“Can’t Be the Only One That…”: Why We All Feel This Way (And What It Means)
We’ve all been there. You’re scrolling through social media, watching a movie, or even chatting with friends, and a thought suddenly hits you: “I can’t be the only one that feels this way.” Maybe it’s a quirky habit, an irrational fear, or a guilty pleasure you’ve never admitted aloud. The uncertainty gnaws at you—Am I weird? Does anyone else get this?
Turns out, you’re far from alone. In fact, the feeling of being “the only one” is one of the most universal experiences humans share. Let’s unpack why this happens, why it matters, and how embracing these moments can actually connect us more deeply to others.
—
The Paradox of Feeling Unique (But Not Wanting to Be)
Humans are wired to crave belonging. From an evolutionary standpoint, fitting into a group was essential for survival. But we also want to feel special—to believe our thoughts, talents, or struggles set us apart in meaningful ways. This tension creates a funny contradiction: We fear being “too different,” yet we’re terrified of being utterly ordinary.
Take something as simple as laughing at a meme no one else finds funny. Your brain might cycle through: “This is hilarious… Wait, why isn’t anyone else reacting? Is my sense of humor broken?” Suddenly, a harmless moment becomes a tiny identity crisis.
Psychologists call this “pluralistic ignorance”—when people privately reject a norm but assume others accept it, leading them to stay silent. It’s why students might nod along in class pretending to understand a confusing topic, or why coworkers laugh at a joke they don’t actually find funny. Everyone’s hiding the same doubt: “Can’t be the only one that doesn’t get this… right?”
—
Why We Underestimate How Common Our Experiences Are
Our brains love shortcuts. One mental shortcut, known as the “availability heuristic,” causes us to overestimate how unique our experiences are. If we can’t immediately recall someone sharing our feelings, we assume they’re rare. For example, if you’ve never heard a friend admit to singing made-up songs while doing chores, you might think your shower-concert habit is bizarre. But ask around, and you’ll discover it’s shockingly common.
Another factor? Society often rewards conformity. People tend to share polished, “acceptable” versions of themselves publicly. Social media exacerbates this by showcasing highlight reels—perfect vacations, flawless selfies, and achievements—while hiding messy, relatable moments. This creates a false impression that everyone else has life figured out… except you.
—
The Power of Speaking Your “Can’t Be the Only One” Truths
Here’s the good news: Every time someone dares to voice a “Can’t be the only one…” thought, magic happens. Think of the relief when a friend admits, “I hate small talk too!” or when a celebrity reveals they struggled with impostor syndrome. These moments dissolve isolation and build connection.
Consider the rise of online communities centered around niche interests or challenges. Reddit threads titled “Am I the only one who…” routinely go viral because they tap into shared experiences people assumed were unique. One user might post, “Can’t be the only one who organizes Skittles by color before eating them,” and thousands reply: “I do this with M&Ms!” or “I thought I was a weirdo—thank you!”
These interactions reveal a truth: Our quirks and vulnerabilities are often more relatable than the personas we carefully curate.
—
How to Navigate the “Only One” Feeling in Daily Life
1. Normalize Curiosity
Instead of judging your thoughts, get curious. Ask yourself: “What if lots of people feel this way but just aren’t saying it?” This reframe reduces shame and opens the door to empathy.
2. Test the Waters
Share your “Can’t be the only one…” moment with a trusted person. You might say, “This might sound silly, but does anyone else…” More often than not, the response will be, “Oh my gosh, YES.”
3. Seek Out Stories
Books, podcasts, and documentaries highlighting diverse human experiences remind us that “normal” is a myth. For instance, memoirs like Quiet by Susan Cain (about introversion) or Hyperbole and a Half by Allie Brosh (on mental health) help readers realize their struggles aren’t solitary.
4. Embrace the “Cringe”
Many “weird” habits—like talking to pets in a baby voice or rewatching the same comfort movie 20 times—are harmless joys. Lean into them! As writer Anaïs Nin said, “We don’t see things as they are; we see them as we are.” Your quirks make you you.
—
When “Can’t Be the Only One” Signals Something Deeper
While most “Am I the only one?” moments are lighthearted, sometimes they point to deeper needs. If you consistently feel isolated in your beliefs, values, or emotional struggles, it might signal a lack of supportive community. For example, someone questioning their career path in a family of doctors might think, “Can’t be the only one who doesn’t want this life.”
In these cases, seeking out like-minded groups—whether online or locally—can be transformative. Platforms like Meetup, niche forums, or even hobby-based classes help people find their “tribe.”
—
Final Thought: You’re Part of a Bigger Story
The phrase “Can’t be the only one that…” isn’t just a doubt—it’s an invitation. It challenges us to look beyond surface-level interactions and dig into the rich, messy reality of being human. Every time you wonder if others share your experience, remember: For every unspoken thought, there’s someone else thinking it too.
So go ahead—ask the question, share the story, or laugh at the weird meme. You might just discover how beautifully un-alone you really are.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » “Can’t Be the Only One That…”: Why We All Feel This Way (And What It Means)