When Doing the Right Thing Makes You Feel Like a Villain
We’ve all been there. That moment when you know you’re making a choice that’s correct—ethically, professionally, or morally—but it leaves you with a sinking feeling in your gut. “I feel like a jerk for doing this…” plays on repeat in your mind. Maybe you had to give a student a failing grade despite their efforts, or perhaps you reported a friend for cheating on an exam. Whatever the scenario, the tension between doing what’s right and feeling like the “bad guy” is universal, especially in educational and mentorship roles. Let’s unpack why this happens and how to navigate it without losing your integrity—or your sanity.
—
Why Doing the Right Thing Feels So Wrong
Humans are wired for connection. We crave approval, harmony, and positive relationships. So when enforcing rules or holding boundaries conflicts with someone’s immediate happiness, our brains interpret it as a social threat. Think of a teacher who cancels a much-anticipated field trip because students didn’t meet behavioral expectations. The teacher knows the decision reinforces accountability, but watching disappointed faces triggers guilt.
This discomfort often stems from a clash between two values: compassion and responsibility. For example, a college professor might agonize over failing a student who tried hard but didn’t meet standards. Letting the student pass out of pity feels kind in the moment, but it undermines the credibility of the institution and does the student no favors long-term. Still, prioritizing fairness over empathy can leave you feeling coldhearted—even when logic says otherwise.
—
The Myth of the “Nice Person” Trap
Many of us subconsciously believe that being a “good” person means never upsetting others. This mindset is especially toxic in educational settings, where mentors and peers often prioritize being liked over being respected. A high school counselor, for instance, might avoid discussing a student’s poor college readiness because they fear the student’s reaction. But dodging tough conversations doesn’t make you kinder—it makes you less trustworthy.
Psychologists call this the “approval paradox.” The more you try to avoid conflict to preserve your image, the more inauthentic you become. Students and colleagues can sense when you’re withholding honesty to spare feelings, which erodes trust. As author Brené Brown says, “Clear is kind. Unclear is unkind.” Sometimes, the “jerk” feeling is just the price of clarity.
—
When Guilt Is a Teacher, Not an Enemy
Guilt isn’t always bad. It’s a signal that you care about the impact of your actions. The key is to differentiate between healthy guilt (e.g., “I wish I’d handled that conversation more patiently”) and unproductive guilt (e.g., “I’m terrible for enforcing a deadline”). Healthy guilt prompts growth; unproductive guilt keeps you stuck in self-criticism.
Let’s say a student plagiarizes an essay, and you’re obligated to report it. They beg for a second chance, arguing it was a one-time mistake. You follow protocol but feel awful afterward. Instead of ruminating on being the “villain,” reframe the situation: By upholding academic integrity, you’re teaching that person—and the entire class—that shortcuts have consequences. It’s not personal; it’s pedagogical.
—
Practical Steps to Ease the “Jerk” Feeling
1. Name the Emotion
Acknowledge the guilt without judgment. Write down or verbalize: “I feel like a jerk because I canceled the group project, but I know it was necessary.” This separates the emotion from the action, making it easier to process.
2. Clarify Your ‘Why’
Reconnect with your core intention. Did you set a boundary to protect someone’s growth? To maintain fairness? Write your reason on a sticky note as a reminder when doubt creeps in.
3. Balance Firmness with Empathy
Tough decisions land better when paired with compassion. For example:
“I understand you’re upset about the grade, and I want to see you succeed. Let’s create a plan to improve next time.”
4. Normalize Discomfort
Share your struggles with trusted peers or mentors. You’ll quickly realize you’re not alone—most educators grapple with these moments.
—
The Long Game: Why It’s Worth It
A student once told me, “The teachers I hated most in high school became the ones I respected most after graduation.” Why? Because they held him accountable when no one else would. While “being the bad guy” stings in the moment, it often plants seeds for resilience, self-discipline, and respect—for others and oneself.
Institutions thrive when standards matter more than temporary popularity. Think of the coach who benches a star player for skipping practice or the professor who refuses to curve grades unfairly. These acts aren’t about power—they’re about preserving values that help communities grow.
—
Final Thought: You’re Not a Jerk—You’re a Guide
That gnawing guilt? It’s proof you’re human. But don’t let it overshadow the bigger picture. Leadership—whether in a classroom, workplace, or family—requires making unpopular choices that serve a greater purpose. The alternative—sacrificing principles to avoid discomfort—breeds resentment and mediocrity.
So the next time you think, “I feel like a jerk for doing this…”, pause. Ask yourself: Am I causing harm, or am I upholding a standard that helps others grow? If it’s the latter, stand firm. The world needs more people brave enough to be misunderstood temporarily to do what matters permanently.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Doing the Right Thing Makes You Feel Like a Villain