The Parenting Advice I Should’ve Taken (But Didn’t) – And Why I’m Glad
Every parent has been there: drowning in a sea of well-meaning advice. From sleep training to screen time limits, everyone seems to have an opinion on how to raise your child. Most of this guidance comes from a good place, but over the years, I’ve discovered that some of the “best” parenting tips simply don’t align with my family’s reality. In fact, the advice I’ve ignored has often led to unexpected breakthroughs. Let’s unpack three common pieces of wisdom I’ve tossed aside—and why doing so might not be the parenting fail it seems.
—
1. “Never Let Them Sleep in Your Bed”
The Advice: Co-sleeping is a controversial topic, but the loudest voices often warn against it. Experts cite risks like dependency, disrupted sleep for parents, and even safety concerns. The message is clear: “Train your child to sleep alone, or you’ll regret it.”
Why I Ignored It: My daughter, at age three, went through a phase of night terrors so intense that her screams could’ve shattered glass. No amount of reassurance or nightlights helped. One exhausted 3 a.m., I broke the “rule” and brought her into my bed. She curled up, sighed, and slept soundly for the first time in weeks.
What Happened Next: Critics might say I created a “bad habit,” but the opposite occurred. After a few weeks of co-sleeping during rough patches, her anxiety diminished. She began voluntarily returning to her bed, feeling secure enough to sleep alone. By prioritizing her emotional needs over rigid rules, we both got more rest—and she learned to self-soothe on her terms.
The Lesson: Sometimes, flexibility trumps fear. Children’s needs evolve, and a temporary “fix” can build long-term confidence.
—
2. “Limit Screen Time to 30 Minutes a Day”
The Advice: Screens are the modern-day boogeyman. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends no more than one hour of high-quality programming daily for young kids. Parents who exceed this are often shamed for “lazy parenting” or harming their child’s development.
Why I Ignored It: During a cross-country move, my toddler and I spent 12 hours in airports and planes. Coloring books and snacks lasted approximately 27 minutes. Desperate, I handed her a tablet. What followed wasn’t a zombie-like trance but a fascinated little human learning Spanish via Bluey and solving puzzles.
What Happened Next: Screen time became a tool, not a crutch. On chaotic days, it gave me breathing room to cook or work. But I also noticed her mimicking problem-solving skills from games and asking thoughtful questions about nature documentaries. By focusing on content quality rather than arbitrary time limits, screens became a bridge to learning—not a barrier.
The Lesson: Technology isn’t inherently bad. It’s about intentionality. A documentary about marine life can spark curiosity; a mindless YouTube loop? Not so much.
—
3. “Make Them Share Everything”
The Advice: Sharing is caring, right? Forcing toddlers to hand over toys teaches generosity and empathy. At least, that’s the theory.
Why I Ignored It: At a playground, my son clutched his toy truck while another child eyed it. The other parent insisted, “Make him share!” But I’d read about the importance of autonomy—kids need to feel ownership before they can choose to give. Instead of forcing him, I said, “You can play with it until you’re done. Let your friend know when it’s their turn.”
What Happened Next: My son played for two minutes, then voluntarily handed the truck over. Later, he explained, “I didn’t want to share before because I wasn’t finished. But then I was!” By respecting his boundaries, he learned that sharing feels good when it’s his decision—not a power struggle.
The Lesson: Forced sharing can breed resentment. Trusting kids to navigate fairness (with guidance) fosters genuine kindness.
—
Why “Good” Advice Doesn’t Always Work
Parenting advice often assumes a one-size-fits-all approach. But children aren’t robots; they’re individuals with unique temperaments, fears, and strengths. What works for a calm, adaptable child might backfire for a sensitive, strong-willed one. Similarly, parents have different capacities. A sleep-deprived single parent surviving on caffeine isn’t failing by co-sleeping—they’re adapting.
Ignoring advice isn’t about rebellion. It’s about recognizing that you know your child best. Experts provide frameworks, but you’re the one who fills in the details.
—
When to Listen (and When to Tune Out)
This isn’t a blanket endorsement for ignoring all guidance. Safety recommendations (like car seat rules) are non-negotiable. But for subjective issues like discipline or routines, ask yourself:
1. Does this align with my child’s personality?
2. Is this sustainable for my mental health?
3. What’s the worst-case scenario if I try it my way?
Sometimes, the answer is clear. Other times, you’ll course-correct—and that’s okay. Parenting is less about perfection and more about adaptability.
—
Final Thoughts: Trust Your Gut
The best parenting advice I’ve ever ignored taught me to trust my instincts. Rules matter, but so does context. By staying attuned to my kids’ needs—and my own—I’ve found creative solutions that “by-the-book” methods couldn’t offer.
So the next time someone says, “You’re doing it wrong,” smile and remember: You’re not ignoring advice. You’re rewriting the script—one bedtime story, shared toy, or screen-time compromise at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Parenting Advice I Should’ve Taken (But Didn’t) – And Why I’m Glad