The Parenting Advice No One Wants to Hear (But Actually Works)
Parenting is full of well-meaning suggestions. We’re told to praise our kids constantly, shield them from discomfort, and fill their schedules with enriching activities. But what if some of the best advice flies in the face of these modern norms? Here’s a collection of counterintuitive strategies that might make you cringe at first—but could transform how your child grows into a resilient, independent adult.
Let Them Be Bored—Really Bored
The modern parent’s reflex is to entertain. We stockplayrooms with toys, sign kids up for endless activities, and hand over screens at the first hint of restlessness. But boredom isn’t the enemy—it’s a catalyst for creativity.
When children aren’t constantly stimulated, they’re forced to problem-solve. A bored kid might invent a game with sticks, write a silly song, or build a fort out of couch cushions. These unstructured moments teach resourcefulness. Research from the University of Central Lancashire found that boredom sparks associative thinking, allowing the brain to make unexpected connections.
Try this: Next time your child whines, “I’m bored!” resist the urge to fix it. Say, “What cool idea can you come up with?” You might be surprised by their ingenuity.
Stop Rescuing Them From Minor Failures
We’ve been conditioned to see failure as tragic. Forgot their homework? Rush it to school. Struggling with a puzzle? Jump in to help. But small failures are training wheels for adulthood.
A child who forgets their lunch learns to double-check their backpack. One who loses a board game discovers how to practice gracefully. Psychologists call this “autonomy-supportive parenting”—allowing kids to face natural consequences builds responsibility. A University of Pennsylvania study found that children who experienced moderate adversity early in life developed better coping skills than those shielded from setbacks.
The hard part? Watching them struggle. But as psychologist Jessica Lahey writes in The Gift of Failure, “Kids need practice doing things wrong, reflecting on what didn’t work, and figuring out how to recover.”
Delay Solving Their Problems
When a child comes to you upset, your instinct is to fix things immediately. But responding with, “What do you think we should do?” teaches critical thinking.
For example:
– “Sophie won’t share the LEGOs!”
Instead of intervening, ask: “How could you ask her in a way that might help?”
– “I don’t understand my math homework!”
Try: “Let’s look at the textbook example together. What steps do you see?”
This approach fosters metacognition—the ability to analyze their own thought processes. It’s slower and messier than handing them a solution, but it’s how they develop problem-solving muscle.
Don’t Praise Effort (The Way You Think You Should)
“Good job!” and “You’re so smart!” are well-intentioned, but generic praise can backfire. Stanford researcher Carol Dweck’s work on growth mindset reveals that how we praise matters more than the praise itself.
Instead of:
– “You’re a natural at soccer!” (Labels ability as fixed)
– “I’m proud of you for working hard!” (Still adult-focused)
Try:
– “I noticed you kept practicing that kick even when it was tough. How does it feel to see your progress?” (Highlights specific actions and invites self-reflection)
– “What strategy did you use to solve that problem?” (Encourages them to analyze their process)
This shifts the focus from seeking approval to valuing their own growth.
Protect Them Less (Physically and Emotionally)
Helicopter parenting isn’t just about hovering—it’s about over-sanitizing life. Kids need to climb trees, get scraped knees, and navigate awkward social interactions.
– Physical risks: Let them balance on low walls (within reason), use real tools under supervision, or walk to a friend’s house. Risk-taking builds spatial awareness and confidence.
– Emotional risks: Allow them to have conversations with waitstaff, apologize to a friend they’ve hurt, or perform in a school play. Mild embarrassment teaches emotional resilience.
A University of British Columbia study found that children who engaged in “risky play” (climbing, exploring alone) developed better risk assessment skills and were less likely to suffer anxiety.
The Common Thread: Trust Their Capability
These “unpopular” strategies all share a theme: treating children as competent beings instead of fragile projects. It’s not about being harsh—it’s about resisting the cultural pressure to over-parent.
Yes, it’s uncomfortable to watch your child fumble. But consider this: Every time you solve a problem for them, you subtly send the message, “You can’t handle this.” Conversely, when you step back, you communicate, “I believe in your ability to figure it out.”
Parents who’ve embraced these approaches often report surprising shifts. One mom shared, “After I stopped rushing to soothe every meltdown, my daughter started calming herself down faster. She’d say, ‘I’m angry, but I’ll be okay.’”
The goal isn’t to dismiss modern parenting wisdom but to balance it with old-fashioned trust in childhood resilience. After all, our job isn’t to raise happy children—it’s to raise adaptable adults who can create their own happiness, even when life gets messy.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Parenting Advice No One Wants to Hear (But Actually Works)