students you serve. Let’s unpack why this matters and how to ensure your lesson plans pass the authenticity test.
—
The Role of Authenticity in Teacher Preparation
Teaching is a deeply personal profession. While textbooks and online resources offer templates, a lesson plan should never feel like a copy-paste job. Supervisors require authenticity checks because they want to see evidence of your ability to:
1. Tailor content to your classroom’s needs. A lesson on fractions might work for one group of students but fall flat for another. Authentic plans show you’ve considered factors like cultural backgrounds, learning styles, and prior knowledge.
2. Problem-solve in real time. If a lesson plan is borrowed without adaptation, it suggests you might struggle to adjust when unexpected challenges arise (and they always do).
3. Develop your teaching philosophy. Your plans should hint at your beliefs about education—whether you prioritize collaboration, inquiry-based learning, or hands-on experimentation.
A supervisor’s insistence on originality isn’t about distrust; it’s about ensuring you’re building skills that’ll sustain you long after student teaching ends.
—
How Supervisors Detect Inauthentic Work
Supervisors aren’t detectives, but years of experience make them adept at spotting red flags. Here’s what might trigger scrutiny:
– Overly polished or generic language. If your plan reads like a textbook glossary—with no personal anecdotes or specific examples—it may signal a lack of genuine engagement.
– Mismatched tone and style. A kindergarten lesson plan filled with college-level terminology or a high school chemistry plan that’s overly simplistic could raise eyebrows.
– Inconsistent formatting or pacing. Sudden shifts in structure (e.g., one day’s plan is hyper-detailed, the next is vague) might suggest borrowed content stitched together.
– Missing reflection components. Many programs require student teachers to include post-lesson reflections. Generic statements like “The students enjoyed the activity” lack the depth supervisors seek.
To avoid these pitfalls, treat your lesson plan as a living document. Let it evolve as you observe students, receive feedback, and refine your approach.
—
Strategies for Crafting Authentic Lesson Plans
Creating original plans doesn’t mean starting from scratch every time. Here’s how to balance inspiration with authenticity:
1. Use Templates as Guides, Not Blueprints
Templates are fantastic for organizing ideas, but customize them. For example, if a template includes a “warm-up activity” section, describe your chosen warm-up and explain why it suits your students (e.g., “A quick ‘think-pair-share’ to activate prior knowledge about ecosystems”).
2. Incorporate Student Voice
Survey your students about their interests or learning preferences. Did they mention loving hands-on experiments? Do they struggle with group work? Reference these insights in your plan. A note like, “Based on last week’s feedback, I’ve added a visual diagram for visual learners,” shows intentionality.
3. Document Your Decision-Making
Supervisors appreciate transparency. If you borrow an activity from a peer or website, credit the source and explain why you chose it. For instance: “This exit ticket idea comes from Ms. Thompson’s blog, but I’ve modified the questions to align with our unit on climate change.”
4. Reflect Authentically
After teaching a lesson, jot down what surprised you, what didn’t work, and how you’d adjust. Instead of writing, “The group activity went well,” try: “Two groups finished early and seemed disengaged. Next time, I’ll prepare extension questions for faster learners.”
5. Collaborate Without Copying
Discuss ideas with peers or mentors, but translate their advice into your own words. If a colleague suggests a storytelling approach to teach history, design a unique activity that fits your style—maybe a role-play exercise or a student-led podcast project.
—
What If Your Plan Gets Flagged?
If a supervisor questions your work, don’t panic. Use it as a learning opportunity:
– Ask for specifics. Which sections seemed inauthentic? Is it the structure, the content, or the lack of personalization?
– Revise with intention. Add details that reflect your classroom’s reality. Did you have to modify an activity mid-lesson? Include that in your plan’s reflection.
– Seek feedback early. Share drafts with your supervisor before submitting final versions. Proactive communication builds trust.
—
The Bigger Picture: Authenticity as a Lifelong Practice
The push for authentic lesson plans isn’t just a hoop to jump through—it’s preparation for the unpredictability of teaching. In a real classroom, you’ll constantly adapt to snow days, tech failures, and “aha moments” that derail your schedule. By honing your ability to create flexible, personalized plans, you’re building resilience and creativity.
Remember, your supervisor isn’t evaluating you on how flawlessly you execute someone else’s ideas. They’re assessing how well you think on your feet, connect with students, and grow from each experience. So embrace the authenticity check. It’s not a barrier; it’s a bridge to becoming the teacher your students deserve.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Authentic Lesson Plans Matter in Student Teaching (and How to Create Them)