When Students Struggle: The Shared Responsibility Between Professors and Learners
Walking into a classroom, students carry backpacks, notebooks, and a quiet hope to succeed. But when grades plummet or assignments go unfinished, society often points fingers at the learners: “They didn’t study enough.” “They’re lazy.” “They’re not cut out for this.” While personal accountability matters, there’s an uncomfortable truth we rarely discuss: educators also play a role in student failures. This isn’t about shifting blame but recognizing that learning is a two-way street. Let’s explore why professors must reflect on their contributions to academic struggles and how collaboration can turn setbacks into growth.
—
The Myth of the “Perfect Student”
The traditional narrative paints professors as infallible experts who deliver knowledge to passive recipients. Students, in this model, are expected to absorb information flawlessly, regardless of teaching style, classroom dynamics, or accessibility. But this mindset ignores a critical reality: no two students learn the same way. A lecture-heavy approach might work for auditory learners but leave visual or hands-on learners disengaged. When professors default to “this is how I’ve always taught,” they risk leaving entire groups behind.
Take Sarah, a biology major who failed her first-year chemistry course. She attended every lecture, took detailed notes, and stayed up late reviewing formulas. But her professor refused to provide practice problems or answer questions outside class, insisting students “figure it out independently.” Sarah’s failure wasn’t due to laziness; it stemmed from a mismatch between her learning needs and the professor’s rigid methods.
—
Where Teaching Styles Fall Short
A professor’s responsibility extends beyond content delivery. It includes creating an environment where students feel supported to ask questions, make mistakes, and seek help. Here are three common gaps where educators inadvertently contribute to student struggles:
1. Outdated Teaching Practices
Many professors cling to decades-old PowerPoint slides or rely on monotonous lectures, ignoring advancements in pedagogical research. Active learning strategies—like group discussions, case studies, or real-world applications—are proven to boost retention. Yet, some educators dismiss these as “trendy” or “time-consuming,” prioritizing convenience over effectiveness.
2. Lack of Communication
Students often hesitate to admit confusion, fearing judgment. When professors don’t proactively check in or offer flexible office hours, struggling learners slip through the cracks. A simple midterm survey asking, “What’s unclear?” could identify issues before they escalate.
3. Unclear Expectations
Vague grading rubrics, inconsistent feedback, or sudden changes in assignment guidelines leave students guessing. Imagine spending weeks on a research paper only to lose points for formatting rules never mentioned in class. Such oversights breed frustration and disengagement.
—
Case Studies: When Accountability Works
Critics argue that holding professors accountable undermines their expertise. But evidence suggests the opposite. Universities that prioritize faculty development see measurable improvements in student outcomes.
– The University of Michigan’s Teaching Academy trains professors in inclusive pedagogy, emphasizing empathy and adaptability. After implementing these workshops, STEM courses saw a 15% drop in failure rates.
– Dr. James Carter, a history professor, noticed his online students were scoring lower on essays. Instead of blaming “poor effort,” he recorded short video feedback explaining common errors and hosted weekly Q&A sessions. Essay grades improved by an average of 20% the following semester.
These examples show that small shifts in teaching practices can create big wins for students.
—
Building Bridges, Not Barriers
So, how can professors foster accountability without sacrificing academic rigor?
1. Adopt a Growth Mindset
Great educators view criticism as a tool for improvement, not an attack. Regularly seeking student feedback—and acting on it—builds trust. As one engineering professor put it: “If half the class bombs an exam, that’s not their failure alone. It’s a sign I need to rethink how I’m explaining concepts.”
2. Normalize Academic Support
Professors should openly discuss resources like tutoring centers, study groups, or mental health services. Normalizing help-seeking reduces stigma and empowers students to advocate for themselves.
3. Design Assessments That Teach
Instead of high-stakes exams that encourage cramming, consider low-stakes quizzes, peer reviews, or project-based assignments. These methods reduce anxiety and reinforce learning incrementally.
—
Students Aren’t Off the Hook
To be clear, this isn’t a free pass for learners to neglect their responsibilities. Attending class, meeting deadlines, and seeking help when stuck are non-negotiables. However, professors must ask themselves: “Am I equipping students with the tools to meet these expectations?”
A medical student once shared, “I failed my anatomy exam because I didn’t understand the lab instructions. When I asked the professor for clarity, he said, ‘You should’ve paid attention.’ But I was paying attention—the instructions were contradictory.” Situations like this reveal a systemic issue: education is a partnership.
—
Moving Forward Together
The debate isn’t about “students vs. professors.” It’s about acknowledging that both parties influence academic outcomes. Schools must invest in ongoing teacher training, and professors must embrace adaptability. Meanwhile, students should communicate their needs early and often.
At its core, education isn’t just about transferring knowledge. It’s about nurturing curiosity, resilience, and critical thinking. When professors step into their role as mentors—not just instructors—they don’t just teach subject matter. They teach students how to succeed.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Students Struggle: The Shared Responsibility Between Professors and Learners