When Prestige Overshadows Purpose: Unpacking the IIT/NIT Obsession
Every summer, as Indian school boards announce exam results, a familiar pattern unfolds. Families celebrate “successful” students who secure admission to Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) or National Institutes of Technology (NITs), while others quietly mourn “average” scores. But beneath the surface of these reactions lies a pressing question: Are these institutions truly a benchmark of a student’s potential, or have they become trophies for parents to display in societal showcases?
The Weight of a Legacy
The IIT/NIT brand carries undeniable clout. For decades, these institutes have produced globally recognized engineers, entrepreneurs, and innovators. Their rigorous entrance exams—JEE Main and Advanced—are often described as “career-defining” battles. However, the obsession with these schools isn’t just about academic rigor. It’s deeply tied to cultural narratives. In many Indian households, an IIT/NIT admission symbolizes upward mobility, financial security, and, perhaps most importantly, social validation. Parents proudly announce their child’s acceptance at family gatherings, post updates on social media, and wear the achievement like a badge of honor.
But here’s the irony: While parents view these institutes as a finish line, students often experience them as the starting point of a high-pressure marathon. The real journey—figuring out their passions, building resilience, or exploring unconventional paths—gets sidelined in the race to secure a coveted seat.
The Student’s Silent Struggle
For every student who genuinely thrives in the IIT/NIT ecosystem, there’s another who feels trapped by expectations. Take Riya, a 19-year-old from Mumbai who cracked JEE Advanced but confided, “I spent two years memorizing formulas I hated. Now that I’m here, I’m just counting days until I can switch to design school.” Her story isn’t unique. A 2022 survey by an Indian mental health organization revealed that 68% of engineering students across top institutes felt “obligated” to pursue their branch due to parental or societal pressure, not personal interest.
This mismatch between external validation and internal fulfillment raises a red flag. When the pursuit of a prestigious tag overshadows individual growth, students risk becoming passengers in their own lives. They may graduate with technical expertise but lack the curiosity, creativity, or critical thinking skills needed to navigate an evolving job market.
The Parental Perspective: Love, Fear, and Good Intentions
Criticizing parental pride isn’t the goal here. Most families push their children toward IITs/NITs with the best intentions. For middle-class households, these institutes represent stability in an uncertain economy. A parent from Jaipur shared, “My daughter won’t face the financial struggles I did if she becomes an engineer. How do I explain that to someone who’s never worried about next month’s rent?”
Yet, good intentions can sometimes blur the line between guidance and control. When parents equate a child’s worth with their ability to crack competitive exams, they unknowingly send a harmful message: Your value depends on a system’s approval. This mindset can breed anxiety, imposter syndrome, or even resentment over time.
Beyond the Tag: Redefining Success
The solution isn’t to dismiss IITs/NITs as “overrated” but to reframe how we perceive them. These institutes are exceptional platforms—if they align with a student’s goals. For example, a coding enthusiast passionate about AI would thrive at an IIT’s computer science department. Conversely, a student drawn to literature might suffocate in the same environment, no matter how prestigious the institute.
Parents and educators can foster healthier attitudes by:
1. Normalizing exploration: Encourage students to intern in diverse fields before committing to a career path.
2. Separating achievement from worth: Celebrate effort and curiosity, not just rankings.
3. Highlighting alternatives: Showcase success stories from non-engineering fields—artists, chefs, environmentalists—who’ve carved fulfilling careers.
A Shift in Mindset
Change is already brewing. Younger generations are increasingly questioning the “one-size-fits-all” approach to education. Platforms like YouTube and LinkedIn are filled with IIT graduates discussing burnout, career switches, and the importance of mental health. Meanwhile, parents who once rigidly upheld the IIT/NIT dream are now witnessing peers’ children flourish in fields like gaming, content creation, or sustainability—without a “top-tier” engineering degree.
The true measure of success isn’t the institution name on a degree but the alignment between a student’s choices and their sense of purpose. As educator Sudha Murthy once remarked, “A flower doesn’t compete with the one next to it. It just blooms.” Perhaps it’s time we let students bloom at their own pace, in their own soil—whether that soil is an IIT campus, a liberal arts college, or an apprenticeship in a startup.
After all, life isn’t an entrance exam. It’s a journey where resilience, self-awareness, and passion matter far more than any institutional tag.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Prestige Overshadows Purpose: Unpacking the IIT/NIT Obsession