Why Girls’ Extracurricular Choices Make Adults Uncomfortable—And Why That Needs to Change
When 13-year-old Mia signed up for her school’s robotics club, her dad joked, “Isn’t that for boys?” Meanwhile, her classmate Emma quit soccer to join cheerleading, prompting her aunt to ask, “Why not stick to something less… girly?” These reactions aren’t rare. Across playgrounds, classrooms, and family dinners, adults often cringe, judge, or outright oppose the extracurricular activities girls choose. But why does a teenager’s after-school hobby trigger such visceral discomfort? And what does this say about society’s unresolved hang-ups about gender, ambition, and authenticity?
The Unspoken Rules of “Appropriate” Interests
From ballet to coding clubs, girls’ extracurriculars are scrutinized through a lens of outdated expectations. Activities perceived as traditionally feminine—cheerleading, dance, or baking clubs—are dismissed as frivolous or “shallow.” Meanwhile, girls who gravitate toward male-dominated fields like STEM or sports face skepticism (“Are you sure you’ll fit in?”) or even mockery (“Trying too hard to be special?”).
This discomfort reveals a lose-lose dynamic: Society polices girls for embracing femininity and penalizes them for rejecting it. Take the backlash against “girly” interests: When girls enjoy makeup tutorials or fashion design, adults often frame these hobbies as vain or anti-feminist. But when girls avoid “girly” activities to pursue physics competitions or debate teams, they’re accused of being “not like other girls”—a backhanded compliment that pits them against their peers.
The problem isn’t the activities themselves. It’s the baggage adults project onto them.
Why “Grossed Out” Reactions Matter
When adults recoil at girls’ choices, they send subtle but damaging messages:
1. Your passions are trivial. Dismissing interests like art or cosplay as “silly” undermines girls’ confidence in their own judgment.
2. Your worth depends on others’ approval. Girls learn to filter their choices through the question, “Will this make me look ‘cool’ or ‘smart’?” rather than “Do I enjoy this?”
3. Gender stereotypes still rule. Judging activities as “for boys” or “for girls” reinforces archaic divides, limiting kids’ exploration.
These messages don’t just hurt feelings—they shape life trajectories. Research shows girls are less likely to pursue careers in fields stereotyped as masculine if they internalize early judgments about their “place” in hobbies. Conversely, girls pressured to avoid “girly” interests often struggle with authenticity, feeling forced to perform interests they don’t genuinely enjoy.
Breaking the Cycle: Let Girls Be Messy, Curious, and Human
The solution isn’t to push girls toward “better” activities but to dismantle the biases that make adults uncomfortable in the first place. Here’s how:
1. Separate Activities from Stereotypes
A robotics club isn’t inherently “masculine”—it’s a space for problem-solving. A dance class isn’t “shallow”—it’s an art form requiring discipline and creativity. Adults need to reframe hobbies as neutral ground for skill-building, not gender performance.
2. Celebrate Hybrid Interests
Why can’t a girl love both makeup chemistry and coding? Hybrid interests—like starting a YouTube channel about science experiments or designing sportswear—are where innovation thrives. Encourage girls to blend passions instead of forcing them into boxes.
3. Expose Them to Role Models Who Defy Labels
Girls benefit from seeing women who’ve succeeded in “non-traditional” fields and those who’ve excelled in feminine-coded spaces. Highlight CEOs who sew their own clothes, engineers who compete in ballroom dancing, or athletes who write poetry. Normalize multidimensionality.
4. Call Out Subtle Shaming—Even Your Own
When a relative scoffs, “Cheerleading? Really?”, step in. Say, “She’s learning teamwork and athleticism—what’s not to love?” Likewise, check your own reactions. If your daughter’s hobby makes you uneasy, ask yourself: Is this about her happiness… or my insecurities?
The Bigger Picture: Trust Girls to Write Their Own Stories
The discomfort surrounding girls’ extracurriculars isn’t really about the activities. It’s about fear—fear that girls might outgrow societal scripts, fear that their choices challenge our nostalgia for “simpler” gender roles, fear that we can’t control their futures.
But here’s the truth: Girls aren’t gross. Their hobbies aren’t gross. What’s gross is a world that still polices their interests, their bodies, and their potential based on century-old stereotypes.
So let’s retire the cringes, eye-rolls, and backhanded compliments. Let’s create spaces where a girl can build a robot and bedazzle its exterior, where she can score a touchdown and choreograph a dance routine—without apologizing for any of it. After all, the goal isn’t to make girls “less gross” to adults. It’s to make adults less gross about girls.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Girls’ Extracurricular Choices Make Adults Uncomfortable—And Why That Needs to Change