“Unreasonable or Am I Tripping?” – How to Tell When Your Gut Feeling Is Right
We’ve all been there. You’re in the middle of a conversation, a workplace meeting, or even a casual hangout, and someone says or does something that makes you pause. Your brain starts racing: “Was that comment out of line? Is their reaction way over the top? Or… am I just overreacting?” The tug-of-war between doubting others and doubting yourself can feel exhausting. So how do you figure out whether someone’s behavior is truly unreasonable, or if your own perspective is skewed? Let’s unpack this mental dilemma.
The Fine Line Between “Unreasonable” and “Overthinking”
Humans are social creatures wired to seek harmony. This means we often second-guess our instincts to avoid conflict or preserve relationships. But this instinct can backfire when we ignore red flags. For example, imagine a friend cancels plans last-minute for the third time in a row. You feel hurt, but they brush it off with a vague excuse. Part of you thinks, “This isn’t cool,” while another part whispers, “Maybe I’m being too demanding.”
Here’s the thing: Context matters. If someone repeatedly dismisses your feelings, breaks promises without accountability, or reacts aggressively to simple requests, those are signs of unreasonable behavior. On the flip side, if you’re constantly questioning yourself in multiple relationships or situations, it might signal anxiety or self-doubt creeping in. The key is to spot patterns. Does the behavior happen only with one person, or does it feel like everyone is “acting weird”? The former suggests an external issue; the latter might mean it’s time to check in with yourself.
Why We Gaslight Ourselves
Self-gaslighting—downplaying your own feelings to avoid discomfort—is more common than you’d think. Say a coworker takes credit for your idea during a meeting. You want to speak up, but fear being labeled “difficult.” Instead, you wonder, “Maybe I didn’t communicate clearly enough. Am I tripping?” This internal conflict often stems from societal conditioning. Many of us are taught to prioritize politeness over honesty, especially in professional or family settings.
Mental health experts point out that self-gaslighting can also arise from past experiences. If you’ve been told your emotions are “too much” or “dramatic,” you might unconsciously adopt that narrative. Over time, this erodes trust in your own judgment. Think of it like a muscle: If you don’t exercise self-validation, it weakens.
How to Spot Unreasonable Behavior (Without Losing Your Mind)
1. Use the “Friend Test”
Imagine the situation happening to someone you care about. Would you tell them they’re overreacting, or would you support their concerns? If it’s the latter, grant yourself the same compassion.
2. Look for Consistency
Unreasonable behavior often lacks logic. For instance, if someone praises your work one day and harshly criticizes it the next—without clear reasons—it’s worth questioning their motives. Healthy interactions have a baseline of respect, even during disagreements.
3. Notice Physical Reactions
Your body often knows before your brain does. A racing heart, stomach knots, or a lingering sense of dread after an interaction can signal that something’s off. Don’t dismiss these cues as “just stress.”
4. Seek a Second Opinion
Talk to a trusted friend, therapist, or mentor. Describe the situation factually (“Here’s what happened; here’s how I feel”) and ask for their unbiased take. Sometimes, an outside perspective clarifies whether the issue is them, you, or a mix of both.
When It’s You: Navigating Self-Doubt
What if you realize you’re the one spiraling? Maybe you’re hyper-sensitive to criticism after a tough week, or past trauma is coloring your reactions. That’s okay—self-awareness is the first step. Try these strategies:
– Journal It Out
Write down the situation, your emotions, and any evidence for/against your reaction. Seeing thoughts on paper can reveal irrational patterns.
– Practice the “Pause”
When emotions run high, buy yourself time. Say, “I need to think about this,” instead of reacting immediately. Often, clarity comes with space.
– Challenge All-or-Nothing Thinking
Thoughts like “They always do this!” or “I’m never taken seriously!” are usually exaggerations. Replace them with specific examples: “They interrupted me twice today,” not “They never listen.”
The Gray Area: When Both Sides Have a Point
Sometimes, nobody’s fully “right” or “wrong.” Let’s say you and your partner argue about chores. You think they’re not pulling their weight; they accuse you of micromanaging. In such cases, focus on solutions, not blame. Use “I” statements: “I feel overwhelmed when I handle most chores alone. Can we discuss a fairer split?” This shifts the conversation from “Who’s unreasonable?” to “How can we fix this?”
Trust Yourself (But Stay Open)
Learning to distinguish between genuine red flags and personal triggers takes practice. It’s okay to make mistakes—apologize if you overreact, but also set boundaries if someone crosses a line. Over time, you’ll build confidence in your judgment while staying open to growth.
Life’s too short to spend it wondering, “Am I tripping?” By tuning into your intuition and staying curious about others’ perspectives, you’ll navigate conflicts with more clarity and less self-doubt. After all, the goal isn’t to be “right” every time—it’s to build relationships (and a mindset) that feel balanced and authentic.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » “Unreasonable or Am I Tripping