When Prestigious Degrees Come with Hidden Costs: The Silent Struggle of Unresolved University Refunds
For thousands of students across India, gaining admission to a premier institution like an Indian Institute of Information Technology (IIIT) is a dream come true. These institutes are synonymous with academic excellence, cutting-edge research, and promising career opportunities. But what happens when the institution itself fails to uphold its end of the bargain? A growing number of alumni are speaking out about unresolved financial disputes—specifically, refunds they were promised years ago but never received. Worse yet, many claim their alma maters are now ignoring their attempts to seek answers.
The Promise vs. Reality of Institutional Accountability
Most students and parents assume that reputable institutions operate with transparency, especially when it comes to finances. Fees are paid upfront, hostel deposits are collected, and occasional administrative charges are incurred during the academic journey. In many cases, students are assured that certain fees—like caution deposits or unused hostel charges—will be refunded upon graduation.
But for some IIIT graduates, this promise has turned into a frustrating waiting game. Take the example of Rohan Sharma (name changed), a 2019 graduate from a top IIIT. During his final semester, he was told that his ₹50,000 caution deposit—meant to cover potential damages to lab equipment—would be returned within six months of graduation. Four years later, Rohan is still waiting. His emails to the institute’s accounts department go unanswered, and calls to administrative offices are met with vague assurances like “processes are delayed” or “we’re looking into it.”
Rohan’s story isn’t unique. Online forums and alumni groups reveal similar grievances: incomplete refunds, missing documentation, and a lack of clear communication from institutes. One graduate even shared screenshots of a decade-old email thread with her IIIT’s finance team, highlighting how requests were repeatedly deferred until the thread eventually went cold.
Why Are Refunds Stalled—or Ignored Altogether?
The reasons behind these delays vary. Some institutes cite bureaucratic hurdles, claiming that refunds require approvals from multiple departments or government bodies. Others blame outdated accounting systems or staffing shortages. However, critics argue that these explanations often mask deeper issues, such as mismanagement of funds or a lack of accountability.
“Many institutions treat student deposits as interest-free loans,” says Ayesha Kapoor, a legal advisor specializing in education disputes. “They hold onto these funds for years, earning interest, while students struggle to follow up. When pressed, they may stall until graduates give up out of exhaustion.”
Another factor is the power imbalance between students and institutions. Fresh graduates, busy launching their careers, rarely have the time or resources to pursue lengthy legal battles. Institutes, aware of this dynamic, may drag their feet, betting that most students will eventually drop the matter.
The Emotional Toll on Graduates
What starts as a financial inconvenience often evolves into a deeper sense of betrayal. For many students, attending an IIIT represents years of hard work and sacrifice—not just for themselves, but for their families. When the institution they trusted fails to honor basic commitments, it can sour their entire academic experience.
Priya Mehta (name changed), a 2020 graduate, recalls how her IIIT’s refusal to refund ₹35,000 in hostel fees affected her family. “My parents took out a loan to cover my education. That refund was supposed to help repay part of it. Now, it feels like the institute prioritized its own convenience over our financial well-being,” she says.
The lack of communication exacerbates the problem. Automated email replies, unreturned calls, and generic responses leave graduates feeling dismissed. “It’s not just about the money,” says Rohan. “It’s about respect. We contributed to the institute’s reputation—the least they can do is respond to our concerns.”
What Can Affected Graduates Do?
While the situation is undeniably frustrating, graduates aren’t entirely powerless. Here are actionable steps to address unresolved refunds:
1. Document Everything
Gather all relevant records: fee receipts, refund policies, email correspondence, and even screenshots of institute webpages detailing refund timelines. This documentation strengthens your case if you need to escalate the matter.
2. Leverage Alumni Networks
Connect with fellow graduates through LinkedIn groups or alumni associations. Collective complaints carry more weight than individual ones. Some institutes respond faster when multiple stakeholders raise the same issue.
3. File a Formal Grievance
Most IIITs have internal grievance cells or ombudsman offices. Submit a written complaint detailing your case, and request a resolution timeline. If the institute is government-affiliated, consider reaching out to regulatory bodies like the University Grants Commission (UGC).
4. Explore Legal Avenues
For amounts exceeding ₹50,000, consulting a consumer rights lawyer can be worthwhile. The Consumer Protection Act 2019 classifies educational services under its purview, allowing students to file complaints against unfair practices.
5. Use Social Media Strategically
Publicly tagging the institute’s official handles on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) or LinkedIn often prompts a response. However, maintain professionalism—avoid emotional rants and stick to factual updates.
A Call for Systemic Reform
While individual actions matter, systemic change is crucial. Alumni argue that institutes must adopt automated refund systems to minimize delays. Clear, publicly accessible refund policies and dedicated helplines could also rebuild trust.
Additionally, regulatory bodies could enforce stricter audits of institutional finances, ensuring that student funds aren’t misused. Transparency reports detailing how deposits are managed would hold institutes accountable.
Final Thoughts
The unresolved refund issue highlights a gap between the lofty ideals of education and the ground realities of institutional administration. For IIITs and similar institutes, protecting their reputation isn’t just about academic rankings—it’s about demonstrating integrity in every interaction, even after graduation.
To graduates still waiting for closure: persistence is key. By advocating for your rights, you’re not just reclaiming what’s owed—you’re paving the way for a fairer system for future students. After all, a prestigious degree should symbolize trust, not broken promises.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Prestigious Degrees Come with Hidden Costs: The Silent Struggle of Unresolved University Refunds