The Curious Case of the “Average” Option in English Tests: What You Need to Know
If you’ve ever taken a standardized English test—whether it’s the TOEFL, IELTS, SAT, or a school exam—you’ve likely encountered multiple-choice questions. These questions often follow a predictable pattern, and one idea that frequently pops up in test-prep circles is the “average option” theory. Some students swear by guessing the middle answer (like Option B or C) when they’re stuck, believing it’s statistically safer. But does this strategy hold up? Let’s unpack what the “average option” really means, why it’s debated, and how to approach test questions strategically.
What Is the “Average Option” Theory?
The concept is simple: test creators, aiming for fairness, might distribute correct answers evenly across options (A, B, C, D, etc.) to avoid patterns that could give away answers. Over a large number of questions, this would make each option roughly equally likely to be correct. For students, this creates the illusion that guessing the middle option (e.g., B or C in a four-option question) improves their odds.
But here’s the catch: tests aren’t always designed this way. While some exams do randomize answer placements, others prioritize question logic over strict distribution. For example, a grammar question’s correct answer depends on the rules of English, not probability. Blindly relying on the “average option” can backfire if the test isn’t structured to fit that pattern.
Why the Myth Persists
The belief in the “average option” thrives for three reasons:
1. Confirmation Bias: When a guessed middle option turns out correct, it feels like validation. However, people tend to forget the times it failed.
2. Human Pattern-Seeking: Our brains love finding order in chaos. If two consecutive answers are B, we might assume the next one “should” be C—even if there’s no real connection.
3. Test-Prep Folklore: Older strategies, passed down through generations of students, often emphasize shortcuts. While some tips are useful (like eliminating wrong answers first), others lack evidence.
The Risks of Blind Guessing
Guessing based solely on position has pitfalls:
– Uneven Distributions: If a test section has 10 questions, and the first five answers are A, B, C, D, E, the next five won’t necessarily reverse the pattern.
– Question Difficulty: Harder questions might cluster certain options. For instance, test-makers sometimes place tempting distractors (incorrect options) in the middle to trap rushed students.
– Adaptive Testing: Many modern exams, like the TOEFL iBT, use computer-adaptive formats where question difficulty adjusts based on performance. This makes answer patterns even less predictable.
A Better Approach: Strategic Elimination
Instead of fixating on the “average option,” focus on narrowing down choices. Here’s how:
1. Cross Out Clearly Wrong Answers
Start by eliminating options that conflict with grammar rules, vocabulary definitions, or logic. For reading comprehension questions, discard choices that contradict the passage.
Example:
Question: “The protagonist’s primary motivation is ______.”
Option A: “to become a chef” (never mentioned)
Option B: “to find her missing sister” (central to the plot)
Option C: “to win a lottery” (irrelevant detail)
Option D: “to travel to Mars” (absurd for the story’s setting)
Here, even if you’re unsure about Option B, eliminating A, C, and D makes B the obvious choice.
2. Watch for “Extreme” or “Vague” Language
Incorrect options often include absolutes like always, never, or everyone, which rarely apply in nuanced contexts. Conversely, overly vague terms like might or could can also signal distractors.
3. Use Context Clues
For vocabulary questions, replace the blank with each option to see which flows naturally. For grammar questions, read the sentence aloud (silently, during the test!) to catch awkward phrasing.
4. Note Question Patterns
While answer positions may vary, question types often repeat. For instance:
– Inference questions (What is implied?) require connecting ideas, not direct quotes.
– Tone questions (Is the author critical or supportive?) rely on adjectives and verbs.
Practice tests help you recognize these patterns, reducing reliance on guesswork.
When Guessing Is Necessary
If you’re truly stuck, then consider probability—but with nuance:
– Even Distribution: If you’ve eliminated one or two options, your odds improve significantly. Guessing between B and C gives a 50% chance in a four-option question.
– Streaks: If five answers in a row were D, the next one is slightly less likely to be D (but not impossible!).
Long-Term Strategy: Build Skills, Not Just Tactics
While test-taking strategies help, they’re no substitute for mastery. To genuinely improve:
– Read Widely: Exposure to diverse texts sharpens vocabulary and comprehension.
– Practice Writing: Essays and short answers reinforce grammar and coherence.
– Listen Actively: Podcasts, movies, and conversations improve listening skills for exams like the IELTS.
– Learn from Mistakes: Review incorrect answers to identify weak spots (e.g., verb tenses or prepositions).
The Bottom Line
The “average option” theory is a mixed bag. While tests might distribute answers evenly over many questions, banking on this for individual questions is risky. A smarter strategy combines critical thinking (eliminating wrong answers) with foundational knowledge.
Remember: Tests aren’t just about outsmarting the format—they’re designed to measure your English skills. By focusing on learning rather than shortcuts, you’ll not only perform better but also gain confidence in real-world language use.
So next time you face a tricky multiple-choice question, take a breath, trust your preparation, and tackle it step by step. The right answer isn’t always in the middle—it’s wherever your skills lead you.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Curious Case of the “Average” Option in English Tests: What You Need to Know