Is It Just Me, or Does the Whole College Thing Feel Like BS?
Let’s cut to the chase: If you’ve ever sat in a lecture hall, stared at a $200 textbook you’ll never open, and thought, “Why am I even here?”—you’re not alone. The idea that college might be overhyped, outdated, or downright exploitative isn’t some fringe conspiracy. It’s a growing sentiment among students, graduates, and even parents questioning whether the traditional four-year degree is still worth the time, debt, and existential dread.
But before we burn our diplomas and declare higher education a scam, let’s unpack why this debate matters—and what it means for anyone considering their next steps.
The College Promise: What We Were Sold
For decades, college was marketed as the golden ticket to a stable career, middle-class comfort, and societal respect. Parents, teachers, and guidance counselors hammered home the idea that a degree equaled success. And for a while, this formula worked. Graduates in the 20th century often landed jobs with pensions, benefits, and salaries that justified their student loans.
But here’s the catch: The world has changed. Tuition costs have skyrocketed (up over 160% since 1980), while wages for entry-level roles have stagnated. Meanwhile, industries like tech, creative arts, and entrepreneurship increasingly value skills over credentials. The disconnect between what college promises and what it delivers is leaving many feeling duped.
The “BS” Factors: Why College Feels Like a Letdown
Let’s name the elephants in the lecture hall:
1. The Debt Trap
The average student loan debt in the U.S. is $37,000 per borrower. For many, this debt lingers for decades, delaying milestones like buying a home or starting a family. Worse, some degrees (looking at you, underwater basket-weaving theory) don’t lead to jobs that justify the investment.
2. Outdated Curriculum
Many programs teach theories and practices that haven’t evolved with industry needs. Imagine studying social media marketing from a professor who last updated their syllabus in 2010. Or sitting through mandatory “core” classes that feel irrelevant to your career goals.
3. The Experience vs. Reality Gap
College sells itself as a transformative journey of self-discovery. But for some, it’s four years of stress, burnout, and disillusionment. The pressure to balance academics, internships, and mental health can leave students wondering, “Is this really preparing me for life?”
4. Alternative Paths Are Thriving
Coding bootcamps, online certifications, apprenticeships, and freelance gigs are proving you don’t need a degree to succeed. Platforms like Coursera, YouTube, and LinkedIn Learning offer affordable (or free) ways to gain skills—without the frat parties or all-nighters.
But Wait—Is College Always BS?
Before we write off higher ed entirely, let’s acknowledge its upsides. For certain fields—medicine, law, engineering—a degree isn’t just helpful; it’s non-negotiable. College also provides structure, networking opportunities, and a safe space to explore interests. For many, it’s where they discover their passions or build lifelong friendships.
The problem isn’t college itself; it’s the one-size-fits-all narrative that pushes everyone onto the same path. Not every 18-year-old needs (or wants) to enroll immediately. And not every career requires a bachelor’s degree.
So, What’s the Alternative?
If college feels like a shaky investment, what options exist? Let’s explore:
– Skill-Based Learning: Platforms like Google Career Certificates or Udacity teach job-ready skills in months, not years.
– Gap Years: Taking time to work, travel, or volunteer can clarify your goals before committing to a degree.
– Community College: Affordable gen-ed credits let you test the waters without drowning in debt.
– Entrepreneurship: Starting a business or freelancing teaches real-world problem-solving—no syllabus needed.
The key is to align your choices with your goals. Want to be a software engineer? A coding bootcamp might suffice. Dream of being a clinical psychologist? You’ll need that PhD.
How to Decide If College Is Right for You
Ask yourself these questions:
1. What’s My “Why”?
Are you attending college to gain specific skills, fulfill a passion, or meet societal expectations? If it’s the latter, rethink your motives.
2. What’s the ROI?
Research starting salaries in your desired field. Will your future income justify the debt?
3. Can I Test Drive First?
Take online courses, shadow professionals, or intern in your field. Get a taste before signing the loan papers.
4. Am I Ready to Advocate for Myself?
College works best for self-directed learners who’ll seek out mentors, internships, and extracurriculars. If you’re passive, you might leave with little to show for it.
The Bottom Line
College isn’t inherently “BS”—but the myth that it’s the only path to success certainly is. The modern economy rewards adaptability, creativity, and grit far more than a framed piece of paper. For some, college will remain a valuable stepping stone. For others, it’s an expensive detour.
The real issue isn’t whether college is worthless. It’s about redefining success on your own terms. Whether you choose a dorm room or a DIY education, what matters is owning your journey—not blindly following a script written decades ago.
So, if you’re sitting in class right now, questioning everything, know this: Your skepticism isn’t a flaw. It’s the first step toward building a life that actually makes sense for you.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is It Just Me, or Does the Whole College Thing Feel Like BS