When Strict Teaching Crosses the Line: A Memory That Shaped My View on Education
Middle school language classes are supposed to be gateways to new cultures, exciting discoveries, and maybe even a little fun. But for me, seventh-grade French felt more like navigating a minefield. My teacher, Mr. Dupont (not his real name, but close enough), had a reputation for being strict, unpredictable, and oddly fixated on catching students off guard. His favorite target? Me.
It started innocently enough. On the first day of class, he asked me to conjugate être in front of everyone. I stumbled, he sighed, and from that moment, I became his go-to “volunteer” for pop quizzes, vocabulary drills, and public corrections. Every raised hand in the room seemed to shrink whenever he scanned the classroom, because we all knew where his finger would land. “Anna?” he’d say, leaning back in his chair. “Translate this sentence.” Or, “Anna, why is the adjective placed after the noun here?” The anxiety became a constant hum in the back of my mind.
Then came the Textbook Incident.
—
The Day Everything Boiled Over
One Thursday morning, I realized my French textbook had disappeared. Maybe I’d left it in my locker, or perhaps it was buried under a pile of unfinished math worksheets. Desperate, I approached Mr. Dupont’s desk before class. “Excuse me,” I whispered, already bracing myself. “I think I need a new textbook.”
He looked up slowly, peering over his glasses with that familiar mix of amusement and mild disdain. “Ah, très bien,” he said, folding his hands. “But first… tell me: How do you say ‘textbook’ in French?”
My stomach dropped. I knew this. Or at least, I should have known. But under pressure, my mind went blank. The harder I tried to remember, the more the word slipped away. Seconds stretched into eternity as he waited, eyebrows raised. The room felt suffocatingly quiet.
That’s when the tears started. Not a graceful trickle, but full-on, hiccuping sobs. I couldn’t stop. The embarrassment only made it worse. Students turned to stare; someone giggled nervously. Mr. Dupont, to his credit, looked momentarily panicked. He handed me the textbook without another word and shooed me back to my seat.
—
Why Moments Like This Stick With Us
Looking back, the Textbook Incident wasn’t just about forgetting a vocabulary word. It was about power dynamics, the weight of constant scrutiny, and how seemingly small interactions can tip someone over the edge. Mr. Dupont’s teaching style relied on intimidation—a “tough love” approach he probably thought would motivate us. Instead, it created an environment where mistakes felt catastrophic.
Research supports what many of us instinctively know: Stress inhibits learning. A 2014 study in the Journal of Educational Psychology found that students perform worse under high-pressure conditions, especially when fear of judgment is present. Language acquisition, which requires experimentation and vulnerability, suffers most in hostile environments. Imagine trying to conjugate verbs while your brain is flooded with cortisol!
Mr. Dupont wasn’t a villain. He likely believed he was holding us to high standards. But his methods ignored a critical truth: Effective teaching requires trust. When students feel safe to ask for help or admit confusion, they engage more deeply. The classroom becomes a collaborative space, not a battleground.
—
What This Taught Me About Learning (and Teaching)
1. Pressure ≠ Progress: High expectations matter, but how we enforce them matters more. A teacher’s role isn’t to terrify students into memorization but to guide them through challenges.
2. Small Moments Have Big Impact: That day, Mr. Dupont learned a lesson too. After my meltdown, he never cold-called me again. Sometimes, a single event can shift a teacher’s perspective—or at least make them rethink their tactics.
3. Advocating for Yourself Matters: I wish I’d spoken up earlier about how his methods affected me. Silence often protects the status quo, even when it’s harmful.
Years later, I’ve made peace with that memory. I even laugh about it sometimes—how absurd it was to cry over livre de texte. But it also shaped my approach to learning. When I started studying Italian in college, I chose a professor known for her patience. We laughed at mistakes, played games to practice tenses, and celebrated small victories. Unsurprisingly, I thrived.
—
Final Thoughts
Teachers hold immense power to inspire or intimidate. For every student like me—quiet, anxious, eager to please—there’s a tipping point where encouragement fuels growth, while pressure breeds paralysis. The Textbook Incident taught me that education isn’t just about transferring knowledge; it’s about nurturing curiosity, resilience, and self-compassion.
As for Mr. Dupont? I like to think he’s retired now, sipping espresso at a Parisian café, finally relaxed enough to let someone else answer the questions.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Strict Teaching Crosses the Line: A Memory That Shaped My View on Education